The situation with the endless demands of nature conservation
Hopefully the government led by Evika Siliņa has at last, by its decision, put an end to the speculation about how much territory is being handed over to nature conservation. Namely, 10% under strict protection, 20% for multifunctional use and 70% productively usable for scientific and economic purposes. At the same time there have been "surprises" in this field — for example, the responsible state institution "inadvertently" published a list of potentially protected territories, even though there was and is no requirement to publish it. Likewise, new territories have been placed in the protected category while no inventory has been carried out of the territories previously designated as protected. It is no wonder that nature "takes" its own course and in specific places the species being protected have died out, because others have simply squeezed them out — there is no longer an environment suitable for them to live in.

Overall, the Latvian government no longer insists as strongly as the previous one on shutting down the peat industry after a number of years; the green light for peat extraction and for the production of substrates used in agriculture has not really been given, however, even though without these substrates there are pressing questions about growing vegetables and tree seedlings. On the whole it must be concluded that there are topics on which the government and particular ministers can even be praised, and there are also those on which there is nothing to praise. But there are fundamental questions about why someone acted as they did.
Matters in which the positive is "not seen"
One may be ironic about it, but the National Development Plan for 2021–2027 includes a farmland bird and forest bird index, even though in spring it certainly rises and in autumn it falls, because the migration of birds is a reality and not an invention. The greatest concentration of birds (and therefore the index) has been observed in the vicinity of Riga Central Market and in the vicinity of the Getliņi landfill... Does that mean these are the best places for people to live? If so, it seems the residents of the shelter near the Central Market are best placed to judge. And what is the bird index in those regions of Ukraine where active fighting is going on?
This national development planning document also states that the share of specially protected nature territories (% of Latvia's total area) is 18.2%. A lot or a little? Almost every fifth hectare of land in the territory of the Latvian state is a specially protected nature territory! Of course, looking at what is happening in other EU member states, for example in Germany, it seems that everything here is quite good.
For example, last year Germany's motor industry lost around 50,000 jobs. Bosch plans to cut 22,000 jobs in the Stuttgart region. The crisis is felt both in everyday life and in politics. More and more people in Stuttgart are looking for work, which can be regarded as a new but very unpleasant phenomenon in this German region, since the federal state depends on the motor industry not only for jobs but also for tax revenue. Trade tax revenue in Stuttgart fell by almost 50% last year — to 750 million euros. Because of the drop in income, the car manufacturers Mercedes and Porsche paid far smaller sums in taxes than before. In nearby Rastatt, tax revenue fell by as much as two thirds because of Mercedes difficulties.
And again there is a harsh example concerning the EU Nature Restoration Regulation and what it contains, which has little to do with the real situation in Latvia, one of the greenest countries in the European Union. I do not know what Latvia's partners in "old Europe" — Germany, France, Italy — would do, or how, if they actually had to restore the state of nature as it was many decades ago. Will the Nordic and Baltic countries, as well as Poland, have to carry the heavy burden not only for themselves but also on behalf of the Western European states? It should not be so, but it is written that the condition of habitats must be returned to the form it had 70 years ago. Such a position has been assessed at the level of European experts, but Latvia's position on this draft regulation was — how is it to be implemented — since it would take very large areas of land out of economic circulation, several tens of thousands of hectares. Restoration of the hydrological regime is envisaged for peat soils, which puts Latvia's drained land back 70 years into the past, a process that is the opposite of drainage. But, given Latvia's climatic situation, where the volume of precipitation exceeds the level of evaporation, this would mean turning Latvia into a bog, where there is no place for people.
What is actually meant to be achieved in the name of nature conservation?
Depopulation continues in Latvia. It is interesting — but as the number of inhabitants shrinks, does the number of animals of every kind increase? And how is one to understand the aggressive rhetoric of certain groups of individuals about things "getting worse for nature in Latvia"? Perhaps the logic is the reverse — the more foxes, wolves, bears, badgers, raccoon dogs and beavers there are, the worse it is for the people living in Latvia? Yet if the numbers of these animals are indeed increasing, it is logical that the reason for their multiplication is a favourable environment, an adequate food base and also a smaller human population. The only question is — at what number of these animals, especially wolves and bears, will that eco-fanatical part of society, which mostly lives in urban areas and regards animals rather as inhabitants of a zoo, be ready to understand that their numbers must match the food base while not posing threats to people's health, lives and also their livelihoods. This does not mean the violent destruction of animals, but rather a sensible, economically justified and environmentally friendly population.
Last December the Minister of Justice signed the Council of Europe Convention on the Protection of the Environment through Criminal Law, affirming Latvia's commitment to strengthen the fight against criminal offences directed against the environment and to promote a common European approach to investigating and punishing environmental crimes. The convention provides that states must define the most serious offences against the environment as criminally punishable, ensuring effective penalties for both natural and legal persons. All this would be fine, but there is much left unsaid on this topic, because criminal liability is to apply to substantial pollution (it is not known how this will be measured or who will determine it), unauthorised transport of waste (how much — a kilogram or 20 tonnes?) and its management, damage to protected territories (if the wind has blown down an entire protected forest stand, will the owner of that territory face criminal liability?), breaches of the protection of wild plant and animal species (which ones?) and other harm. It is important to know who then will have (has) the right to criminal-law defence and representation on behalf of the environment. Eco-activists, the Minister of Justice, the Prosecutor General, or any person who at that moment feels that serious harm is being done to the environment? On the one hand it is a splendid opportunity for new jobs and staff positions in investigative structures, but on the other it makes no sense and has no positive effect on state budget revenue — quite the opposite: additional expenditure.
The future. What to expect?
Everyone must strive to achieve the necessary result. The forest sector and the Latvian state need decisions that are scientifically substantiated, economically advantageous and useful to society. Experts from an Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) mission recently visited Latvia with the aim of obtaining in-depth information about Latvia's forest sector and the sectors connected with it. The OECD experts will use the information gathered to prepare an extensive report on the forest sector's contribution to rural development. I hope the OECD report might open the eyes of some part of society to the sector's contribution to Latvia's national economy, to the state budget, and to the development opportunities, potential and benefits for those living in Latvia, while at the same time removing from public rhetoric the phrase "all the forests have been cut down", even though from time to time there are reports of people getting lost in the forest and of rising numbers of various predators. It has to be understood that in the long term every person's welfare depends not on how many real or fictitious biotopes we count today, or on how much of our forest we reclassify as protected forest, but on how strong the national economy in Latvia will be, because only that determines the inflow of money (taxes) into the state budget, which is the source for financing services that are significant and necessary for the whole country (and society).
Three important figures — Latvian state budget expenditure in 2025 was approximately 19.5 billion euros, total revenue only 17.8 billion euros, of which tax revenue was almost 14.4 billion euros. The conclusion — Latvia is already unable to manage without European structural fund money and increases in the national debt; the best solution is a favourable and predictable economic environment, especially for the land-based sectors — forestry, agriculture and peat extraction — combined with an effective, genuine reduction in bureaucracy. If this scenario does not come to pass, there will be no other solution than raising tax rates or introducing new ones, together with a decline in the availability and quality of services that matter to society.
Is raising taxes, as in Estonia, the best solution?
Highly doubtful! That is precisely why it is so important that decision-makers better understand the potential of the land-based sectors and their capacity not only to feed those living in Latvia, but also to provide jobs and taxes for the state coffers. It should be recalled that last year the timber industry proposed increasing the forest sector's output over a period of 3–5 years by raising annual timber harvesting in state forests by around 2 million m³ (or ~15% of the average volume over the past 5 years); this would have a positive effect on the budget — approximately 200–300 million euros each year (direct and indirect taxes plus an increased volume of dividends from the management of state forests). Over a 3–5 year period that would be approximately 1 billion euros, or symbolically a "security billion" from the forest sector. That would already be a political decision, the essence of which is — are we in Latvia ready to make use of the assets that are in society's hands.



