When work comes easily... A conversation with Maija Dubro, head of the Sabile care association "Kalme" - Zeme un valsts

When work comes easily... A conversation with Maija Dubro, head of the Sabile care association "Kalme"

In Sabile – a small, cosy town on the banks of the Abava – life and time flow on, regardless of whether the river is rushing or calm, as the seasons change. There is a house in Sabile that many locals know well.

Why talk about a care home on a forestry and related industries portal, no matter how excellent it may be?

The story (like more than one on the zemeunvalsts.lv portal) is about experience. We will highlight – a very good experience in a field from which we mostly hear demands for money and reviews of various long-standing problems. In Sabile, when solving situations and issues smartly, without money, of course, one cannot manage, but... you will feel the difference between “let's wait, maybe it will happen” and “let's act, then it will happen”.

Less than five years ago, I accidentally ended up in a conversation with a colleague about private senior care homes. A relative of my colleague wanted to spend her old age in Latvia. At that time, we concluded that our situation with private senior care homes was not exactly brilliant – that is – the opportunities to place a relative in one were quite limited. How is it now?

Private senior care homes are mainly located in Riga. Legally, we in Sabile are an association, which cannot be considered entirely private. Of course, we do not have state or municipal guaranteed co-funding; everything happens within the framework of the association's budget, which is formed by our clients' contributions.

In the Kurzeme region, we are definitely the cheapest in terms of long-term social care and social rehabilitation service costs, and I suspect the same for the whole of Latvia. Currently, the fee is €600 a month for full round-the-clock care, including food, accommodation costs, utilities, medication, hygiene products, staff salaries and taxes. Contributions are mostly made up of our clients' pensions, and for some clients, also contributions from relatives.

If we talk about the situation in Latvia, I have always believed that small or medium-sized boarding houses or care homes are much more valuable, and my colleagues agree with me on this. With us, the client is not impersonal; they can be considered a family member. In a large boarding house, the carer rarely sees the client, not to mention the head of the boarding house.

What is it that a person needs most? They have been torn from their family, from their familiar environment, and we try to create something similar to that familiar environment so that our seniors feel fulfilled. Nowadays, depression can sneak up on a person even when they are at home, let alone outside their usual rhythm of life.

The main task of a care home is to create a feeling – that the person is needed and that they are... a person. It is very easy to make the situation impersonal – “sit there and do this, don't go there, etc.”

Of course, when thinking about the national situation, society – whether we like it or not – is ageing. Another problem, which I consider to be a consequence of the disorganized healthcare system, is that people end up in our care homes very ill, often with well-advanced ailments.

I am not talking about dementia here, because the age of our clients ranges from 75 to 98, and there are plenty of people here in “Kalme” whose diagnosis is dementia. We have even taught some clients to speak and think after a stroke. We do everything so that the person does not live in memories of old times, not remembering what they ate yesterday; we have even taught a few to walk, literally lifting them up from a bedridden state.

Officially, in the register of the Ministry of Welfare, we are a social care centre, and we have been operating for 25 years. 206 clients have passed through “our hands” so far; in the nine years since I have been running the boarding house, four clients have gone home. Their health condition improved, and their relatives were able to live with these people quite easily.

It is understandable that people also end up with you because the family cannot really cope, as they lack both time and professional skills...

Of course they cannot cope, because our clients need round-the-clock care! As a relative who has to work until retirement age, how can one provide round-the-clock care for a loved one? Relatives do not have the option for this kind of (round-the-clock) care, and besides, the cost of living shows one thing – everyone who has the opportunity must work. That is why there is a demand for care homes.

In your daily work, have you had to hear the deeply rooted stereotype in part of society about these kinds of care homes – namely – that they are still often called workhouses. That is an old, but local classic.

I can only speak for the last nine years, as I mentioned. The term “workhouse” is occasionally heard, but not because the people involved (our clients or their relatives) think so – that is what people around say and judge. A person who ends up with us, and their relatives, seeing the situation, neither think nor say that. It is judged by a neighbour or a distant acquaintance who does not know the situation. I think that in time the word “workhouse” will disappear from colloquial language and remain only in books. People understand very well that it does not fit the times. Our clients wait for the opportunity to come to us and even hope for it – the queue that has applied today is quite large, and I cannot provide a spot for everyone waiting in the queue. For example, the next person who will come to us, if a place frees up soon, has been waiting in the queue for two years. The waiting time is not short. It should be added that for some of our clients, the conditions at home were much worse than with us.

I cannot compare “Kalme” with other care institutions of a similar type, but with us, the term “workhouse” has effectively disappeared because there is no basis for it. I will add – it is no secret that we also have clients arriving who have been made penniless by their relatives. Houses signed over to someone, property signed over – thank you – now we are ready to place you in a good care home... It also happens like that! The harsh reality of life is not common, but it exists.

The concentration of senior care homes in Riga and its surroundings that you mentioned would be understandable, but surely there are also such places in the regions.

During the period when C19 was current for us, we had to inform the Ministry of Welfare every day about the situation, about those who were ill, etc. At that time, there was an opportunity to see a list of similar institutions, to understand who and how. There are care homes under the supervision of associations (there are few of them), there are state and municipal boarding houses. There are some private ones – in Riga and Jūrmala; there is also a branch of the private boarding house “Liepas” in Sabile. I think that in care homes located outside Riga and Jūrmala, there is even a healthier environment and fresher air. After all, the majority of Riga residents also came from rural areas.

How many people do you provide with work?

We provide work to 14 people, and we have 30 clients. Everything is compact. Part of the building we inhabit was once built for the needs of the town Council, another part was intended for a kindergarten. Last year (in 2022) the building turned a round 100 years old. Before the care home, an ambulance station was located here. When its work ended, the previous management of the boarding house founded an association and, with the financial help of the Queen Juliana Foundation, started renovations. Over the last nine years, we have made various changes; I might add, my office was the last one to be renovated. I remember the builders teased me, as this was the first institution where they had to work where all the rooms and attics were renovated first, only tackling the boss's office last. I will say – I did not have time for that.

You mentioned that the care home belongs to an association. Who are your members?

The employees. The association has great advantages in organizing economic activities. For example, if we buy products, we do not have to organize a tender; we carry out a price survey and we know ourselves what we need and how. We are exempt from rent because the land and building belong to the municipality, which is important enough. We get water from a well; we created the borehole ourselves. Improvements to the building and surroundings happen slowly and systematically, also by attracting money from various projects. I write the project applications myself, and we implement them as an entire team.

Client geography...

...from all over Latvia – Riga, Liepāja, Kuldīga, as well as locals.

It would be valuable for people to come to you for experience exchange.

Colleagues come, look, and we talk. Recently, people from Dundaga visited me. The Talsi municipality council planned to move the Dundaga Health Centre to Lauciena; colleagues were looking for a solution. I told them and explained. I read that the council's decision has been halted, and I understand that the work there will take place in a different quality, but without changing the location of the care centre.

My work comes quite easily to me because I have worked long enough in economic tasks – I have managed several municipalities and the Sabile municipality communal service, and I am a lawyer by education. Having worked for many years, I know many people, and in everyday life, those acquaintances still come in handy.

About connections. In Latvia, the “fine style” is considered to be organizing tenders and surveys, but at the same time, the existence of personal contacts is also praised.

I am not against lobbying; maybe I just understand the term differently. For me to want to lobby someone, specific qualities of the applicant are important; for example, I would need to know perfectly whether this person's words will match their actions, whether they are sufficiently knowledgeable, and what their methods are for achieving the goal. For work to proceed successfully, I would put experience in the first place. Speaking of personal contacts, it is important to me that people know who I am and what I can do. Speaking of various tenders, the evaluators must be confident that the winner of the tender is capable of performing the relevant work.

You operate and feel quite comfortable in a field that is talked about a lot and which is sufficiently supervised (at least that is the impression that arises). How do you get along with control from various institutions?

In our work, we deal most with the Food and Veterinary Service, because the cooking takes place right here on-site. We have set up a vegetable garden on a one-hectare plot – we grow everything ourselves, store it for the winter, and put it in jars.

We work with the permission of the Ministry of Welfare. In nine years, I have neither met anyone from the ministry nor heard phone calls – “How are you doing, is there anything you need?”

I receive invitations to seminars; now and then I connect using Zoom, I listen, but mostly they talk about topics that are important and are being solved in Riga. As I mentioned at the beginning of the conversation, there is a big difference if we are talking about care homes in Riga or outside it; in the regions, the problems are completely different.

Now and then we are visited by the health inspectorate, and everything is fine with that. Some time ago there was an audit by the State Revenue Service, which concluded that we as an association were carrying out overly broad economic activity and, in their view, we would better fit the status of an LLC. That was the time when social enterprises were current. Now this situation has quieted down, and we are of little interest to state institutions.

Who manages the hectare of land that belongs to you?

We work it ourselves. We rent the land. I have very good cooperation with the State Employment Agency; in the summer period, there are so-called short-term projects where it is possible to get the necessary labour – basically, it is weeding. We organize the harvesting work bee together with the staff; everything that is to be sown, I sow myself. Potatoes grow on 0.3 ha, which we plant mechanically; we sow cucumbers last, for everything else the furrows are ploughed, just start sowing. 34 furrows, 70 m long. In autumn, we put away what has been grown with the help of all the “Kalme” inhabitants.

It is understandable that in the town and region you are a good employer and cooperation partner – jobs, the opportunity to purchase produce from local farmers, etc.

Farmers offer us what they have grown or produced themselves; they know us. We sign contracts with local firms like “Talsu piensaimnieks”, “Lēdurgas miesnieks”, and “Latvijas maiznieks”, who deliver everything themselves. Once every two weeks, SIA “Miesnieks” from Vārve parish, Ventspils municipality, and the Talsi individual enterprise “Svēde” come to us with meat products.

In the autumns we have many donors – from Matkule and Sabile they bring us potatoes, pumpkins, and cucumbers every year, as well as berries. During the season, the local Roma people from Sabile offer blueberries, cowberries, cranberries, and mushrooms.

Listening to your story, one can mentally hear a reaction from another Latvian region: “Oh! We would also love that!” What would you answer?

Why not? Everything is possible for anyone – if there is good will, a clear goal, a motivated strategy, and a good team.

As I mentioned – personal acquaintance and contacts are very important. Since I have worked with people all my life, it is quite easy for me to communicate. I can say – I know how to talk. My second principle for successful cooperation – never spit in the well from which you might have to drink. Whoever you have to talk to – whether it is a subordinate, a friend, or a boss – see the human in the interlocutor first, then things will be good.

How simple would it be to create a similar care home in some municipality or parish?

There will be a little bureaucracy. One – you must have the conviction that you want to do it. Two – you must create or choose the legal form in which you want to operate (I will immediately add – it will be difficult for a private individual). Three – premises.

...and also employees.

The employees will come after that. One employee in “Kalme” has a medical education, but everyone is trained in healthcare courses (these are mandatory for cooks). For example, today, as we are talking, a trainee carer is working with us who is on practice; we have three such people. I look, observe, “keep an eye” on things. It is important for me to build a collective – there is a significant difference whether a person arrives just to work a day (24 hours) or whether I can perceive them as part of the collective. Every year I have several trainees doing their practice here; two have stayed to work with me, but... well, I am looking for a replacement for myself because my pension start year is long behind me. For now, the searches are not very successful. This is not easy work.

Would this be work that younger people would want?

If they had offered me this work 20 years ago, I definitely would not have come, because I would not have understood the people I had to work with. A normal age for this position would be around 45-50 years, if such things are interesting and one has the appropriate skills.

It is no secret that one has to talk to many of our clients every day in the way they understand on that particular day.

When a young employee starts working, on the first day I say – you have come to work, your family stayed at home – it will not be that you run around and call someone or run off somewhere. You have work to do. Financially, we do not slight anyone – our wages have long been well above the average.

It is understandable that family members visit your clients. Does it happen that a person is brought and simply left?

Mostly that is not the case, but there are such instances. Every person's situation is different. Family members come to visit their own. During C19, the situation stimulated the idea of the need for an outdoor veranda, because those around us were ill for long enough, whereas we are sufficiently cautious. Each relative can “bring something in” to us. Bedridden clients had no visitors during C19; those who can walk themselves were dressed and taken “into the veranda” – they can meet their own, they can breathe some fresh air.

The C19 time in Latvian care institutions and boarding houses was described quite harshly. It was surprising to see a comment from a few care institution managers that “we must definitely wait for some guidance” from the ministry or some other kind of “higher-up” in order to do something in the boarding houses. Is that truly the case?

Of course, we waited for nothing. If one can say so, we survived the situation very easily. Three clients passed away from C19, but... that happened in the hospital where they ended up with another ailment, catching C19 there.

An account of an event from that period. One client, according to a doctor's instructions, had to be placed in “Ģintermuiža”. There was a place, we took them ourselves, everything was fine. The next day they called us: “Come and pick them up, there is C19 in the hospital!” We went, but... our client already had C19. We carried out all the necessary measures and ours is still alive today, and even the need for “Ģintermuiža” has disappeared.

Two employees also caught the virus. How did we fight it? Everyone has three vaccinations. The employees were vaccinated voluntarily, as were the clients. Two years in a row, everyone has also received flu shots.

The vaccine leaves a certain impression; we have observed this, for example, blood pressure fluctuating, etc. In this regard, we listened very much to what Professor Ludmila Vīksna said, knowing that such side effects could be directly caused by the vaccine; we also listened to local specialists and knew what needed to be done. Speaking of waiting for instructions, I want to emphasize that it is a very strange thought, and a boarding house manager who holds such views, it seems, is not in the right place. Every client who ends up with us signs a contract that we are responsible for this and that... If something happens, one must look at who did not fulfil the contractual obligations. What can an outsider who does not see the situation advise or instruct me? If necessary, I call an ambulance; if necessary, I ask the family doctor. We have one family doctor for all clients – that is advantageous. People get ill and will get ill, but everything depends on the manager and the care home staff who know the situation and are able to evaluate the necessary future action.

Where do you think the care field will move, how will it develop?

Care issues and processes are and will be needed, and as time passes, they will become ever more topical and necessary. The most effective service providers, in my opinion, would be private care centres. However, managing them would be much more difficult because there would be no guaranteed state and municipal funding. In “Kalme” we are already thinking about expansion, about a small extension. Difficulties and the biggest problems are caused by economic instability, the government's political steps that regulate prices and attitudes, etc. For example, unpredictable price changes. In my time, I foresightedly concluded a contract for pellet supply at the low prices valid at that time; the increase in electricity costs is also large, but we generally do not feel it. An institution manager must keep up with legislative changes. Thus, I reacted in a timely manner to the benefits due to the group I disabled people living in our centre, who use electricity and can receive benefits every month. Is it hard to send such a list to “Latvenergo”? Any signed contracts with suppliers provide stability and clarity in daily work.

It is not easy to organize and develop the senior long-term care sector in the current circumstances. The Ministry of Welfare does not show the initiative that would help fix many global things in our place, and we locally could deal more with our clients and our household. Support at the state level is lacking in terms of clarity and fixing the situation. If you ask some representative of a state institution a “more naive” question, instead of an answer, you are more likely to get control. “Say, if you are asking, then everything is not in order!” Currently, the mechanism of the care service system does not work as a unified one; each link in the chain wants to be the main and only correct one. Unfortunately, in this interaction of parts, bureaucracy often “wins” and the person for whom it all happens disappears. With the current government's policy, I do not see drastic changes in the care system.
Photographs of Maija Dubro, Inese Liopa, and zemeunvalsts.lv used

Add a comment