Europe's lungs without compensation, or why not all European solutions are suitable for Latvia - Zeme un valsts

Europe's lungs without compensation, or why not all European solutions are suitable for Latvia

Latvia is the fourth most forested country in Europe, yet forest owners, who are being burdened with the most obligations by European environmental policy, receive compensation that does not even cover inflation. In a conversation following his speech at the Forest Certification Council of Latvia's 11th international conference, "Environment and Sustainable Forest and Land Management," held at the LBTU Faculty of Forest and Environmental Sciences in Jelgava, Rolands Feldmanis, Chairman of the Board of the Agricultural Cooperation Association of Latvia (LLKA), discusses why Brussels-enacted regulations mean an asymmetric shock for Latvia, why Scandinavians pay more for our forests than we do ourselves, and what the small owner with nine hectares should do.

At the conference, you emphasised that Latvia's greatest peculiarity is its small forest owners. Why?

Latvia is the fourth most forested country in Europe, and our greatest peculiarity—which is simultaneously an asset—is the fact that we still have a very large number of small forest owners. The average forest property owned by a private individual is 9 hectares. What to do with these numerous owners is one of the industry's biggest problems; I will return to this.

First, about the problem. It was mentioned several times at the conference that the forest is ageing. One could say our lungs are ageing too. The rate of carbon sequestration in a young forest is much higher than in an old one, which is why the forest needs to be used more efficiently and productively; in this way, we would get a fresh breath for our own lungs as well. This is exactly where policy begins—namely, the Nature Restoration Law, LULUCF (land use, land-use change and forestry), the Biodiversity Strategy, and the EUDR (EU Deforestation Regulation). For all these policies, the main payer is, in fact, that same small forest owner with his 9 hectares. Most is demanded of him, his property rights are restricted, yet in return, he gets no income and instead has his capital and inheritance frozen.

You call this an asymmetric shock. What does this mean for the forest industry?

When the Nature Restoration Law is adopted at the European level, we all go to Brussels and receive what is known in economics as an asymmetric shock. Rules that are good for a forest in Spain—if there is any forest at all and if it is comparable in quality to Latvia's forest—or for deciduous forests in Italy, France, and Germany, are applied to our spruce, pine, and mixed-species forests in a completely different region. The first difference is forest structure, which is why we cannot have the same rules and requirements that Europe introduces.

Our Polish colleagues and the Austrian example confirm this. In Austria, the forest cover is much lower, and the forests are in the mountains, where nobody can get to them anyway. In other countries, cliffs and mountain slopes where economic activity cannot be carried out are simply designated as reserves because practically nothing can be done there, and the target for protected areas is met without any loss. It is like that in Spain, and it is like that in the Alps. In Latvia, there are no cliffs. We have forest that needs to be removed from economic circulation, i.e., from ourselves. Perhaps we should use the seashore in that way, where economic activity is already restricted, rather than removing productive forest from circulation in the middle of the country.

The state pays certain compensation to forest owners for restrictions.

The state makes the forest protection pledges, but the forest owner pays. The compensation, which is 50-190 euros per hectare per year, does not cover the losses. Here I arrive at the question that should be asked by everyone who owns a forest, namely—what am I to do with it?

I calculated it based on the assumption that I own an averagely productive forest that can be logged. The compensation generates a return of about one and a half percent of the frozen capital per year. That is less than a bank deposit. The European Central Bank's inflation target is 2%, so if my forest with the compensation generates less income than inflation takes, I am losing capital every year. The return on forestry, depending on productivity, is higher, and the discount rate of "Latvijas valsts meži," which, it seems, has not been recalculated for a long time, is 4.58%. Even that is low when compared to a situation where I sell the forest and invest the money in a stock market index.

Why the stock market index specifically?

A stock index is a diversified portfolio of the world's largest companies, and if one fares worse, it is replaced by another. Over a longer period, 50 years, it gives 6-8% per year, including all crises and downturns, and at any moment this asset can be turned into money. The forest, on the other hand, is not diversified, because it has all sorts of diseases, taxes must be paid on it regularly, and it cannot be sold in one day. The small owner with 9 hectares and all these restrictions loses the opportunity that he would theoretically have if the forest could be managed. It is not fair! Most other regulations work very similarly—namely, officials sign the commitments, but we pay.

Is it the same with the EUDR or the Deforestation Regulation?

The EUDR is the same. It is a global solution to stop the disappearance of primeval forests in the world. But in Latvia, the forest area has grown. It is rightly objected that while the hectares are increasing, the quality of the forest is falling. Why is it falling? Because we do not want to invest. Why invest if you cannot get a return? If I grow a new forest, an eagle will appear there, there will be a micro-reserve, a habitat, and something else—and what then? The forest owner is not protected; the industry cannot develop like that.

The asymmetric shock has been studied since the beginning of the 2000s. Economist Morten Hansen (Morten Hansen), whom I studied under myself, especially emphasizes that a small country cannot automatically adopt regulations that come from Europe. Southern Europe lacks water and forest, it has other problems, and these are large countries with "large" voting rights. Latvia alone cannot decide anything, and neither can the Baltics. The Scandinavians say they go their own way, and Poland has the Visegrád Group and its own policy. We are pushed to the sidelines, to the Russian border, to the periphery, yet the same conditions are applied to us. Our MEPs in the European Parliament can explain this, but there are only a few of them, compared to, for example, the German representatives, who effectively set the policy.

What helps? Are there countries where protection works?

The Austrian example, where the owner is paid compensation, and Finland, where such a system works. If there is an eagle in your territory—if you have tended the forest or left it in a pristine state and a noble bird has appeared there, which nature lovers like—you have done a good job. Why not receive compensation for that, if it is a benefit to society? Nature lovers speak out as if they represent the majority of society. Then we must say: "Fine, if you are willing to pay, we are ready to conserve this forest, and it costs so-and-so much."

If we have ensured that the eagle is there, then it must be paid for, and perhaps even more than could be obtained for timber. Because right now, the only value by which we judge forest land is the timber that can be harvested. We have no other values.

When we go to the gym, we pay for it; no one has any questions as to why one should pay for a sports club or sports equipment. That is usage. The forest can be perceived in exactly the same way, as sports equipment and a place for recreation, which also costs something. If a forest owner has not put up a sign that you must not walk here, and has not put a fence around their property, they are providing a service to society. Why not receive compensation for that?

If our forest return is so low, why do the Scandinavians buy it and pay more than we do?

If we look at the transactions, such a question arises. Why are the Scandinavians buying up our forest and why for sums that exceed what we are prepared to pay? Let us remember the "Bergvik Skog" transaction in 2018, when the Swedish cooperative "Södra" bought more than 100 thousand hectares of Latvian forest for 324 million euros, and Latvijas valsts meži, which also wanted to buy, could not outbid them because, according to unofficial reports, the Swedes paid about 50 million more than the state considered economically justified. Why? Because they have calculated how much their factory downtime costs and realize that it is better to pay extra here for a resource that they export from Latvia as roundwood. We are left with the unsequestered CO₂ and a worse balance, but the raw material leaves without value-added.

This is the opposite of what local companies do. "Gaujas koks," "Latvijas Finieris," which is building a plywood factory, and the third, the Ramoliņš family company "Stiga RM," are all trying to add value. The Scandinavians export timber because they need to keep their factories running, and that is why they can afford to pay more for our timber. Our balance is negative because we lose the value-added.

If the compensation were adequate, as in Austria or Finland, our forest owners would be willing to keep their forests because they would generate income that approaches the 8-9% that the alternative provides. Now the opposite is happening—namely, small owners are selling off their forest, the Scandinavians are buying it, and buying it for their own needs, not to support our economy and value-added, but to keep their own factories running.

What does this mean for the Latvian timber industry?

If we restrict our forest usage opportunities again, the biggest threat is that we stop using our production capacity. The factories we have built, the furniture manufacturing that is already very advanced, the plywood, and simpler processing—all these investments, all the employee training, only work if there is raw material. If we remove the production base, the industry disappears, and our Polish colleagues explained this at the conference. Removing raw material is shooting oneself in the foot.

Value-added comes from three factors: human, capital (i.e., equipment), and land. If we do not use the land, we destroy the capital, and our number of people is not growing. We are already one of the poorest countries in Europe, and by killing off an industry like the forestry sector, we will have no springboard, because there is no chemical or IT industry that could pull the country along faster. A colleague from "Laflora" said at the conference that he is ready to pay 100 million in taxes if he is allowed to use the resource.

What are your conclusions? What should be done?

Three things. First, national adaptation. Ideally, it would be to achieve adaptation from the European side in a short time and eliminate the asymmetric shock, but you have to start with your own society, and it is divided. In discussions with the President of the State, half the room says they want to live green. We, the farmers and foresters, are sitting nearby. Do we not want to live green? We do, both in a literal and figurative sense, just like the whole of society. Therefore, first of all, we must achieve social unity and understanding of where the industry is heading and how important it is. We talk a lot about the negative, but too little about the positive. "Latvijas Finieris" differs from other companies in that it is a public limited company with many owners, while most, including "Gaujas koks" and "Stiga RM," are single-owner companies. "Latvijas Finieris" would gladly build and develop factories here, just like others, but cannot due to the restrictions.

Secondly, fair compensation. That 90 euros per hectare is a rip-off deal for the forest owner. The compensation must cover the foregone income, not a fraction of it.

Thirdly, cooperation. I come from a cooperative environment, and there is no other way out for the small owners; they must be united in cooperatives. Small ones unite into larger structures that work together and are a more predictable partner with stable supplies and stable quality. But the time for cooperative propaganda had run out back then, at the conference.

In Finland, the voluntary forest protection programme METSO operates. What decisions must Latvia make to introduce something similar?

The answer is one, namely, first inform the public so that it is understandable where we are heading. I participate in the law-making process in Saeima committees daily, and if two groups of society argue, the head of the committee says to argue it out first and then come with a decision. Therefore, the homework must be done. Perhaps the forest industry has done this too little, explained too little, been too little insistent, and, as Uldis Biķis said, we tried to be polite. As a result, those who shouted the loudest now seemingly represent the majority of society, although in reality, they represent a person who has a house in Baltezers or elsewhere outside Riga and who wants everything around him to be a forest that no one cuts.

Is it fair to forbid an owner to manage their own forest without adequate compensation?

If you buy an apartment and suddenly you are told that it is not just your apartment, and several families have to live in it now, how can you feel and what can you plan? Many forest owners continue to be owners only for patriotic and emotional reasons, not driven by financial considerations.

The Green Deal foresees reducing the use of timber. How should this be evaluated?

The Green Deal, where timber is replaced by fossil or imported raw materials, is absurd because timber is one of the most wonderful materials. To produce cement, to be used in reinforcing a house, it takes thousands of degrees and a lot of burned fossil fuel, after which the building is insulated with synthetic materials, and in addition, we say that we have saved fossil resources. Those who build wooden houses should be subsidised; just pay them a supplement, and there would be demand for timber.

At the conference, the question of expert responsibility for decisions taken in relation to another person's forest property was also raised.

It is not fair; I will tell you one case. In Teika, in the former "Marss" velodrome territory on Brīvības gatve next to new apartment blocks, the state had decided to build a State Security Service building, but in the meantime, a park had formed in place of the track. In May 2020, well-known people in society organised a picket from the Freedom Monument to Teika, doused themselves in red paint, blocked Brīvības Street, and told the whole of society how a park was being demolished. The action was organised in the morning, at rush hour. That shows what it was for, namely, not for everyone to find out, but for everyone rushing to work to be delayed. Later, the State Security Service itself found out that the protesters had been paid by the developer of the adjacent new building; the press also wrote about it. The calculation is simple. A 20-storey building opposite a park is 5-10% more expensive. If the house value is 10 million, 5% is 500 thousand; they paid 10 or 20 thousand for the protest. That is what happens. Forest owners sit and are ashamed to tell such facts. If it were not for the Security Service, we would never have found out about it.

Add a comment