There can be differing views on what is considered a prosperous society, or what one actually is. “That’s enough”, “it suffices” or “I want more” is a very personal matter, but... what and how to do (and not do) to ensure there is enough for so many people is a topic worth a broader discussion.
During the pandemic, rhetoric and activities directed against farmers intensified. Why such a “convenient moment” for both justified and unjustified criticism?
I certainly do not see a connection between the activities against farmers and the pandemic; it is just a coincidence. The movement for a greener lifestyle and a smaller human environmental footprint had already begun moving quite rapidly even before the pandemic. I suspect a large portion of the people who think about or are concerned about these specific issues work in well-paid positions. These people had a rather long period of lockdown and remote work, when there was both the opportunity and the time to express and activate their social desires.
I will emphasise: we should be happy, that in Latvia it is possible to hold and discussions are taking place about production (what to produce and how), about choices (vegetarianism, veganism, raw foodism, meat-eating), about farming practices (where and why to keep chickens), etc. Why? Such a discussion indicates that we live in a prosperous society that is already beginning to get a little bit spoiled in the face of its own desires. For example, in countries where there is food scarcity or other serious problems, such discussions do not exist. I recently gave lectures to students from Nigeria, talking about market trends in Latvia. I mentioned that soon we will produce tuna from peas (vegan), and I showed a video prepared by the relevant entrepreneur. In the middle of the film, I was asked: “What does vegetarian mean, and what is a vegan?” By the end of the film, one student concluded that he didn’t know any vegans or vegetarians in his own country, and wondered: “If we have both tuna and peas available in Latvia, and both are healthy and tasty – why can't you eat both tuna and peas, instead of needing peas that taste like tuna.” Now that is a good example of the difference in thinking!

A sensible question!
Indeed! In this regard, I remember a trip to Cambodia. At night, while travelling along the river, we saw illuminated fields. Why? Insects are being caught, we are told. We, in the boat, reasoned that they could be local organic farmers because they were trapping pests from the field. Of course, that is a conclusion based on our – European – understanding. The next day, we were shown the insect trap up close, which consisted of a lamp, a plastic sheet and a bowl of water. The insect flies towards the light, hits the sheet and falls into the water. At the end of the conversation, we found out that they weren't catching insects to protect the rice field, but were using them for food. Being a “well-fed European”, I asked: “Are they tasty?” The Cambodian farmer didn't really understand my question, replying: “It is pure protein.”
I felt ashamed! In Europe, eating is one of life's pleasures, and we think about food differently. In Cambodia, people think completely differently. If we are well-fed and prosperous, we must think about ourselves, about the environment and about the rest of society. I think that every intelligent person understands the current “green” issues: that the human footprint should be as small as possible. If Europe has announced its climate neutrality goals, it must be reminded that the UN goal still stands: it is necessary to feed the planet's population. Both of these goals cannot be considered identical! So...
At one time, Ukraine was called the breadbasket of a great country; in Latvia, that name is often given to Zemgale. Is it necessary to determine where what should be grown?
No! Not everywhere do climatic conditions allow for the growing of crops useful for food. Of course, in some influential country or international organisation, sitting in an office, one could politically erroneously decide: let's grow this here, and another crop elsewhere, etc. If such decisions appear, they will undoubtedly resemble the system we so desperately wanted to get rid of at the turn of the 80s and 90s.
Even in the 21st century, more than one decision looks as if it was plucked from past experience...
It does look a bit like that! Speaking of Latvia, I think a serious problem lies in the fact that the country is run by people who have no understanding of the Soviet era. The President and the Prime Minister are effectively foreigners. They do not understand the weakness of a regulated economy. Yes, the Prime Minister does not understand what a large portion of Latvia's population knows! “But we want what's best!” I even 100% believe that the Prime Minister's thoughts on a regulated economy are well-intentioned, but... When we loudly pride ourselves on the fact that people who know nothing about the bygone era are coming into government, I would rate that as a disadvantage. Why? Any experience is a great advantage, if one knows how to use it! I will emphasise: if one knows how to use it!
It is important to remember that the order of many things is determined by a person, not their hair colour, gender, religious or political affiliation, etc. The Prime Minister has neither the experience nor the understanding of what a regulated economy leads to. Yes, there is currently an attempt to create something like that; we can see it clearly: there are enough disagreements of various kinds in the world in this regard – what, for example, the USA, Australia and France are arguing about. About the attempt to divide and dictate who will do or produce what and how. Despite major flaws, democracy and the market economy are and remain the best social systems, because there is nothing better (at least for now)! For comparison, the vaccine against Covid is not exactly something exceptionally healthy, but... there is nothing better at the moment! We take the best that is available.
Comparing this to the economy: if we in Latvia are told that we must do this and that, and nothing more, while another EU or world country does something else, etc., what will happen in the event that we argue with someone or some group or are unable to get along? If a situation happens like the one we recently experienced: cargo flows stop and what we need cannot be delivered to us... What happens in such a case? ... I think the most correct thing is for everyone to do what they are best at, where there is the best knowledge and suitable climatic conditions. Speaking of agriculture, I saw a good example in Argentina: soybeans and wheat grow in the fields, and cattle graze under a bridge, often up to their bellies in water. Someone here would certainly be worried about the welfare of the animals...
... the herd probably walked into the river by itself...
I agree, but I mean something else – in Argentina, in soils where wheat grows well, they do not engage in livestock farming. There is another reason for this too – in Argentina, there is no state support for agriculture; after the financial crisis, farmers were relatively the only rich people in the country, because they had grain in their barns, meat in their cellars, etc. At that time, in that country, the food industry was not given subsidies, but an export tax was introduced – if you want to export wheat, pay for that opportunity. It would never occur to a farmer in Argentina to engage in livestock farming on the most fertile soils.
We in Latvia can be grateful that we have been given the conditions to be able to engage in agriculture, feeding ourselves and others.
Are there countries in Europe where farmers are not supported (not subsidised)?
In the European Union, there are none. The problem lies in the fact that we cannot operate solely according to market laws, because various restrictions and prohibitions exist and have been set. Subsidies are a logical action by the state because if something is prohibited, it must be compensated. I think the frequently observed or heard dislike of subsidies is often caused by a system of granting subsidies or compensation that is not always well-considered and justified.

Recently there was talk about the large volume of food thrown into the trash**: in Latvia it is said to be around 30-40%
Yes, unfortunately, a lot of food ends up in the trash! That is clear! It is also clear that the volume of food thrown away today is less than it once was.
“A lot...” How much is “a lot”?
Yes, how to measure “a lot”... Speaking in a way that is not very scientific: for a long time now, I have wanted to find out where the leftovers from very rich “Swedish tables” or banquet tables at various events end up.
In the countryside, what is left over can be given to a school, kindergarten, dance group...
A good example, but I don't think anyone in fancy restaurants, hotels or on cruise ships is going to look for a rural school!
I agree! Conversely, nobody is going to clear tables into a little bucket and feed a piglet, even though the piglet would appreciate it
Pigs are fed in a modern way now, because consumers demand cheap pork. If we wanted to fatten pigs with food waste, the meat would cost significantly more! Food waste also requires more labour.
Public catering in Latvia is still “on the brakes”. A large part of our society struggles with eating, consuming what they can afford, not what they would truly like or what they should. There is little talk about this part of society. And I am talking about normal people with higher education, families, and jobs that aren't paid as well as they should be... When talking about throwing away food, the part of society being discussed should be taken into account. Moreover, if we approach green issues too “greened”, we will have a large part of society that will not be able to afford to buy food (that they should be buying).
The issue of food accessibility includes information about serious price rises within the framework of the Green Deal. Why, in your opinion, is this not talked about? I suspect the statistics are known, but in Latvia, there is a sufficiently large part of society that has not achieved the hoped-for prosperity in 30 years of independence. Of course, the reasons are various, but not everything has depended solely and exclusively on a specific individual.
Yes! The matter is not simple. In my opinion, a person is green-thinking by nature. Of course, there are certain individuals who absolutely must drive a car into the dunes, absolutely must throw trash in the forest or absolutely must break a branch in a park, but – that is a minority of society. If a person lives in a place “for the long haul” (or for staying at all), they will want a suitable and tidy environment around them. The pandemic has created even greater inequality in society. Those who were rich have become richer; the poor – what they were, they remain, or they are even poorer. On top of that came the new tax reform... If a person spends their daily life or works in Riga, near Dome Square, they may mistakenly judge the monthly salary based on four or five digits. No, there isn't one like that all over Latvia! Every person who works (full-time, part-time – it doesn't matter) and can support themselves is a benefit to the state. A normal person does not want to live on benefits. For a portion of people, the new tax system denies them the opportunity to support themselves...
The “bubble”, the circle of people or the circles (we can call them various things) where decision-makers live or circulate are, in thought and deed, very far from the life that other residents of the country live. At one time, I thought the saying “You don't understand me” had a slight humorous undertone, but... It is completely clear that decision-makers do not understand the situation in the country. The “high or elite end” of those involved in politics, I think, does not know that there are dry toilets, houses heated with firewood, and water that must be carried from a well or an outdoor tap in Latvia (even in Riga). What I don't understand in this regard – do a member of parliament or a minister really only have friends and relatives who live in that wealthy bubble, or city dwellers from the centre?
Members of the 13th Saeima are often accused of “accidental” entry into parliament and specifically of non-elitism...
I think an essential place here has been and is held by public information. For example, at one time, the opinion was built (created) that “oligarchs are very, very bad” (I am not saying that they are all good!). What happened? Those who replaced the “bad oligarchs” were undoubtedly declared as “good”! A simplified view, but it turned out: those who replaced the oligarchs are not “good” at all; they both make mistakes and act incorrectly, but... “If we admit that our praised bright forces are not better or are even worse, it won't be good...” Populists have ended up in power in the Saeima: they do not come from the fine end of society, but the general level of intelligence and understanding of the parliament and decision-makers is not comparable to the period 15-18 years ago. The brains are no longer as wrinkled as they were at the beginning of the century. That is a problem!
What, in your opinion, will the next Saeima be like? There is still a year to go...
I hope that nothing “terrible” will happen during this time. The state's “touches” (decisions) leave an impression not only on the object of the “touch”, but also move into the depths and distance. For example, the idea of party financing from the state budget. What is the result? Those who work in parties have money, and they no longer need support from entrepreneurs, teachers or medics, nor do they need the money of entrepreneurs. Now the politicians have the money, and this same money has correspondingly sharply reduced the desire to turn to an entrepreneur and ask: “How are you doing? What do you need? What is hindering you?”
If there is money, one must buy votes. How many entrepreneurs are there in Latvia? Enough, but not too many. The cheapest are the votes of populists and fools, which is why there is an active struggle, including by intelligent parties, for the votes of vaccine opponents. If doctors and resuscitators work in the party leadership, this direction of the party is not understandable or acceptable to me. Of course, that is the party's business plan. But, for example, I have received the vaccine and about me, a conscientious citizen of Latvia, the parties have completely forgotten! The pragmatic field is empty. At least for now!
Returning to agriculture: “(expensive) plant protection products that are watered and sprayed without purpose”. At least that is what the radio says, what is written on Twitter and what city people discuss.
I think we cannot do without plant protection products here, and I don't know if we should. Why? We, humans, tend to go to the pharmacy for doctor-prescribed medicines; we use modern medical capabilities; if necessary, we are operated on by a professional surgeon. The exact same thing happens with our pets if they get sick. Speaking of crops – we cannot feed the world only with organically grown food. The view that farmers “water and splash” is wrong, as you already mentioned in your question – plant protection products (PPPs) are expensive! The second thing – while driving on the highway and seeing a cloud rising from a sprayer, one must remember that 95% or 99% of it is water with the pure protective substance in low concentration. PPPs are not watered, but sprayed! I don't think a farmer will necessarily do what they don't have to. I doubt a farmer who lives near their field is ready to “poison themselves a little” too, and the farmer, like all of us, also needs insects and pollinators.
The focus of critics or opponents is precisely on negative experiences or isolated cases.
Negative experience is everywhere! I do not think that bad examples are justifiable, that one should look through one's fingers at them and secretly praise them. That does not happen! Offenders must be punished!
In Latvia, populist decisions are often made that sound beautiful because they prohibit something, but the essence of the decisions is more harmful than what is achieved. In Latvia, many environment-related issues are justified by emotions, beliefs and faith, not knowledge and science, which is why many decisions are not professional. It is similar now with Covid, because decision-makers are afraid of the public's reaction. Green issues and decisions also build politicians' popularity, fit into the large, grey stream and... do not produce anything good.

For example, the areas for fava beans have decreased rapidly in Latvia. Beans are legumes that improve the soil, which are very useful in crop rotation, etc. But! If one wants to grow beans and receive subsidies from funds intended for greening, they must be grown without plant protection products... without which, unfortunately, it is practically impossible to grow beans in Latvia's climatic conditions. Also, we do not want to buy and consume wormy beans or peas. Or do we? Do we want disease-affected potatoes? How useful is mould for the human body? Before starting to angrily disparage something, simple questions must be answered.
Another example: it has been accepted that several PPPs cannot be used for roses, which is why rose growing in Latvia has declined. Wait, but we import roses from countries where the protective agent prohibited for us is used! How is that? It would be consistent to prohibit importing roses as well and be done with it. Another story: a currently topical subject – fur animals. If we prohibit raising them right here – there should be a complete prohibition on importing fur. Everything. Why? Production and profit as a result of seemingly correct decisions go to others, while we get the “bad stuff”. Is that the goal of the decision?
“If we don't grow them here, they will grow them elsewhere...” “They will liquidate them in Latvia...” “We will give a well-functioning industry to others...” That is not forward-thinking.
The goal is a green life. As I already mentioned, “green” decisions are often not based on evidence.
Why do we want to make ourselves a poor country? By doing nothing, there will be nothing. We have the conditions and a good climate for work and for the development of agriculture. Why give all that to someone else?
Another example from what I experienced in Cambodia. While riding in a boat, we noticed soybean fields and a sprayer. We got out and took a look. Holes had been drilled into a metal pipe, next to it were several bags of plant protection products... The inscriptions on the bags indicated that such products are not allowed in Europe. The farmer says: “...we will export this organic soy to the USA or Europe.” ... How is this “organic product” delivered to Europe? What about the checks? Ever since I see a carton of soy milk, I remember what I experienced... No, better not that!
*AREI – Institute of Agricultural Resources and Economics
**https://www.fao.org/3/ca6030en/ca6030en.pdf



