In conversation with forester Juris Buškevics are Māris Liopa, Chairman of the Forest Certification Council of Latvia (LMSP), and Pauls Rēvelis, editor of zemeunvalsts.lv
Since March, there has been plenty of talk about “Rīgas Meži” in terms of conjecture. How did the change in management come about, and was there any prior sign of dissatisfaction from the city administration regarding the company's performance?
The decision by the Riga City Council leadership on 18 March was unexpected for me; it was a situation not easily comprehended. It is a very unpleasant feeling: you have worked with full dedication for almost 10 years, thinking of the company, and now this work is gone... For the first month, I continued to feel like part of the company, like an employee. In my thoughts, of course. Seeing and reading statements that are untrue, and most likely the whistleblowing report is also fake, which no one—except for a few Riga City Council representatives—has read or analysed... how do I feel? Journalists ask me about this and that, but I would gladly ask them: “How do you think I feel, and how does my family feel?” The statements coming from the Council and the media are hurtful because everything is phrased in terms of conjecture and probability.
(“...we have unofficially heard this space referred to as a hunting lodge. When I am there, that is the impression I get... ...this is something we must carefully check; at the moment, we have no proven grounds to claim this, but it also raises these concerns...” (Quote from the Riga City Council press conference, 16:44))
It is sad when good acquaintances meet and ask: “Juris, how did this happen?” Nobody has turned their back on me, though. There are many who openly express their support and say: “We know it is not true.”

In Latvia, bad news is still good news, and it is accepted very uncritically
That is true! People do not want to familiarise themselves, for example, with a sawmill business plan. I wonder if anyone at the Council has even read it...
Have the Mayor of Riga, Edmunds Cepurītis, or other deputies been to “Rīgas Meži”, familiarised themselves with the work, and seen the tree nursery and the sawmill?
I understand very well that those in power and working at the Riga City Council have no concept of how “Rīgas Meži” operates. That is precisely why, even before the extraordinary Riga City Council elections, we invited the politicians running for office to visit our sawmill. Why that specifically? Everyone has hopefully been to the forest at least once, for a walk, for example. In a sawmill? Hardly. A number of candidates accepted our invitation and arrived, including those who were later elected. Mr Staķis also visited both the sawmill and the Green Classroom, saying he had gained a rich impression. We felt a certain level of support: if Mr Staķis were to become Mayor of Riga, our work and needs would be understood; we even outlined the company’s strategy, which we talked about for several hours. Our plan was simple: for politicians who want to get into the Council and prepare to work there to gain an understanding of one of the capital's municipal companies and its operations. As it turns out, that was not necessary...
When did the actions from the Council begin?
The opposition from the previous Council term effectively continued the same style of rhetoric after the elections, albeit from a position of power, which was a little incomprehensible: the owners can come to us and say whatever they want. Whatever the owner wants, management will do.
An owner can want things, but the owner must also understand something... Otherwise, these “wishes” begin to sound a bit like a fairy tale...
True, but first you need the owner to actually be an owner. For quite some time before the elections in the Riga City Council, many things were “temporary”: there were acting mayors, temporary executive directors. For at least a year or a year and a half, we had no real owner; we worked by adhering to the previously developed strategy, which was recognised not only by the old owner (the previous Council) but also by numerous audits. For example, Ernst&Young audited the sawmill and concluded that, based on the business plan, it was operating ahead of schedule—that is, profits appeared sooner. It is clear that in the first years of the sawmill, we did not plan for profit, as investments must be recouped.
Rīgas Meži is also certified...
The management of Rīgas Meži is definitely influenced by the surrounding urban environment. We cannot say that we can manage forests solely by following legislation. We also have social responsibility, ensuring opportunities for the residents of Riga and the surrounding areas to relax, which increased significantly during the pandemic. “Rīgas Meži” has constantly been in the position of reconciling economic interests with something or someone... It is not just about forests in the city of Riga, where every economic activity must be coordinated with local residents.

Returning to certification, “Rīgas Meži” did not just receive certificates; we earned them, proving our compliance with sustainable forestry. The first was the PEFC certificate, which is in a sense more democratic than other certification systems. But, I must say, we saw the return and contribution of this certificate immediately. The first thing I consider very important: occupational safety, which this certificate requires. Reading various documents coming from the EU and other institutions, I occasionally see requirements and guidelines appear that “Rīgas Meži” has been dealing with for a long time—for example, that business must become social. We have always paid serious attention to social issues, and it is also one of the fundamental issues in the certification system. When we received the FSC certificate, we gained confirmation that forestry is also environmentally friendly and environmentally sustainable. Of course, it is not a free exercise; it is a certain burden on the company, but if you work in a business, the money has to be counted.
I may be repeating myself, but the understanding of forests and forest management among Riga residents is perfectly illustrated by Biķernieku Street and the forest. First, we tended the forest on the left side of the street, heading from the centre. There was shouting. When we showed what we were doing and what we were carrying out, the crowd of dissatisfied people decreased. We started working in the forest on the right side of the street, where the start of the work coincided with the pre-election period. Associations of residents from the micro-districts and neighbourhoods appeared, and spokespeople criticised us for forest maintenance. What now? We tried to find the people who praised us for the work on the other side of the street. We received many words of gratitude for tidying up the left side of Biķernieku Street, because now it is possible to walk safely in the forest; it has been cleaned up, and the undergrowth has been removed. People are scared by overgrown areas and thickets. The elections ended, the paths were tidied up, and that is already forgotten.
Critics lately have been using words like: “No, we ‘feel’, ‘it seems’, or ‘we think that...’ ”
The age of social networks allows amateurs and people unconnected to management to talk and express anything, which they are not ashamed to do. To a specialist, listening or reading this, it becomes clear there is no competence or understanding in what is being said. I will not even talk about forestry and the understanding of it.
“Rīgas Meži” was founded 13 years ago, when the Riga Forest Agency was transformed into an SIA (Limited Liability Company). Not all employees understood it, but the transition took place while respecting social principles and democracy; for example, we kept the employees that the SIA took over from the agency, and we preserved their social guarantees. There was a trade union in the agency, and in the company, we agreed that the best form of cooperation would be a collective agreement with stable social guarantees. I joined “Rīgas Meži” in August 2011, and I know that all these years the company has been moving forward, developing for growth. Sometimes it was tiring, because every day there was something new. The first issue I addressed: forest planting and maintenance, which at the time was done through outsourcing. In the first few weeks, getting to know the practical work of “Rīgas Meži”, I found that the foresters and rangers were not satisfied with the contractors. Low quality of work, performance deadlines slipping. It seems simple because there is a contract with specific terms, but... in nature, if it is planted poorly and the time is missed, the young growth is lost. Yes, after a few years we can get fines through the courts, but the forest is lost! There was no other solution—I set up the management so that the forest would be planted and tended by our own employees. Another circumstance encouraged this: we concluded that the winner of the procurement did not even have workers. The company that won “ran around” looking for workers. The initiative of the rangers was to tend the forest with their own forces and their own employees, which we supported. Additional motivation for us was having the ranger in the forest outside of their daily routine. The first year doing this allowed us to save about 30% of funds. Yes, we saved money because we tended what needed to be tended! (In procurement, the volume of areas to be tended must be determined, which is impossible to predict—will the plantation become overgrown or not, will it be dry or wet, what will the year be like... Do we need to tend it twice?) We saved money, and that is not to mention the quality and deadlines. Meanwhile, we introduced tablets for rangers, making them forget paper sheets. We bought drones, which help very effectively in both forest fire control and ditch maintenance. We also bought an excavator for ditch maintenance. Ditch maintenance gives forest stands additional growth, but... our logging costs decreased. By restoring the banks of the ditches, they became transport roads for timber. Everything is connected: how to do it better, how to be more frugal, how to be more rational.

Why, in the end, such an attitude? Has that been the mandate?
If we hear the question: “Who benefits from this?”, there are not many answers!
Green Classroom...
The project and idea for the Green Classroom are old; “Rīgas Meži” “inherited” them from the Riga Forest Agency. A deer park had been set up, which is a certain burden for the company (the capital company), because it is only an expense. Seeing the investments made previously (about 300,000 Lats), it seemed it would not be economical to simply discard or write them off. Not use them? Irresponsible! Continuing what was started, but in a different direction, would be more correct—for example, thinking about education. If we only showed deer to interested parties, it would have little to do with education... But the territory is interesting in many ways; at one time there was an army base there; there are very old spruce stands, which is not very typical for Latvia because the biological age of spruce is lower than that of pine; the terrain is suitable, and the Norupīte river flows through the territory: it is a very suitable place in terms of landscape. From a forestry perspective, one can find an opportunity to show how a forest develops. Thus, the idea of the Green Classroom was born, where one could tell what forestry is. We acted quickly, we bought a log cabin, but... one must always look at the availability of funds. Namely, during the time I described, “Rīgas Meži” was responsible for everything related to Mežaparks, and that required serious investments (about 500,000 Lats); in 2012, the agency “Rīgas parki un dārzi” (Riga Parks and Gardens) was added to us, which is also only an expense. We evaluated the share of total expenses in the “Rīgas Meži” budget very pragmatically, slowing down the development of the Green Classroom for a time. At that time, the construction of the sawmill was underway. The holder of the capital shares in the Riga City Council supported our plans; we did receive criticism about the inherited deer park and its goals, but... when we explained about the planned education project, we were told: “Why talk then, just do it!”
Regarding hunting, there is also great hypocrisy in Latvia and a desire to “green” oneself with slogans. The representatives of the current Council blamed “Rīgas Meži” employees for having privileges in hunting...
We are blamed for the fact that “Rīgas Meži” employees are in a hunting collective, they hunt, and they do not have the highest rental fee. Yes, true! The “Rīgas Meži” hunting collective, where the majority of members are foresters and rangers, pays a lower rental fee, but... A non-specialist will not understand: if a forester is “brought” into the forest in their free time (hunting usually happens on Saturdays or Sundays), if, while driving the hunt or going to the hunting spot, they see what they do not see in everyday life... (The ranger’s day is planned; they have to be in specific plots, in specific stands). Physically, a ranger cannot inspect all plots every day, but during the hunt, there is an opportunity to be in another forest, in another plot. Seeing the damage caused by ungulates (ungulates are multiplying rapidly because agriculture is developing), for which young growth is a tasty morsel—spruce and pine are being eaten incessantly; our task is to reduce the damage to a level that does not affect forestry activity, and the only possibility is hunting. Fences? That is an expensive, even a very expensive, pleasure! In the amount of project money, fences can be built for scientific purposes, no more. If a ranger is in their district hunting in their free time, can we charge them an increased fee for that? If we are talking about social responsibility: we provide an opportunity for employees to also relax in the forest. The company gains from that!
Speaking of the previous Council, “Rīgas Meži” was by no means on the list of municipal companies mentioned for criticism of the Riga leadership (there were Rīgas Satiksme, Rīgas Namu pārvaldnieks, Rīgas Karte...). Can you compare... What was it like to work?
Everywhere I have worked, they demanded fruitful work from me. When I started working in the capital company, my task was to ensure its competitiveness. All the goals coincided with those to be carried out in a normal capital company. I will say, at the time I did not appreciate how the previous Riga City Council leadership allowed us to work. I am not talking about politics, but about the approach: the entrepreneur and the company must work!
Although to inadvertently praise the previous Council composition is neither refined, nor correct, nor...
Let us not be naive; at that time the Riga City Council was led by “Saskaņa” and “Gods kalpot Rīgai”, and people belonging to other parties spoke: we were “serving red Riga”. Were we? We worked and we were allowed to work! We did not participate in active political activity; no one invited me to join any party. I have always believed that I was invited to work at “Rīgas Meži” as a specialist! At one time, “chairmen on paper” were popular, who only signed papers and sipped coffee or something stronger, spending their workday like that. That was not us!
Seeing how harmoniously, professionally orienting themselves in the sector, “Rīgas Meži” cooperated with other industry companies, at the moment there is no certainty that it will continue...
In the company, in my opinion, the inertia of the work started is still continuing, because the employees know their duties and there is nothing radical that needs to be changed!
The sawmill and talk about/around it...
I have no proof that anyone had their eye on the sawmill for themselves, which is what one hears talked about. The surprise at the accusations made was, however, genuine, because in the audits carried out by both the State Audit Office and the Competition Council, there were no significant indications that the sawmill's operation should be stopped.
Upon entering the market, a market participant must reckon with increased competition. Usually, they do not evaluate what kind of market participant it is; “Rīgas Meži” entered with what was at its disposal—we did not claim raw materials that we had ourselves.
In the strategic plans, we already foresaw that the areas of protected territories in “Rīgas Meži” would increase; one must reckon with that, they will be no less than 30%. Speaking of other restrictions: when the Riga Forest Agency was operating, it had a budget that had to be fulfilled, where there could not be more income than set. Absurd, but a fact! At that time, many unmaintained middle-aged stands accumulated in the forests. The goal of the capital company is profit (which we are now being blamed for)... and the course of action is different.
Forests must be tended, they must be processed, timber must be sold—they cannot be used otherwise. Selling wood on the stump (in logging areas), we saw that those who sell the timber further to sawmills make the money. So, others are profiting. We saw that sawmills are profiting: “Wait, why not profit ourselves?!” Accusations sound: we are only thinking about profit. What will the city of Riga do when there are many restrictions in the forests? RailBaltica is coming, city infrastructure is developing... Every year we lose several tens of hectares of forest area. The railway will take hundreds—who will compensate the city for that? We are already obtaining less timber... Who will compensate for the lost income? The sawmill!

Will RailBaltica affect “Rīgas Meži” areas?
Yes, they will be large enough, several hundred hectares! It will not be true that they only started thinking about RailBaltica in Riga now. In the course of the project development several years ago, the routes were marked, followed by more specific changes. As I mentioned, at the moment all the areas that will be deforested are known. That is definitely known! We actively participated in the project discussion and development, because we were interested in access roads and wild animal crossings. The latter are very important so that wild animals can move, and we are not just talking about ungulates or foxes, but about frogs, hedgehogs, etc. I will add, in the course of the project, we expected greater support and interest from the so-called environmental or green NGOs, which did not happen...
There are moments when the greens disappear... They are needed, they are not there!
Yes, and this Council composition is the one that has to get down to the implementation of the project!
Have you thought about the newly built concert hall? The latest plans, for some reason, provide at any cost to stuff it into one of the Riga parks...
I have not participated in the discussion, but as a citizen, I believe that to attack any of the Riga parks for the needs of a concert hall is absurd! There are plenty of places! If we look at good examples—concert halls in Latvian cities—the main thing is their accessibility! That is important! “Gors”, “Lielais Dzintars”—elegant examples! If accessibility can only be provided by one of the Riga parks... that is not understandable.
But, I am not an architect, I will not meddle in these matters; I feel very bad if I am taught by a person without forestry education or understanding. I can understand if I am asked, because they do not know.
“Rīgas Meži” also has a tree nursery
The forest starts from there. In the tree nursery, there is an opportunity to earn; in recent years it has brought profit, we have sold everything grown.
If we now see that the expenses for the development of the tree nursery and the development of the company are stopped, it is clear that something is wrong, because there may be no gains. How long will the inertia of the company's operation I mentioned last? How will the employees understand it? Understandably, the company will exist and work! In what form, it is not clear.




Comments