Is there anything you can gain from a business management master's degree that a philosophy doctorate couldn't beat?
During the seven years I worked as a management consultant, I spent a lot of time struggling to look older than I actually was. I got quite good at knitting my brow and wearing a solemn expression. Those who saw through it assumed that my youth was offset by an excellent education in business management. Here they were mistaken. I do not have a master's degree in business. I have a doctorate in philosophy – specifically, 19th-century German philosophy. Before I started teaching senior executives of large corporations things that these people clearly should have known already, my work experience was limited to earning extra money by consulting grumpy undergraduate students on the wisdom of Hegel and Nietzsche, and a series of summer jobs, mostly at the less appetising end of the fast food industry.
The oddest thing was that my complete lack of a management education seemed to make no difference. As one of the main partners and founders of a consulting firm that gradually grew to 600 employees, I interviewed, hired, and worked shoulder-to-shoulder with hundreds of business school graduates. I got the impression that this whole business master's thing requires one to write off two years of one's life and be up to one's ears in debt. And all that just to learn how not to smirk when pronouncing phrases like "thinking outside the box", "win-win situation" and "core competencies". When I needed to choose people to work in a team with, I placed the greatest hopes on people who had spent their university years studying something other than business management.
After leaving the consulting business, contrary to the natural order of things, I decided to delve into management literature. Partly because I wanted to "process" my own experience and find out what I had missed by not choosing to study at a business school. Partly because I simply had a lot of free time. Digging through volumes on competitive strategy, business process re-engineering, and similar matters, I never once caught myself thinking: "Damn! If only I had known this earlier!" On the contrary, I noticed thoughts popping into my head that would have seemed unlikely before, say: "I would much rather be reading Heidegger right now!" This process unnerved me unpleasantly. The veil of mystery thickened around the question that had been gnawing at me from the very beginning of my business career, namely: why does management education exist at all?
Management theory was born in 1899 with a simple question: "How many tons of pig iron can one worker load onto a train wagon in the course of a working day?" The man in whose mind this question was born is Frederick Winslow Taylor, the author of "The Principles of Scientific Management" and, as most believe, the founding father of management business.
When the aforementioned pig iron question struck Taylor, he was forty-three years old and had signed a contract with the Bethlehem Steel Company. Across the factory yard, which occupied several square miles of the Pennsylvania landscape, he watched as workers loaded into train wagons bars that weighed forty-one kilograms each. There were 80,000 tons of such iron bars that had to be carted away as quickly as possible to satisfy the new demand created by the Spanish-American War. Taylor squinted: he was convinced that the case was not without losses. Having quickly checked the ledgers at the company headquarters, he estimated that each of the men was loading iron into the wagons at an average speed of twelve and a half tons a day.
Taylor stormed back into the yard like a whirlwind, taking his assistants with him ("college men", as he called these people), and rounded up a bunch of the best loaders ("first-class men"), who in this case turned out to be ten "big, burly Hungarians." He offered to double the workers' wages if they agreed to participate in an experiment. The Hungarians, desperate to please their supposed benefactor, showed what they could do. Gasping and puffing up and down the train wagon ramps, they loaded sixteen and a half tons in about fourteen minutes. Taylor quickly calculated: taking a ten-hour working day, it came out to seventy-five tons a day from each man. Naturally, time had to be allowed for visits to the lavatory, lunch, and catching one's breath, so he reduced the figure by about forty per cent. Henceforth, every labourer at the company was tasked with loading forty-seven and a half tons of pig iron a day. Bonuses were provided for meeting the target, and fines for failing to do so.
When the Hungarians realised that they were being asked to quadruple their existing daily load, they began to shout and refused to work. Then Taylor found a "very expensive man", a lean Pennsylvania Dutchman whose mental faculties he equated with the gifts of an ox. Tempted by the promise of increasing his pay by 60%, from 1.15 to a full 1.85 dollars a day, Taylor's very expensive man loaded forty-five and three-quarter tons into the wagon during one hard day's work – enough for this achievement to be recognised in Taylor's mind as a victory for modern management methods.
Taylor continued his work, further turning to the fine art of shovelling and a whole series of other questions that occupied his industrial clients. He declared that this new and unusual approach to solving business problems was nothing more or less than a "true mental revolution". In time, urged on by followers, he dubbed his method "scientific management". And so the idea was born that management is a science – a body of knowledge collected and nurtured by experts, guided by neutral, objective, and universal standards.
At that very moment, the notion also saw the light of day that management is a special function best handled by a special category of people – people distinguished from the rest by special education, way of speaking, and manner of dress. Taylor, who was fond of manly prose, expressed it best in paragraphs such as the following insight: "... the loading of pig iron is such a great skill and plays such a mighty role that it is impossible for the man best suited for this type of work to understand the principles of this science or even simply work in accordance with them without the help of a better-educated person." Looking from a metaphysical perspective, one could say that Taylor was a "dualist": there are brains and there are muscles, but he believed these things met in one place very rarely.
Taylor travelled the country, repeating the pig iron epic and other stories from the days he spent in the factory yard before his audiences. From these narratives, a kind of gospel for a new and highly motivated cult of management experts was formed. Along with the founding of the first business schools, this avant-garde finally pressed into the very citadel of the ruling circles. In the spring of 1908, Taylor met with several Harvard professors, and after just a few months, the university opened the first master's programme offering a scientific degree in business. Its first-year curriculum was based on Taylor's scientific management. From 1909 to 1914, Taylor visited Cambridge, Massachusetts, every winter with a lecture course – a thoroughly inspiring discourse was only slightly marred by the lecturer's habit, acquired in factory shops, of swearing coarsely at the most inappropriate moments.
However, just as Taylor's ideas about management began to gain popularity, a whole series of weaknesses in his approach also came to light. The first thing that many commentators noted about scientific management is that there is almost no science in it at all. The most significant variable in Taylor's pig iron calculations was that 40% "adjustment" he had calculated by extrapolating from a 14-minute sample of one working day. Why measure everything a bunch of Hungarians do with second-by-second precision if the fine results are then smeared with such a piece of guesswork? Later, when Taylor was questioned on this matter before Congress, he carelessly mentioned the fact that in other experiments such "adjustments" varied from 20 to 225 per cent. He defended this ugly, as one might say in the language of business management master's students, "thumb-sucking" as the fruits of his "judgement" and "experience", but it is perfectly clear that the very purpose of scientific management is to eliminate the need to rely on such variables shrouded in mystery.
One of the most characteristic features required for any theory that aspires to the name of science is the ability to repeat experimentally obtained results. However, Taylor never published the data on which his pig iron loading theory or any other conclusions were based. When Carl Barth, one of his loyal followers, took over the work at the Bethlehem Steel Company, he found that Taylor's data was unusable. Another, even more essential characteristic of science – and here I invoke the shadow of Karl Popper – is that it must put forward falsifiable propositions. While Taylor devoted attention to such mundane activities as loading bars onto a train wagon, he did indeed come up with assumptions that could be refuted (and this was often done). However, as soon as he turned his gaze to business management as such, he seemed capable of nothing more than inspired banalities. As a result, his "method" can be expressed in a couple of slogans: "Think more! Work smarter! Buy a stopwatch!" Taylorism, like a large part of subsequent business management theory, is in its essence a collection of quasi-religious aphorisms about how good it is to be good at what you do, enclosed in a protective shell of figurative parables (also known as case study analysis).
In 1901, Bethlehem fired Taylor and simply liquidated all his implemented systems. And yet, when Taylor travelled the country, preaching the doctrine of efficiency before countless audiences, this obvious lack of a concrete result did not prevent him from continuing to speak to his listeners through his parables.
In business management literature of this time, Taylorism, if it is mentioned at all, is treated as a chapter of ancient history; over the last century, Taylor's successors have developed a mighty arsenal that allows business problems to be solved with all sorts of statistical methods and analytical approaches. And yet the world of management still rests firmly on the foundations of Taylorism. At its best, business management theory echoes the principles of American democracy. It aims to replace the despotism of the old bosses with the rule of law of science. It offers economic power to everyone who has enough talent and energy to achieve it. The revolution in corporate management must be counted among the same expansion of economic opportunity that has contributed so much to the prosperity of us all. However, by claiming an esoteric credibility to which it has no right, management theory betrays the very ideals on which it is based.
Taylorism and its modern variations are often just a way of putting the workforce in its place. From the Hungarians' point of view, the entire pig iron experiment was just an unimaginably dull way of demanding more work for less pay. However, it is equally true that management theory is a hidden attack on capital. (The Soviet five-year planning process was directly inspired by one of Taylor's most ardent followers, the engineer Henry L. Gantt. A large part of business management theory today essentially serves to satisfy class interests – and that is neither those of the capitalists nor the working people, but a completely new social group: the manager class.)
Based on personal experience, I can testify that management consultants continue to worship at the same altar of numerology where Taylor once sacrificed his first piece of guesswork. I, too, felt forced in many projects to flatter recalcitrant statistical data with figures concocted entirely by my own efforts. But I humbly yield the seat of honour to a colleague of mine, a stern and life-hardened Belgian whose hobby was collecting hunting trophies and a new mathematical technique of his own invention, which was nicknamed "two-handed regression". When data that should have shown the relationship between two variables demonstrated only a shapeless cloud – even though we knew perfectly well that there had to be some connection between them – he would place his fleshy hands on the offending spots, and after a moment, he would reveal a line that had previously been hidden from the view of conventional mathematics.
Modern management theory is usually so painful to read not because of the lack of reliable empirical data. For that, we must thank its infuriating infallibility, worthy of the Pope. Yes, of course, you can find a pearl of insight here and there and a couple of stories about heroic company executives that can taste like lousy popcorn. But everything else is simply idiocy. Those who have tried to find out what "business process re-engineering" actually means, the most frankly Taylorist of recent business management fashion whims, have been rewarded for their efforts with gems of vacuity such as "BPR means going to work with a blank sheet of paper" and "BPR means rethinking everything, absolutely everything!"
Each subsequent management fashion whim compels one to focus on a different virtue – first it is efficiency, then quality, then satisfying the customer's wishes, and finally the matter reaches the point where one must return to efficiency once again. If this reminds one of the toothless wisdom offered by self-help literature, that is because management theory is for the most part a subgenre of self-help lore. By that, I do not mean to say that it is completely useless. However, just as most people are able to live a full life without consulting Deepak Chopra, most managers can probably spare themselves the schooling in the wisdom of business management theory.
The world of business management theorists is not subject to the necessity of accounting for results. Consultants' recommendations have the same semantic properties as campaign promises: recalled after a year, they seem almost whimsical.
While participating in the closure of a large European bank branch, I noted in my calculations that one of the competing consulting firms had swindled them for 5 million dollars for its services. "They were supposedly meant to save the company," a client manager said with a groan. "No, actually, what was required of them was that the illusion be maintained for as long as it took for the boss to find a new job," he immediately corrected himself. Were our competitors held accountable for failing to put the company on its feet and/or violating the unshakeable ethical standards of consulting firms? On the contrary, they soon collected an even larger sum in another wing of the same organisation.
And that is exactly what I did, too. Truth be told, we quite liked failing companies – usually, you could earn quite a lot of money propping up these companies before they finally went under. True, the auditing firm Arthur Andersen did sink after Enron. But what happened to pillars like McKinsey, which received millions of dollars in fees from Enron and supplied the company with its responsible officials? The Enron saga is not just about bad deeds or faked accounting; it is about sensible business practice being confused with trendy business management ideas, to which the powers that be in the management world continue to sing praises with great pleasure until the party is finally over.
If one is to believe our HR manager, the consulting firm I helped found embodied a complete rejection of the Taylorism practised by ordinary companies. In our firm, the determining factor was not bureaucratic control and robotic efficiency in the pursuit of money. The main thing was love.
We were typical children of our time. The business gurus of the 90s were unanimously convinced that a radically new form of human cooperation would appear in the world at any moment, which they tended to label with different names: "information-based organisation", "intellectual holding company", "learning organisation", and "ever-creative organisation". "The end of bureaucracy" is near, wrote Gifford Pinchot, famous for his own coined term "intrapreneur" ("intracorporate entrepreneur"). Much good can be said about the "new" organisation of the 90s. And who would want to stand against creative spirit, freedom, opportunities for initiative, and – yes, let's call a spade a spade – love? However, one thing cannot be said about this "new" organisation – namely, that it is new.
In 1983, Harvard Business School professor Rosabeth Moss Kanter stole a march on the apparent revolutionaries of the nineties by arguing that the rigid "segmentalist" corporate bureaucracy was already beginning to retreat before new "integrative" organisations that would be "informal" and "change-oriented". However, Kanter only summarised a view that had been sufficiently widespread since at least 1961, when Tom Burns and G. M. Stalker published an influential work in which they criticised the old, "mechanistic" organisation and advocated for the new, "organic" one. Using vocabulary that evokes ghostly associations with some much later internet company advertisement, they described how innovative firms gain advantages from "lateral" (as opposed to "vertical") information flow, coordination centres created to solve specific issues, and constant redefinition of job responsibilities. The first to praise the "flat" organisation was James C. Worthy in a study on "Sears" published in the 40s, while W. B. Given coined the term "bottom-up management" in 1949. And then there was also Mary Parker Follett, who already in the 20s went on the attack against "departmental" thinking, praised change-oriented and informal structures, and expressed support for the "integrative" organisation.
The meaning of this long and strangely forgetful tradition of "humanistic" organisation theory's eternally repeated collective is best explained by the work of Harvard Business School professor Elton Mayo in the 20s. The Australian Mayo was the direct opposite of Taylor: sophisticated, educated in the best educational institutions, slightly antisocial, and somewhat decadently oriented – perhaps too familiar with the ideas of Freudian psychoanalysis.
A researcher named Homer Hibarger had for some time tested in practice the theory about the effect of workplace lighting on worker productivity. It will surprise no one that his work was sponsored by a manufacturer of electric light bulbs. Homer turned on the lights for a group of workers who were assembling telephone relays and receiver coils. Productivity increased. Then he turned the lights off. Productivity continued to increase! Homer, in complete bewilderment, resorted to other means of influence. First, he told the "girls" that they would be entitled to two five-minute breaks every day. Productivity increased. The next step was the announcement of six breaks a day. Productivity increased again. Then he allowed them to finish work one hour earlier every day than usual. Another increase. Free lunches and refreshments. Increase! And then Homer cancelled the breaks, restored the previous length of the working day, and eliminated the free lunches. But productivity decreased only just perceptibly.
Mayo, who was called in to find some explanation for the results, was in a state of high excitement. His theory: various types of intervention in workplace routine are an insignificant factor compared to the new interpersonal dynamics created by the experimental situation itself. "What actually happened," he wrote, "was that six individuals became a team, and this team spontaneously devoted its energy to common work with full dedication. [...] The workers felt that they were participating in what was happening voluntarily and enjoyed the consciousness that they were working without coercion." The conclusions Mayo drew from this experiment do not differ at all from the teaching of the 90s business gurus: vertical hierarchies based on notions of rationality and control are bad; "flat" organisations based on freedom, common work, and flexible definitions of job responsibilities are good.
Going into more detail, however, it turned out that two workers who had been identified as "not sufficiently cooperative" at the start of the experiment had been replaced by "friendlier" women. Even more disturbing is the fact that both of the particularly responsive individuals received significantly higher pay for their participation in the experiment. Later, in response to his critics, Mayo claimed that such a primitive factor as financial stimulation could not possibly explain the miracle he had witnessed. That did not make his method much more "scientific".
Mayo's work allows us to see more clearly the dark side of the "humanistic" tradition of management theory. The thought of a man who, armed with a clipboard, hangs around a group of factory workers all day long, turning the lights on and off and handing out bars of candy, is undeniably chilling. All this "humanity" – and anyone from my old firm would tell you this – is nothing but a more subtle form of bureaucratic control. It is a technique for harnessing the individuality and sense of well-being of workers to use for the organisation's goals. It is an attempt to trick each of these women into participating in increasingly sophisticated forms of their own enslavement.
Why then are Mayo's findings constantly reproduced and presented as something radically new and emancipating? Why does every subsequent business management theorist seem to try to surpass Chairman Mao himself, calling for an endless rebellion against the old order? Very simply – because every economic organisation is connected with at least some amount of power, and power always annoys people. That is human nature. Ultimately, it is not so much a new world order that management theorists crave, but the feeling of a revolutionary moment. They long for that exhilarating instant when they fight for the forces of light and when visions of future utopias dawn in their minds. What will happen after the revolution – civil war and Stalinism are quite plausible versions – does not interest them in the slightest.
Taylor and Mayo have divided the world of management theory between them. As a result of scientific sampling, I have concluded that, provided one has understood this mutual dialectic of rationalism and humanism, one can calmly spare oneself the need to read 99 per cent of all management literature. The Taylorist rationalist says: "Be efficient!" The Mayoist humanist answers him: "Listen, this is about people!" And the exchange of views continues. In essence, it is just another chapter in the endless saga of reason and passion, of the individual and the group.
People who value their time for reading should know that Rousseau and Shakespeare have already said it all much, much better. In books, poems, plays, music, works of art, and good old graffiti, their authors have delved into the question of what it means to struggle with an evil fate, to use one's unique reason in relations with the world, and to look into the eyes of the inescapable truth about the motivations of beings like themselves. These works apply to every company executive's dilemmas in their efforts to make the world a more productive place just as much as any example of management literature.
My colleagues usually recalled their years spent at business school with fondness. Most of them had found great friends there, and quite a few – love. Everyone was convinced that the degree they received had been useful in climbing the career ladder. But is there anything one can gain from a business management master's degree that a philosophy doctorate couldn't beat?
An education in business management offers a few benefits that have very little to do with management or education at all. A master's degree in business, much like the intricate tattoo of an aboriginal warrior, confirms how deeply and unyieldingly you have sworn allegiance to a career in management. The degree also allows one to accumulate a substantial pile of what, in sociologists' language, is called "social capital". We, the rest, ignoring the fact that the palm computer was invented, still call it a card file.
For companies, business master's programmes can also be a way of offloading recruitment onto someone else's shoulders. Marvin Bower, managing director of McKinsey from 1950 to 1967, was the first to realise this fact and put it to use to build a legendary company. By carefully cultivating contacts with deans and engaging in well-calculated philanthropy, Bower secured for himself almost a monopoly on Baker Scholars (a handful of the very best students at Harvard Business School). Bower was not such a fool as to imagine that anyone was interested in these young educated people because of their education. No, they were valuable because they belonged to the smartest and most ambitious individuals of their generation, who had at their disposal the widest network of contacts. Harvard University had done him a favour by combing through a wide area, attracting and sifting through a large number of candidates, continuing to examine those who were accepted, and then offering Bower the chance to choose from the very best students and brightest minds.
Of course, an education in business management also assumes that a large volume of technical knowledge will be assimilated, accumulated since the times when Taylor set the first administrative-industrial complex in motion – accounting, statistical analysis, decision modelling, and so on – and these bits of wisdom can prove quite useful to students (depending on their career trajectory). However, the "value added" in this case is much more limited than Mum and Dad usually think. In most management positions, almost everything needed to succeed can be learned on the job. Regarding all other skills, it would be worth considering whether they couldn't be obtained by spending less time and money.
The best business schools will tell you that management education is primarily concerned with developing various skills; one of the most important is the ability to think (what business master's graduates call "problem solving"). But do they really succeed in teaching such a skill?
I was once present at a presentation where a consultant, a Harvard business master's graduate, was demonstrating to his client, a manager of a large financial institution from a developing country, how the said company's "competitive advantages" could be analysed by following "five forces" indicators. He even used a diagram borrowed from the bestselling book on "competitive strategy" by the then-worshipped guru Michael Porter. I, not for the first time in my life, felt ashamed that I too could be called a business consultant. As it happened, the client also held a master's degree in business from Harvard. "No," he said, shaking his head in feigned exasperation. "In this case, there are only three forces at work. And two of them are sitting in the Ministry of Finance."
It seems that in business schools, no one is taught that all these "five forces", "seven Ss", and any other general frameworks for solving problems are pure heuristics – they can lead to solutions, but they cannot make a person think. Case study analysis can offer an effective way to solve business problems, but the point of these lessons is lost if students remain in the conviction that they can safely go home, having put all their eggs in one market growth/market share matrix basket.
Among the most important skills for future masters of the universe, along with analysis, communication skills must be mentioned. To give credit where it's due, business schools really do devote a great deal of attention to this art and force their students to hold theatrical presentations in front of each other. However, on the whole, an education in business management has not been exactly generous to those who value the opportunities for free and meaningful expression. Management master's programmes have elevated the confusing jargon characteristic of this industry – known in other circles as pulling the wool over people's eyes – to heights that would make even a proper scholastic pale. As is known to philosophy students, Descartes already demolished the structure of medieval thought by writing in clear language and showing that knowledge is by its nature clear, not hazy.
Aside from developing various skills, business management training must focus on values. I write these words and feel my friends from the business master's programme start to fidget restlessly in their chairs. They were all once forced to sit through an "ethics" course, in the course of which they learned to throw around an even larger quantity of fine phrases, say, "categorical imperative", and dissect behaviour bordering on criminal conduct. For example, to judge what is a legitimate hotel bill and what is elementary profiting from representative expenses; how to distinguish a pat on the shoulder from sexual harassment, and so on. But, as anyone who has studied the works of Aristotle will know, "values" are not a thing one might accidentally stumble upon from time to time in the course of a business career. Business is involved with values all the time – from one end to the other. If we disregard the flashy messing about with stopwatches, the pig iron affair described by Taylor was by no means a description of an aspect of physical reality – how many tons one worker can load. It was a prescription – how many tons a worker should load. In Mayo's telephone factory, the true question was not of a factual nature – how best to attune people to common work? It was a question of a moral nature – how much of a worker's consciousness of individuality and well-being does the company have the right to use for its own needs?
The realisation that management theory is a sadly neglected subdiscipline of philosophy began with a feeling of déjà vu. Before my eyes opened yet another discipline, which consists mostly of unverifiable assumptions and retellings of mysterious incidents, from which one rarely or even never requires that it take responsibility for its own words and which releases into the world a disproportionately large quantity of disastrously bad authors. It all seemed too familiar. The idea that philosophy is an academic field in its very foundations is a recent and quite devilish invention. Epicurus, Descartes, Spinoza, Locke, Hume, Nietzsche, and most other brilliant thinkers of the past were not philosophy professors. I think that if any of them were to come to life now and see what has happened to their discipline, they would take to their heels immediately. However, between philosophers and their temperamental cousins, there exist at least two essential differences. The first and most important is that philosophers know much better what they do not know. The second is money. In a way, it can be said that management theory is what happens to philosophers if they are paid too much.
Translated from English by Sabīne Ozola
First publication of the article in the June 2006 issue of The Atlantic Monthly magazine. First publication in Latvian in the July 2006 issue of Rīgas Laiks magazine



