The Constitutional Court (ST) has ruled that a provision reducing the diameter threshold for final felling is incompatible with the Constitution.
This is the first time that the question of forest management and its sustainability in Latvia has been assessed by the ST. The ST stresses that legislation which may have a significant impact on the environment must be comprehensively assessed, balancing the interests of public welfare, the environment and the economy.
The judgment states that the state is entitled to take decisions that may have an impact on the environment, but these must be in line with the principle of sustainability enshrined in the Constitution – comprehensively assessed, balancing the interests of public welfare, the environment and the economy. Equally important is the precautionary principle contained in Article 115 of the Constitution, which requires, among other things, that all possible adverse consequences be identified and assessed before an activity is undertaken.
As the ST notes, a development planning system has been established to promote the country's sustainability, under which various development planning documents, including policy guidelines, are drawn up. Sectoral policy guidelines require a strategic environmental impact assessment, which ensures that environmental protection interests are taken into account and the precautionary principle observed in the process of adopting environment-related planning documents. The ST recognised that the development directions and policy objectives set out in a policy planning document must be taken into account in the process of drafting a piece of legislation. This promotes compliance with the principle of sustainability and the precautionary principle.
It was concluded that the contested provision establishes a solution that was not included in the Guidelines for the Development of the Forest and Related Sectors, and that the reduction of the final felling diameter therefore does not comply with the policy objective set out in the guidelines of implementing measures to increase the value of forests. At the same time, the ST concluded that, since the contested provision serves as the legal basis for an activity that may have an impact on the environment, it is in substance equivalent to a planning document for which a strategic assessment must be carried out before adoption.
In assessing whether the contested provision may have a significant impact on the environment, the ST finds that several risks that could cause environmental harm were known at the time the contested provision was drafted. The Cabinet of Ministers had assessed these risks in part, concluding that no significant environmental impact was to be expected. However, the ST points out that the actions taken by the Cabinet of Ministers do not indicate a comprehensive assessment of the possible environmental impact. Moreover, a strategic assessment must consider both favourable and unfavourable impacts together. The fact that additional requirements are laid down which may have a favourable effect on the environment cannot be a reason for not carrying out a strategic assessment. Accordingly, the information in the case indicated that the contested provision may have a significant impact on the environment or on a protected nature territory of European importance.
In view of the above, the ST concluded that in the case under review the Cabinet of Ministers had not followed the procedure by which, before adopting a piece of legislation that may have a significant impact on the environment, the significance of the possible environmental impact and the need to carry out a strategic assessment must be assessed. Had that procedure been followed, it is possible that a different decision would have been taken regarding the need for a strategic assessment. The ST therefore recognised that the principle of sustainability and the precautionary principle were not observed in the process of adopting the contested provision, and that the contested provision is thus incompatible with Article 115 of the Constitution.
The ST ruled on the restoration of the legal force of the provision that had been in effect until the contested provision entered into force. The Constitutional Court held that the contested provision is deemed void from the moment it entered into force, and that Annex 7 to the Cabinet of Ministers regulations of 18 December 2012, "Regulations on the Felling of Trees in Forests", in the wording in force until 29 June 2022, is to be restored in the part in which the contested provision had repealed it.
Liene Brizga-Kalniņa, a representative of the Latvian Fund for Nature (LDF), previously reported that in 2022 the Cabinet of Ministers adopted amendments to the regulations on the felling of trees in forests which reduced the felling diameter, thereby permitting the felling of thinner, and thus younger, trees in the majority of pine, spruce and birch forests. For this reason, at the end of 2022 several environmental organisations turned to the ST to request an assessment of whether the decision complied with Article 115 of the Constitution, which provides for the state's duty to establish and ensure an effective environmental protection system and also encompasses the individual right to live in a benign environment.
Environmental organisations turned to the ST because they want to preserve Latvia's forests for the people of Latvia
The environmental organisations took the view that not all the impacts of the amendments had been assessed, including their effect on biodiversity, and that there is therefore a risk that the share of old, biologically diverse forests in Latvia will decline even further. At present such forests account for only 10% of Latvia's forest area. Felling ever younger trees will affect both biodiversity and the capacity of forests to absorb greenhouse gas emissions, and will increase forest fragmentation, thereby affecting the shared living environment of people.
Viesturs Ķerus, head of the Latvian Ornithological Society, previously pointed out that, according to the definition set out in the Forest Law, conserving biodiversity is one of the fundamental principles of sustainable forest management. Yet both these particular amendments and Latvian forest management policy as a whole treat the conservation of natural diversity as some external factor, something that others should think about rather than forest policymakers and forest managers. As a result, forests are being depleted, losing biodiversity and consequently also resilience, V. Ķerus believes.
During the court proceedings, various parties involved were heard – representatives of environmental organisations as well as representatives of the forestry sector and the government, along with invited persons.
The claim was submitted to the ST by the LDF, the Latvian Ornithological Society and the World Wide Fund for Nature. The submission of the claim was supported by the association Zaļā brīvība and the Latvian Association of Organic Agriculture.
The legal consultant for the preparation of the claim is the law firm Cobalt, which provided support in preparing the case pro bono, that is, free of charge. The preparation of the application was also partly financed by the Active Citizens Fund.



