Petteri Orpo, chair of the National Coalition Party (The National Coalition Party (NCP), Kansallinen Kokoomus) in the Finnish Parliament, has questioned the reaction of decision-makers to the widely discussed carbon sink calculations* performed by the Natural Resources Institute Finland (Luke), reports Helsingin Sanomat. These calculations indicate that Finnish forests are failing to sequester as much carbon dioxide from the atmosphere as they used to.
On 11 January, P. Orpo stated that the excessively volatile calculations have surprised more than just him. “In my opinion, it is completely incomprehensible that carbon sink calculations can differ so much. And then people try to act hastily and suddenly start drawing conclusions. That is not how it should happen,” he explained during an election debate hosted by Maaseudun Tulevaisuus (a newspaper in Finland) and the Central Union of Agricultural Producers and Forest Owners (MTK). “We need to find a solid foundation for how carbon sinks are determined and how they are calculated, so that there is a clear understanding of what is justified and what is not,” he added.
In December, the Natural Resources Institute Finland published calculations confirming that in 2021, Finland’s land-use sector shifted from being a carbon sink to an emissions source. The institute attributes this unexpected and unprecedented turn of events to slowing forest growth—particularly in pine forests—and intensified logging.
P. Orpo stressed that “it is clearly possible to improve the situation,” particularly by focusing on the reasons behind the decline in forest growth. It is necessary to look after both the well-being of forests and the competitiveness of Finland’s timber industry.
His view was echoed by Centre Party chair Annika Saarikko (Annika Saarikko) and Christian Democrats chair Sari Essayah (Sari Essayah). However, A. Saarikko noted that she does not doubt the research conducted by the Natural Resources Institute Finland. “The fact that we have fixated on carbon sink calculations for just one year distorts the whole issue,” Sari Essayah said, assessing the situation.
Hanna Holopainen (Greens) and Left Alliance chair Li Andersson, by contrast, emphasized that given the importance of carbon sinks in national climate policy, it is important to respond to the fact that the forests' capacity to absorb carbon dioxide is decreasing.
“The carbon sink calculations performed by the Natural Resources Institute [...] were carried out on a sound scientific basis, and they should be taken seriously in Finland,” noted Li Andersson.
Both the Green League and the Left Alliance have called for a system where forest owners would receive compensation for efforts to increase carbon sequestration. On Tuesday, VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland published estimates suggesting that by offering financial compensation for such efforts, forest owners' income would increase two or threefold, though this would be detrimental to the pulp industry. The compensation amount was calculated based on emission allowance prices.
“The transfer of income to forest owners would be massive,” Helsingin Sanomat was told by Jyrki Raitila, a senior scientist at VTT who led the project.
The newspaper reports that such a system would completely change the concept of forest ownership, because at current emission allowance prices, forest owners would accumulate significantly more from carbon dioxide absorption than from logging. Regeneration felling would likely happen later, as owners would have an incentive to let forests grow for as long as possible to avoid interrupting the steady stream of income.
* zemeunvalsts.lv reported on this previously:
https://www.zemeunvalsts.lv/plasa-meroga-mezizstrade-un-leni-augosas-priedes-apgrutina-somijas-centienus-sasniegt-es-klimata-merkus



