Climate issues, especially in recent years, have become so popular that it is considered important to mention them in almost every discussion. These topics are frequently commented upon in Latvia by socially active and well-known individuals whose daily lives and work are far removed from climate, environment, and forest-related issues or scientific research. It is presumably considered correct and modern to care about the climate; however, it is much less known or understood what exactly needs to be done so that in the fight "for the climate," something else is not lost, and that future generations do not have to struggle to restore or recover this "something else."
The most important issue of the third decade of the 21st century – climate and CO2.
Āris Jansons: One of the currently topical questions is what is actually happening with carbon storage, but (!!!!) this question also has a very significant second part – what is "happening in the documents" regarding this storage. What gets written down or included in documents at various levels does not always reflect or match what is actually happening in nature. A large proportion of documents concerning or relating to the mitigation of climate change define reference periods against which changes occurring over time are calculated; the choice of a different period can significantly affect the result. Similarly, there are areas whose contribution (positive or negative) to climate change mitigation is "counted," and those which are "not counted."

If we assess the situation in nature – when we plant a tree, we plant a tree; if a tree is felled and exported, it is clear that in the place where this tree ends up, this renewable resource will be used, meaning if wood is used, plastic will not be, and logically, we will mitigate climate change.
If we look at the "paperwork" – by exporting logs, Latvia does not gain; the "paper" says that we only derive a benefit if we use this same wood in construction right here in Latvia. But wood remains wood – the climate is global, and the opportunities to reduce the use of fossil resources by replacing them with wood create a global positive impact.
In the climate plan until 2030, its drafters have planned to afforest territories and limit emissions. What would be the most important thing to do in Latvia’s forest and agricultural sector that could and should be done, without reading regulations or other documents?
Andis Lazdiņš: The story would be very long with an even longer introduction – namely – it would be necessary to explain what should be done, what has not been done, why, and what will definitely have to be done in the future.
Until 2025, Latvia has the opportunity to "rest on its laurels" because all necessary requirements will have been met, perhaps with the exception of agriculture, transport, and energy.
In the land-use sector, everything will be fine until 2025, but... it is clearly understood that we cannot treat land use like a vehicle – when the time comes to meet obligations, we put the diesel car in the shed, take an electric car, and everything will be fine. In the land-use sector, in order to meet obligations that will arise in 30 years, one must act already this year, and it would have been even better to have done so 10 years ago. Problems with meeting obligations will begin after 2030. The amendments to the regulation on the inclusion of the land sector in emission reduction commitments (841/2000), which will determine commitments for 2026-2030, will enter into force at the beginning of summer, and there will be no way back or excuses then, because such an optimistic scenario calculation that Latvia could meet its obligations by doing nothing will not be possible. We will not be able to create one.
But by 2050, Latvia must be climate-neutral, and the land sector must also cover agricultural emissions.
Is everything that simple?
AL: Our big problem, which hinders the resolution of Latvia’s climate neutrality, is the very large amount of peat soils. We can eliminate them "on paper," for example, by defining that our peat soils start at a depth of 1 metre and, if the peat layer is thinner, it is no longer peat soil. The "paper" will accept it, and we will not be original in using such a solution, but someone may come along and point out that until now we have assumed the peat thickness threshold was different...

Could soil mapping provide some clarity?
AL: Mapping is being organized for a different purpose; from the perspective of recording commitments defined by the nature restoration regulation, the situation will become clearer, but from the emissions perspective, nothing will change.
If the emphasis in climate matters is placed on reducing the use of fossil resources, what can be done? Speaking of soils – we cannot replace them... After all, bogs and peat are natural.
AL: Relatively natural. Bogs on the planet are a large source of emissions – I will not speak for Latvian bogs – but, for example, huge areas of bogs exist in Western Siberia, and people of my generation have known since school that this region produces a lot of methane emissions. In the seventies, Sweden was seriously studying the possibility of collecting methane from bogs. We do not count bogs as a source of emissions because they are natural; the bog lives its own life, but as soon as a human arrives and sticks in a spade, we start counting, assuming that these emissions are the result of our activities (work). It is similar in forests – we do not count emissions in wet forests, assuming they are natural, but we do count them in drained forests because that is supposedly the result of human activity. Even though in reality the volume of emissions decreases after drainage, they are counted. The situation is currently being assessed incorrectly, by exaggerating the negative impact of economic activity.
ĀJ: There – a perfect example of the difference between what is happening "on paper," where there is no impact, and what is happening in nature. In "nature," there is actually a significant negative impact, i.e., greenhouse gases are being emitted.
Where has such an absurdity come from?
AL: This is not a condition of the aforementioned regulation; this rule is included in the guidelines issued for the implementation of the UN Climate Convention, which state that anthropogenic emissions should be recorded. Interpretations are up to us, but the problem lies in the fact that it is considered that "if water is flooded onto once-drained areas, everything becomes good and excellent there." Such a view exists, but there is not a single scientific proof of it in Latvia.
Would that be the implementation of the term rewetting?
AL: The opinion on this is stereotypical; we are fighting against it, but, unfortunately, we are in the minority in Europe in this regard. Rewetting is advocated by those countries that essentially no longer have peat soils, such as Germany, and where the effect of rewetting is demonstrated on previously intensively used agricultural lands, which are absolutely not comparable to forest lands or peat fields.
The Germans are "rewetting" agricultural lands: if chemical fertilizers are no longer used on such areas and their cultivation is stopped, it is clear that emissions will decrease. Now they want to apply this same principle to our wet forest lands and grasslands.
I have a good example of emission reduction, even though I am tired of it myself, but – in many publications describing the emission reduction effect, it will be noted in small print that this was achieved by removing a metre or half-metre thick fertile top layer of soil, which decomposes elsewhere, but in the specific area, of course, emissions go down.

I have no respect for this type of "science."
ĀJ: I agree with Andis, but I would like to steer the conversation into a local – Latvian – channel, because if we criticize German practice on a Latvian-language portal, it is unlikely anything will change, no matter how right we are.
The situation described by Andis, unfortunately, characterizes the objective reality in the European Union, where we are a small player. It is important to emphasize that there are a number of studies, including those taking place right here in Latvia, which in essence form the experimental base to better characterize reality. Namely – what happens with organic soils in a situation when we do something, and what happens in a situation when we do something or nothing.
Paradoxically – one thing is what we actually do in relation to climate, and the second is what we record according to the regulations. There are a number of situations where there is no consistency between the "paper" and reality.
AL: Closing the topic on organic soils, by comparison, from a climate perspective, they would be as big a problem as our car fleet, both thermal power plants, and the other chimneys combined, however many there are in Latvia. The solution costs much less if we compare it to the costs that would arise if we had to switch to electric vehicles – areas that are currently creating emissions should be afforested. That would be one thing.
Furthermore – within the limits of possibility, drainage systems should be installed in areas where there are none. It must be remembered that the task of installing drainage systems is to reduce the risk of natural disturbances, including preventing periodic flooding, for example, in the spring. In mid-summer, the groundwater level in drained and non-drained areas in a forest does not differ particularly.
Do we have much free land in Latvia to afforest? Besides, drainage is currently considered something quite terrible and unsupportable.
AL: In terms of afforestation, we are talking about agricultural land; drainage systems should be installed on forest land. As for it being considered "terrible" – I will say – "it is terrible that people think that way about drainage."
ĀJ: It must be admitted that in recent times the attitude towards drainage in forests is changing, recovering an understanding of its positive influence. We can also strengthen the role of the forest in mitigating climate change using the Sprīdītis approach – with a spade. One can dig a ditch, one can plant a tree: and there is a positive effect.
How much land would we have to afforest, if we estimate in hectares?
AL: If we approach everything mathematically, it would be 150,000–160,000 hectares of areas with organic soils, with investments calculated at approximately €300 million to ensure the necessary production of seedlings.

What would, for example, an agricultural land owner do in practice (day-to-day) if existing fields were afforested?
AJ: I think – the landowners would continue their work – growing, tending, and looking after the forest. Basically, meadows and permanent grasslands would be the areas to be afforested.
What do the biodiversity conditions and supporters say about this?
AL: That is a different story, and many will not agree with my opinion. Namely, I think that a meadow is not a natural formation for Latvian conditions and under no circumstances should it be entitled to biodiversity maintenance payments, nor should its maintenance be supported. Why? In the place where we now see a meadow, a forest grew in earlier times. It is not understandable why in one case a man-made ecosystem is not acceptable, for example, planted forests or forests with drained soils, but in another case – grasslands, for the maintenance of which they are even paid extra.
ĀJ: We are talking about the fact that small areas should be preserved, such as floodplain meadows (that would be a few thousand hectares) or cultural-historical heritage, which is part of the Latvian landscape. The question is, how much of that do we need and how much would it be necessary?
AL: And – who will pay for it? In a climate context – if, for example, over the next 40 years we can sequester about 40,000 tonnes of carbon in an afforested area of 1,000 hectares, at the same time, by maintaining cultural-historical heritage, this sequestration will not occur and the state will pay for non-compliance with obligations. Someone will have to pay for the maintenance of this heritage.
When the tractor replaced the horse, the need for pastures decreased. If we calculate the number of animals and the area of meadows, comparing it with European averages, we need either three times more animals to graze, or the area of meadows must be reduced three times over, or a compromise must be found that would allow both major agricultural industries to develop and climate goals to be met.
How to act wisely?
AL: The problem is political concession, which I do not wish to delve into because it is not my sphere. Also, very important is the issue of resources and capacity – a smart, state-minded, and motivated civil servant can work in a ministry, but is faced with 5-6 NGO representatives who unargumentatively impose their opinion, insult, and refer to "commonly known truths." Resisting this and defending one’s scientifically grounded opinion is not simple.
How is afforestation assessed elsewhere in Europe?
AL: It is not assessed positively, and not only in Latvia; it is not a supported measure, although in the climate policies of European countries, it is the main measure for achieving climate neutrality goals.
If harvesting is bad, and planting is also bad, what changes in this situation?
ĀJ: If we do not harvest and do not plant, it means that we will have to live and get by on something else. This "something else" could be a situation where, for example, the rest of Europe will pay us for living and doing nothing, but... even in rich European countries, funds are not infinite; printing money does not lead to a good end, and value or a product must come from somewhere. Latvia is a relatively sparsely populated region, which cannot be said about Europe as a whole. There are and will be many people, and their economic interests will have to be reckoned with. In my opinion, one important thing is often forgotten – climate change occurs because we use fossil resources. That is a very, very important aspect that is carefully ignored in debates about the climate. If we did not use fossil resources so much, there would be no climate change.

Again, do not touch... A similar situation was also discussed in Latvia – we will not use gas, which is not good, but we will not use biomass either. Will we freeze as a result?
ĀJ: Biomass is what is in motion between the biosphere and the atmosphere. By using biomass, we can cause harm to someone who may have nowhere to live (rare species). We must look at how to distribute the use of biomass in the landscape and space so as not to disturb someone's (bird, animal, rare plant) living environment. In our latitudes, we have and will need a warm house. If, in addition to everything mentioned, electric cars, etc., will be needed, electricity from hydroelectric power plants will not be enough. In Latvia, we are very far from the capacity of local wind and solar parks to provide what is necessary. Until that happens, there are two alternatives – fossil or renewable. Therefore, the use of biomass is logical and will also be necessary in the future. It must be remembered that no one is talking about burning logs – for energy production, mostly what is left over is used – shavings are created in any sawing; as long as we do not grow square trees – off-cuts are also created, there are lower-value parts of trees, branches – heat from all of this is much "greener" than from coal or any other fossil resource.
What about the climate situation and old-growth forests?
AL: In the context of the Biodiversity Strategy, I remember a situation when the EC was not yet "sufficiently clever," and listened to and used the advice of scientists. The director of the Danish Forest Institute, in a heated discussion about whether not logging forests would solve climate problems, stood up and asked the environmental NGO representatives: "Where have you seen eternally living trees?" Trees do not live forever, so the story that we will stop logging and happiness will arrive is nonsense, not to mention that wood is a material from which houses are built and furniture is made. The myth of old-growth forests and eternally living trees is currently extremely widespread.
ĀJ: Turnover in the forest happens also without human intervention. Trees grow, a storm or bark beetle comes, or fire, or something else – some trees die, some continue to grow, some young ones grow together with the old ones, etc. The average amount or volume of trees per hectare will thus be much less than if we manage the forest, purposefully growing it. A human works in the forest because they are capable of ensuring that in a certain unit of time from a certain unit of area, they will obtain a higher result. That is the essence of forestry.
What does this mean? Over a longer period of time, by neglecting the forest and doing nothing in it, a system untouched by humans (doing nothing) will have a much smaller impact on climate change mitigation compared to a system in which we manage and tend to it.
AL: If we do not manage forests in Latvia, someone else will do it elsewhere; for example, we will make furniture from foreign material. As usual, we will transfer problems to other lands and forget about them.
ĀJ: Lately, I like to repeat a good thought – take a globe, look at it, and... understand that there is no room on it for "somewhere else." There is Chile, Spain, Italy, but there is absolutely no land or territory called "somewhere else." If we need a certain amount of raw material, including to replace various plastics, the best place where we can obtain this raw material is here, with us!

We can work carefully enough, thinking both about the environment and the landscape, while simultaneously obtaining the necessary material. If we control it ourselves, everything will be fine. If timber is obtained "somewhere else," we will be unable to control or change environmental issues and their impact. However, for now, Europe is accustomed to exporting its problems, much like it used to transport plastic to China, batteries and old computers elsewhere, etc., and to announce that, for example, forestry is not needed here. But we will not be able to do that for much longer – other countries do not need our problems either; we must think about how we can effectively provide for ourselves with a renewable resource – wood. By changing our perspective in this way, management will also proceed more meaningfully.
The previously mentioned director of the Danish Forest Institute and her call to think about reality are quite significant. Very many people in Latvia also refer to science. Have you thought about what is happening wrong and what is happening right in our climate matters?
ĀJ: The involvement of scientists is essential for describing reality and understanding how it will change in the future. In the future, natural disturbances will significantly intensify: there will be more frequent storms, more pronounced drought periods, more frequent mass outbreaks of individual insect species, etc. This means that the average life expectancy of a tree will decrease. In managed forests, the impact of these factors can be reduced by promoting tree resilience and reducing the time period during which they are exposed to these impacts – thus achieving that trees of specific dimensions are reached faster. And that is good not only for those who need renewable resources (i.e., all of us), but also for those who like to see vital trees out of their window or go mushrooming, picking berries, or doing something else in the forest (i.e., again – all of us). Larger trees are also good for the woodpecker and lichen and a range of other living nature elements. Of course, remembering that in the mosaic of the forest landscape there are also territories without economic activity for those parts of nature for which such things are essential.
Returning to the story about forest management, I will emphasize that in Latvia, a reasonably thinking middle-aged person is capable of growing a tree in their lifetime, if they take existing scientific knowledge into their practice – selection, drainage, returning nutrients to the forest, etc. In a country that is not totalitarian, the goal of legislation is to promote (encourage) people towards purposeful action, to create opportunities and facilitate the availability of knowledge. Not to regulate every step a person takes.
AL: Speaking of positive examples – one is last year’s amendments to the Forest Law (forest management regulations), which for the first time in 30 years encourage forest regeneration. Yes, as is known, these regulations are currently being reviewed by the Constitutional Court. In this regard, we must look towards the Nordic countries, where police-like restrictions do not exist; they have no place in our society either. We have been living in an independent country for the 33rd year, but Soviet habits keep dragging along...
Speaking of nature protection issues, specific species or territories are usually mentioned. For some time now, the topic has been about percentages of protected areas. How scientifically justified is that?
ĀJ: In nature protection, effectiveness is also essential – how specific areas (and activities carried out or not carried out in them) achieve the desired goal. And dynamics – taking into account the principle of landscape ecological planning, understanding that it is not sensible to solve everything with stationary nature protection areas.
AL: It is difficult to formulate thoughts politely in response to the question... I can return to the old-growth forests mentioned in the conversation. These will not be forests from which income could be derived; most likely, they will not be managed at all; grief and problems will come from there, similar to long-unmanaged territories that we see here and there in Latvia even now. I assume that agricultural land will not be included in the list of protected areas; they will focus on forests.
In untouched forests, there will be lower carbon sequestration; they will create additional emissions. What does this mean? Somewhere else in the world, there will be cultivated and well-managed areas where they will produce what we no longer produce. In Latvia, problems will be created, for example, by unfulfilled obligations and quotas (in millions of tonnes and tens of millions of euros) that will need to be bought. Who will pay for all that? This needs to be realized – protected areas are not and will not be income; they are costs! That is calculable.
For example, there is a requirement to rewet 70% of organic soils on agricultural land by 2050. One cannot answer anything sensible to such a proposal... One could fill in the straits between the Baltic and North Seas, which would cause trouble for other European countries. There are no other technical possibilities to implement this plan.
There is no scientific explanation for such nonsense. Currently, discussions are underway about a different solution – one could rewet part of the extracted peat bogs and part of the forests with peat soils, but as a result, we will "gain" just as large emissions from agricultural lands and increased emissions from forest lands. The situation will not be pleasant. Furthermore, there is a general impression that by flooding or rewetting areas, emissions remain lower, but by performing real measurements, one concludes that emissions increase.
How to prevent such absurdities?
ĀJ: Part of the problems arises from the distribution of people in the European Union and their different interests. That area of the EU where forestry is an important sector of the national economy, which could produce wood so that Europe could get rid of plastic, is relatively small and sparsely populated compared, for example, with the Rhine-Ruhr basin. In a democratic society, the majority determines the result. European metropolises have more voters...
What happens? A politician looks at the situation and assesses – "how will my voter feel?" Perhaps this politician knows how it would be correct to act, but he must think about whether he will be elected if he acts correctly. There is no need to look for conspiracy theories here; it is a clear calculation. Therefore, it is even more essential to conduct scientific research and objectively characterize reality, disseminate information about the results of these studies, and discuss with decision-makers both in Latvia and in Europe. And that is what we are doing.
AL: If we find the so-called LULUCF regulation (2018/841) and the documents related to it on the European Commission's website, and look at the opinion documents there, 99% of those expressing opinions are various types of NGOs, including pseudo-scientific findings. There are no scientific opinions there, and there are no forest industry opinions there either. I will remind you of what was said in the conversation about the civil servant – no matter how knowledgeable and smart he is, how long will he have the strength and will to defend himself against the opinions of vaguely motivated and well-funded NGOs?
Photographs from zemeunvalsts.lv used, taken in various years at the Forest Science Days organized by the Latvian State Forest Research Institute "Silava"



