A homeless man, Jurijs, spent the night at the East Hospital's Emergency Clinic 95 times in one year after being found unconscious or in a state of alcoholic delirium on the street. According to the Latvian Television programme Panorāma, the total care provided cost the state budget more than 13,000 euros. [..] Doctors in the programme do not suggest that one should not call an ambulance for such patients, but they point out that looking after them requires a great deal of time that could be devoted to other patients, such as those suffering from a stroke or heart attack.
Delfi, 2 January
The news about alcoholics eating up the medical budget may seem alarming to any decent citizen. If we are constantly informed about the dire state of healthcare due to insufficient funding – and it is true, as we allocate significantly less to healthcare than other European countries – then the information that this already insufficient sum is being "spent incorrectly" gives rise to legitimate concerns. On the other hand, the question naturally arises: what does it mean to spend this money correctly? The head of the East Hospital's Emergency Clinic, Aleksejs Višņakovs, cites providing aid to patients suffering from a stroke or heart attack as an example of the correct use of these funds. But this suggests that "correct use" (as opposed to "incorrect use") could refer to at least two different things. In one instance, using resources incorrectly means using them in cases where they should not be used. If, for example, alcoholics do not need emergency medical attention, then providing such aid means that the resources intended for medicine – both money and the time of medical staff – are being spent incorrectly. On the other hand, using resources incorrectly can mean that they are being used, so to speak, for less valuable purposes than they ought to be. For example, some might say that providing aid to a heart attack patient is a much more valuable use of resources than caring for an alcoholic, even though emergency aid is necessary for both. Or, in other words, it would be better if such cases did not exist, but since they do, we have to accept that a portion of the funds must also be devoted to alcoholics.
If you look at the situation this way, the issue does not seem so complicated – all that remains is to determine whether or not the alcoholics described in the news actually require emergency medical attention. If they do not, then it is clear that their care is a wasteful and hard-to-justify squandering of resources; but if they do, then one must admit that alcoholics have exactly the same right to receive aid as any other patient, and the medics' comments should be viewed as an expression of regret over the spending of budget funds and their time on what they perceive to be a comparatively insignificant cause.
So – does a person under the influence of alcohol require emergency aid? Unfortunately, it is impossible to provide a general answer to this question because cases can be very different. Moreover, the question itself should be asked slightly differently – must an ambulance be called in such cases? Any conscientious citizen who has looked at the Emergency Medical Service website knows that, for example, unconsciousness is a sufficient reason for a call. If a person is lying unconscious on the street, there should be no doubt that an ambulance must be called. On the other hand, for a person who is simply intoxicated and whose health is not in immediate danger, a hospital is a disproportionately expensive hotel with a not-too-high level of comfort. (Though it must be kept in mind here that severe intoxication is a medical condition in itself.) However, for entirely understandable reasons, such individuals can and do end up in emergency clinics. Namely, in response to the question "Do intoxicated people need emergency aid?", we can answer – not always. But we cannot know for sure. And in this sense, cases involving alcohol consumption are no different from any other case where there is a basis to call for help, even if in the end it turns out that the person's health is not in any significant danger. Many would argue that the case of an alcohol user is different from others, because if they "drank on their own money", then they should take responsibility for the consequences themselves. Specifically, one could argue that alcohol users are to blame for their own health woes, so they are entitled to less help than others. However, this objection is much weaker than it might seem at first glance. Firstly, if alcoholism is a disease, then the alcoholic is more deserving of help than of punishment in the form of refused care. Secondly, if we make the provision of medical aid dependent on how much each individual has harmed their own health, it might turn out that alcohol users are not alone in this; similar reproaches could be directed at others – those who smoke, consume unhealthy food, eat too much or too little, engage in extreme sports, or lead a sedentary lifestyle. In all the cases mentioned, people are harming their own health through their lifestyle, and singling out alcohol users would not be fair.
But let us return to intoxicated people and emergency aid. Severely intoxicated patients – especially on weekends or public holidays – who shout, urinate on the floor, resist, and otherwise make the work of medical staff difficult, are an everyday occurrence at the Emergency Medical Service. Unfortunately, it seems that a simple solution to this is not possible – wherever there are homeless people and others who consume alcohol, they may end up in an emergency clinic with all the consequences that follow. Thus, one should ask not why these people are "eating up the medical budget", but rather – why does it happen that an educated person (the Jurijs mentioned in the Panorāma report, who had been taken to the emergency clinic 95 times, once spoke two foreign languages fluently) becomes homeless within a few years and, upon waking up in the clinic, is no longer able to say their own name? This is, of course, a social and political problem, not a medical one, and it involves issues concerning homeless shelters, unemployment, and social aid. A person is usually not born a homeless person or an alcoholic. They become one. And if society is not prepared to invest resources in social aid, then it later has to spend funds intended for healthcare. One can, of course, understand the medics, whose already difficult daily routine is made even harder by intoxicated homeless people, yet it must also be taken into account that such likely well-intentioned concern for healthcare funds can also lead to a bad outcome – a more indifferent attitude from fellow citizens towards a person lying unconscious on the street.
Article first published in the February 2015 issue of Rīgas Laiks magazine



