Collaboration requires work, investment and skill. An interview with Laimdota Straujuma, Chair of the Council of the Latvia University of Life Sciences and Technologies (LBTU) - Zeme un valsts

Collaboration requires work, investment and skill. An interview with Laimdota Straujuma, Chair of the Council of the Latvia University of Life Sciences and Technologies (LBTU)

Last year, the Latvia University of Agriculture received a new name, becoming the Latvia University of Life Sciences and Technologies (LBTU). A university council was established. In the context of Latvian higher education, we also often hear that tiresome word “reform”, which still sounds both beautiful and hollow to us. The LBTU Council has a lot of work and far-reaching plans; this time, about the immediate ones.

Before we begin talking about educational issues, I wanted to hear your thoughts on a problem that has been highlighted recently – the lack of a broader vision among the government as a team and the head of government. Criticism of this has been voiced for some time and quite often, pointing out that government work is often only stimulated by external factors (C19, war, EU and EC decisions).

I wouldn't want to agree with that. Latvia has had several National Development Plans, and there is the “Latvia 2030” strategy, developed under the leadership of Roberts Ķīlis and approved by the Saeima in 2010. The idea of Latvia as a smart country runs through these documents. Yes, Estonia has overtaken us in the IT sphere, but in my opinion, we need to move towards Latvia as a smart state. Why? Our resources are what they are, and there are only so many; people – there are only so many; and looking at it reasonably, we will not have other opportunities in the near future. We can move further and promote the development of the state and society only with our own intellectual potential, which needs to be utilised. Latvia as a smart country with excellent education and broad human knowledge. This needs to be agreed upon and implemented.

Education and medicine are the sectors in independent Latvia where the word “reform” is mentioned with very rare interruptions. Development and reform are not always one and the same. Does a process that often seems continuous interfere with the most important things – the work itself (treatment, investigation, schooling, knowledge acquisition, etc.)?

Talking “about something”, for the most part, always interferes. We at the Latvia University of Life Sciences and Technologies (LBTU) have braced ourselves for reforms, and we will accomplish them! I very much hope that the LBTU Council will accept the plan. I agree with the point raised in the question: if reforms drag on for a long time and things are “cut or sliced” into small pieces, the process is disruptive and, as you mentioned, practically continuous.

It is understood that, when speaking about reforms, you meant the merging of LBTU faculties.

Exactly! That must be done, because currently eight people are managing small structural units. Some of the current managers can do more useful work; having four faculties managed by four people would be the first, most visible and productive result. The rest will have the opportunity to turn their attention to scientific work. If we look at other research universities, we at LBTU have the smallest faculties in terms of student numbers, both in Latvia and in the Baltics and Europe. Each person can do more...

Yes, I have received letters and emails stating that such a council decision has not been discussed or properly calculated. The point of the letters is the same – delay it, for now, reconsider!

We cannot delay, because the prolonged postponement (non-resolution) of an important issue and indecision will bother everyone for long enough. What must be done, must be done! I understand very well that it will be unpleasant for some; I will have to speak with people, but... if a reform is necessary, it must be carried out quickly. We finish it, we sort it out, and we move on! The decision must be made very soon; the new system must start working in September 20231.

LBTU Rector Prof. Irina Pilvere submitted the current LBTU structure to the council with explanations. From that, it is clearly visible that many institutions within the university are quite fragmented. What good and brilliant things can an institute of two or three people achieve? Who can you compete with in your work?

Why, for example, is the work of the Latvian State Forest Research Institute “Silava” very successful? They know what they want and clearly see where they are going! Furthermore, “Silava” does not want to be with LBTU so much, which, in turn, the university has very much desired...

Do you want “Silava” as an LBTU structural unit or component?

Yes, but I will not initiate this idea a second time! At the time when I was Minister of Agriculture (2011–2014), the management of “Silava” explained to me that the inclusion of the institute in LLU is possible if the LLU Faculty of Forest becomes stronger – in terms of teaching staff, science and infrastructure. Well, for some time now the faculty has had a new, energetic dean, Prof. Linards Sisenis, and I see that in recent years it has “gone up” a lot and successfully.

I will add that the forest industry is one that I can applaud and only congratulate – what personalities have worked and continue to work in it!

The Latvian State Forest Research Institute “Silava” combines both scientific work and industry tribunes, where the institute’s independence is very important.

Independence is an important thing, but in many respects it is also determined by finances. It sounds contradictory, but it is so! Speaking of bureaucratic requirements and burdens, I will emphasize that this has been a very acute and pressing issue for the entire time I have worked in public administration. Bureaucracy has excellent abilities and a tendency for self-preservation. I am personally against excessive requirements and demands for documentation, but the bureaucracy, in order to protect itself (from something that “could be, happen, or occur”), embeds additional requirements into documents.

After reading what you just said, there will be people who say: “Ha! You have worked in public administration for quite a long time – what did you do to reduce bureaucracy? Where are the visible results?”

I know, I know very well; I have heard such questions! In the LBTU Council, I have determined that if something must be requested, it must not be requested more than is necessary! There has been a lot of talk about this, but... I truly do not know how to fight it. I don’t know!

Back in the day, I have looked at and read, for example, the documents of the Veterinary Department of the Ministry of Agriculture – control upon control, we went, searched, tried to solve it. I repeat – I don't know how to fight it; it is like a snowball rolling down a high mountain, getting bigger as it goes.

The experience of Great Britain still seems interesting and feasible to me, namely, that at one time ministry employees had the opportunity to work in business for a while.

When you have worked “behind the ministry door” for a certain time and you see and feel the consequences of what you yourself invented and how it works, or – quite the opposite – hinders operation, the feelings are different. Quite a long time ago, back in the late 90s, I spoke with the then head of the State Chancellery, Gunta Veismane, that such an experiment should be implemented in Latvia as well. The idea is very good indeed; the difficulty will be in its practical implementation.

Since the late 90s, a lot has changed in Latvia; would Latvian entrepreneurs be so willing to see officials in their companies or in the ranks of their employees...

I agree, they won’t take them! Back then, we started “moving” this idea just a little bit, but... One – a series of legislative acts hindered it, two – we needed people who truly wanted it, three – the difference in salaries.

Could one of the reasons for stagnation be the political interests of officials? People vote for a specific political force, understanding that they are voting for their own workplace.

I do not agree that officials would vote for the political force that might preserve their jobs. Perhaps something in the way of thinking has remained from Soviet times, but control here is excessive. People who know me know that I am not a supporter of this type of control, but... I will again self-critically emphasize that, knowing the problem, I have not managed to deal with it.

Returning to LBTU – the nearest task will be the merging of faculties. The university has another magnificent and quite heavy symbol – the Jelgava Palace. Are you thinking about its future?

Step by step, we are tidying up the palace. As much money comes in, we invest. There are no other thoughts about the future of the palace – it must be preserved. Recently in January, we reviewed and examined all current LBTU properties, concluding that there are not few of them and there are some that the university does not need. Future actions will be appropriate for the respective situation (various) – some properties we will sell at auction, some we will transfer to the state, some we will manage or handle otherwise. For example, renovation work is currently underway at Malnava College, with investments from the Ministry of Agriculture.

Malnava College is a good example. How do you assess the Latgale region – on one hand, many (not locals) whine about it, on the other – near Rēzekne, the company “Verems” is successfully operating, and Daugavpils University is having good success.

Malnava College is necessary, there is no question about it! In Latgale, there are enough places where work is progressing; there are entrepreneurs who are very active and successfully operating. If a person is in their place, a model company and a model landscape will emerge and exist there. And for that, Malnava College is also needed, where everything is moving forward, which is a joy.

Back then, also in a conversation with zemeunvalsts.lv2, Daugavpils University Rector Prof. Irēna Kokina talked about a higher education consortium – Daugavpils, Jelgava, Liepāja. The idea sparked, the city leadership also got involved, and... silence. It was said that this initiative had been killed off by the Ministry of Education and Science. Current talks about Daugavpils University raise concerns that Riga will “swallow” DU...

Less than a year ago (May 2022), I expressed the thought that around Jelgava, one strong regional research university could be formed (consolidated) – Jelgava would be at the center. Namely, all universities outside of Riga would merge to be a counterweight to Riga and the three large research universities of the capital. I even managed to express this idea to the State President, but... yes, it was “buried” quite quickly. The management of Liepāja University and also Rēzekne Academy of Technologies chose Riga. I spoke with Andris Grafs, the Chair of the Council of Liepāja University, who for a short moment even thought about it, but...

It is clear that Riga is doing its own thing. In Latvia, a typology of higher education institutions has been created; in Jelgava (LBTU) there is a research university. The status of a research university is important to us; it also means funding. Riga universities are larger and stronger in terms of student numbers; that is objective.

Jelgava is more practical, closer to the ground; Riga is noisier, more urban and closer to the government.

If we look at world trends – the Green Deal, climate change, moving away from fossil resources, food sufficiency and security, efficient use of natural resources – all this is directly related to LBTU.

For example, also the Dobele Horticultural Institute with successful fruit growing and breeding...

Exactly – Latvia is capable of growing and exporting food and forest industry products; these future directions must be located at a research university; we have both a practical and logical basis and a duty – to exist!

About the word “practical”. Last summer, talking with the owners of Oleru Manor3, in the conversation we touched upon the lack of people carrying out practical work, for example, in woodworking. Could Malnava or Ogres technical schools help solve this issue?

In cooperation with the Faculty of Forest, they want to start training woodworking specialists at Malnava College. Ogres technical school is also very important to the industry.

Looking at the recent study conducted by the Ministry of Economy, we see that there is a shortage of specialists, direct workers, in agriculture, forestry, and elsewhere as well. I will add – preparing practical workers does not really “fit” a research university, but, truth be told, there is a lack of good professionals in many places.

Looking at and evaluating the statistics, LLU (LBTU) graduates have some of the best salaries. The question, however, is different – what interests young people at the moment. I am also not a good example – I know perfectly well what specialities are needed in Latvia, but my grandchildren have drifted into that study stream that interests others – economics and commercial sciences. Yes, parents can talk and tell, but... What will so many graduates of economics and social sciences do in the future?

If we look at what happens during the admission time in Latvian higher education institutions – in technical specialities both at RTU and other universities, a portion of budget places remain unfilled; it is similar at LBTU (in technical specialities). However, elsewhere – in economics, commercial studies, psychology, communication specialities – there is still competition, even though such specialists have been prepared in sufficient numbers in Latvia.

After long conversations, also involving the mass media, competition has appeared in the field of IT studies, which is a small step forward. This is an important duty of mine and yours, and of all information disseminators – to talk, explain, encourage and spur young people to study what is necessary.

I allow that one of the reasons for the name change of the Latvia University of Agriculture was also the realization that young people are not currently enticed by the word “agriculture”.

If we are talking about reforms, we must not forget schools, which has been an actual issue for years. The most important thing is that supporters of a certain style of reform – “few students, let's close them” – do not think further – if the school closes...

...everything disappears...

Exactly! Industry colleagues who some time ago in various ways supported the Vītoli school near the Russian border still mention the closing of the school as a very bad and shortsighted action. A Latvian school a few kilometres from the Russian border. Entrepreneurs were ready to support the school financially, but despite the proposal, they closed the school – now neither the school nor the village. When estimating and skimping on and around the education budget, is the question of regional and populated areas taken into account? What regional development could we be talking about? How, in your opinion, would it be right and farsighted to act?

The situation mentioned in the question must be taken into account. Back in the day, while working at the Ministry of Agriculture, we thought a lot about this. For example, the Ozoli school in Limbaži municipality has been closed for some time now. At the time, being at this school, I felt keenly – if there is no school, there will be no village.

What is also important – maintaining small schools costs money, and quite a lot. Finding a compromise and a reasonable solution is a great art and an important skill. So that people do not disappear, children are transported and schooled, and the village or the area develops...

The merging of LBTU faculties is also a saving. Why, for example, couldn't four schools have one director?

Back in the day, on this exact issue, I met with all the then municipal leaders who came to Riga to talk about schools. There are bad examples – in a school in the Latgale region there are 10 students, as many employees, but... the municipal leader did not want to liquidate the school because “the municipality considers it important”. This is also not a solution!

But – I will repeat – weighing, understanding and thinking about the future is a very important skill. Local centers must be preserved; I know that Baltinava is fighting, and quite successfully.

What does your experience say, is it easier to deal with the optimization-lust of ministries? For example, the plan for university optimization – if Liepāja University does not want to merge or cooperate, “roll the dice” together with Daugavpils colleagues, who are very strong in life sciences.

That could be done... Some time ago, I expressed this idea to the LBTU Council and started working. Rēzekne refused our cooperation, financial problems started in Daugavpils, and the Liepāja University Council voted against it. I think Daugavpils is worth thinking about.

What other important things have you decided on in the LBTU Council?

The LBTU strategy has been adopted, on which both the university and the council worked. The strategy contains what we must strive for, what must be – LBTU as the life sciences center of Latvia and the Baltic Sea, the research university status must be preserved. Speaking of the latter, it will not be easy because... the money that is intended for and due to research universities is, understandably, easier to divide into two or three parts, not four. LBTU is a research university, but the path to maintaining this status will be more difficult and work-demanding.

In the context of Latvian higher education institutions, one often mentions the nearby University of Tartu, whose prestige and financial situation are significantly better.

If a higher education institution enters the top 500 universities, both entrepreneurs and various European institutions etc. turn their attention to it. LBTU also does not survive on state funding alone; there are various funds, etc. What I think is important is that the work of the international cooperation center at the university must be drastically improved. We have good cooperation with Uzbekistan; I recently visited Azerbaijan, which is very interested in cooperation with a European Union state university. For example, the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine has the opportunity to invite students from abroad because in some European countries there are restrictions on learning the profession. And – it must be remembered – it is not only cooperation, but also money flowing from European funds.

LBTU Council representatives met with farmers' public organizations on March 17; soon there will also be a meeting with NGOs of the forest and fisheries sectors. It is very important for the university to know what industry specialists specifically want from it.

Besides Malnava College, listening to LBTU’s further plans, could there be a thought about taking another secondary vocational educational institution under one's wing?

We had a thought about Kandava Technical School; last year a council decision was made, but the Ministry of Education and Science did not support it. The school itself “wanted” us, and the Ministry of Agriculture agreed as well. Of course, every such “taking under the wing” is also a financial matter.

About cooperation. Years pass, but the ministries supervise each one their own little field, without seeing more broadly, that is how they supervise. The reason is often sought in the differences of the parties that are responsible for each ministry.

I don't see the problem in partisanship, but in responsibility, yes. Namely – “I have my own field, I tend it, that is my responsibility”. And then there is “someone's” field, which is tended by “someone else”... Do I really have to take on something else? ... Why are you poking around in my sphere of responsibility?

Collaboration is a great word that requires work, investment and the skill already mentioned in our conversation.

1. On March 17, 2023, the LBTU Council meeting supported the 5-faculty model proposed by the Rector and approved by the Senate.
2. https://www.zemeunvalsts.lv/musu-valstij-esam-vajadzigi-
3. https://www.zemeunvalsts.lv/-lai-galva-strada-lai-rokas-zina-daramo-lai-galva-neskrien-pa-prieksu-rokam-un-otradi

Add a comment