Arvīds Ozols is interviewed by Māris Liopa, Chairman of the Forest Certification Council of Latvia, and Pauls Rēvelis, editor of zemeunvalsts.lv.
This conversation took place shortly before the war began. In recent years, there has been a trend in Latvia to exchange stability in a field at any price for energetic activism, whose representatives are not exactly knowledgeable, are quite incompetent, yet loud in their slogans. How has forest policy and the industry in Latvia developed over 30 years, and what should be done with all this bustling panic?
The formation and development of forest policy in Latvia and the high level of forestry have been shaped over a long period of time.
It must be said that there have been no such major changes regarding the alteration of goals, the foundations of management, possible choices, and the like until now; I am referring to the European Union's Green Deal and the plans associated with it.
The industry and the ministry have had so-called 'internal turning points', for example, starting with the formation of forest policy in independent Latvia in the 90s. This policy did not just appear out of nowhere – a specific set of conditions was needed, for example, by the mid-90s, industry interest groups had stabilized, which could talk both among themselves and with the ministry, and, moreover, were able to reach an agreement during the negotiations.

In the early 2000s, the book 'Guidelines for Forest Policy Formulation' was written. Before its publication, the FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations) invited me to participate in the book's approval committee meeting. The discussion was interesting; by the way, the book included a phrase I said that was very well-liked by Ewald Rametsteiner, who was working in the working group: 'Forest policy is negotiated agreement.' In other words – forest policy is not something dictated 'from above', but an agreement reached through negotiation.
Since the 90s, there has been both serious industrial development and a change in understanding – at the moment when we formulated the forest policy, we were thinking not about what others had done or devised, but rather what we could create or reconcile ourselves. When we reached the institutional reforms after the forest policy was developed, we did diligently study what and how others were doing – how state forest management takes place, where, by the way, the situations in different countries were very diverse – from a state institution funded from the budget to successful capital companies, there were also hybrid versions. Things have gone differently since those times, but it is clear that the management of state forests is an economic activity and a business.
When the project for institutional reform was being drafted, we encountered some resistance; there was a desire to involve a good, internationally known brand in the changes. We applied for an FAO project and asked for help from experts, who turned out to be very qualified. The group of experts was led by Hans von Buttlar, Deputy Head of the Forestry Department of the Federal State of Brandenburg. Once, in a conversation, he remarked that reforms were also being demanded of him back home in Germany, which was good – Latvia would be a good training ground, and if the result was good, he could get to work in Brandenburg. Since forest management in Germany is the competence of each federal state (not the federal government), the models vary. On the other hand, 'Latvijas valsts meži' and the Austrian Federal Forests are, to some extent, legal twins – capital companies that make a profit while the forests remain under state ownership. The Irish and the Norwegians, in turn, have invested their forests in a company.
At that time, it was considered almost a revolution.
First, it was necessary to convince others that the project and the idea were viable. There were concerns... for example, what to do with the forests – to invest them in a capital company or not. What if the capital company goes bankrupt, what would happen to the forests? As a result, the concerns have not been justified; a good, profitable company has been formed, which the state often uses as a 'cash cow'. Over these years, more than €1 billion has been paid in dividends and taxes.
If I look at the situation in Latvia from above – from a helicopter flight – I realize that, for example, the things and issues that are and will be subjects of dispute in Latvia do not even fall into the category of problems at the UN Forest Forum.
In Latvia, problems are inflated and sought in the Congo, while the social and economic aspects are forgotten.
This is a nuance of thinking – if you are used to everything just happening and the benefits coming anyway, it is no longer an achievement, but a given. If all this exists, one wants 'something more', but – let someone else pay for this 'something more'.
The number of people who do not understand how it is possible to get one euro into the state budget has grown...
Recently, Kristaps Klauss presented a good analysis of this situation – how many of us in Latvia provide added value (produce) and how many are consumers. Latvia does not have a sufficient base of real money producers – earners. The Bank of Latvia or the government does not produce money... Added value arises in production, and you need someone to buy what has been produced.

In Latvia, upon restoring independence, there were a few clear things. For example, the restoration of the Republic of Latvia and the restoration of those rights and obligations that were once violently interrupted. For example, property rights and land reform and its principles (which are undeniably important because, after the end of the Soviet regime, there have been many different reforms in Europe, and they have ended just as differently). In Latvia, in its basic principles, the land reform has ended. All who were owners or their heirs in independent Latvia became owners again. This created clear basic principles, including the state, which also had to prove what properties it had owned until 1940. The state is an owner just like others. Speaking of state forests, a political decision followed regarding non-privatizable state property. This was certainly an important turning point for starting and developing forest and agricultural policy. For example, our neighbors in Lithuania acted differently, and there is still no clarity regarding the owners of many land plots there.
Speaking of the forest industry, the aforementioned was an essential prerequisite for the formation of a group of people in Latvia whom we now know as forest owners. Initially, they, of course, did not really realize what it meant; it took some time for forest owners to understand what property meant and to organize themselves for work and cooperation.
In Europe, forest owners (and landowners in general) have long been a significant and important group of societal representation. By the way, there are many owners, their families or lineages often 'rely' on this property, work and live – a strong group of owners is one of the conditions for state stability. If we remember the old slogan: 'The proletariat has nothing to lose but its chains', the state is undoubtedly interested in having a large portion of its citizens be owners.
At one time, a certain leader in a neighboring country disliked owners very much, looking only at the proletariat.
There were many problematic issues with the first land reform in Latvia, but it included compensation. It was not a seizure of land in the Bolshevik style. Before World War II, Germans were repatriated, and even then, compensation was provided for. We can talk about details, trifles, dissatisfaction, but the principle is what is important.
Returning to recent times, after the development of Latvia's forest policy, we began successful cooperation with the Swedes, who in the early 90s had carried out their own reform, trusting landowners more. Yes, the cooperation was good, but... the neighbors' ideas somehow did not take root in Latvia. I admit the thoughts were good and are still acceptable, but (at that time) there was a lack of negotiating partners – there were no owner organizations, privatization processes were underway in the processing industry, which brought great changes. By the mid-90s, owners were already represented by organizations, nature conservation organizations had been formed, albeit with a different focus and understanding than today, there were negotiating partners and a plan on how to agree – what and how forest policy is. The process took about two years because, at first, there was no understanding of what we were actually preparing to talk about and what the end result should be – what exactly forest policy is... At the moment, we can laugh about it, but one of the prerequisites was – the forest policy document must be as short as possible, no longer than 10 pages, otherwise it will not be read; in terms of content, professional terminology must be avoided as much as possible because many might not understand it. For example, one of the criteria – give the text to a 6th-grade student to read and write a summary – if most of the summary is correct – the document is ready and can be submitted for political discussion.
In 1989, a ministerial conference on the protection of forests took place in Europe; at that time, they talked more about acid rain and how to stop forest dieback and transboundary pollution. Yes, there was a time when environmental protection was genuine protection! Later followed the conference in Helsinki (1993), where the most important thing was an explanation and agreement – what exactly sustainable forest management means.
The text that was the basis for the Helsinki resolution seemed very good and understandable to everyone: a clear definition of sustainability and a principle – namely – the balance between environmental, social, and economic spheres and interests. Already back then, much was mentioned about knowledge – education, experience, training – necessary for forest owners. For the first time, state functions in ensuring sustainable forest management were defined (policy and regulatory oversight, property management, and support function) and the manner in which they would be implemented. The then-government, led by Guntars Krasts, approved this forest policy. Industry representatives at that time realized their ownership rights over this policy.

The policy was accepted, the logical next step – to start implementing it. First, a so-called gap analysis was carried out – namely – to understand what is happening in real life and what the desired state is, which is included in the policy document. It was concluded that the institutional and functional management of forests did not correspond to the situation, which is why the aforementioned, popularly called 'FAO project' was created – the Latvian initiative group concluded that 'to be a prophet in one's own land, one needs an internationally recognized partner.' The FAO's reputation is good, the project was supported with ~250 thousand USD. A proposal was made for an institutional structure, which has not changed to this day – the State Forest Service as a state administration institution, and a/s 'Latvijas valsts meži' (LVM) as a manager. LVM's development was successful – the task for the first year was to take over the State Forest Service's economic functions and ensure forest management and the supply of raw materials to the industry, the company's viability, and fixed (profit) payments to the budget. We had calculated revenues, expenses, and profit; we went to the then-Minister of Finance, Edmunds Krastiņš, who answered briefly: 'I know how to calculate profit and loss; it is important to me that there is a stable figure in the budget document. Namely, that dividend payments cover the State Forest Service's budget costs. If you can promise that, there will be no objections!' We ensured exactly that.
In 2003-2004, LVM's first strategy was created. A little later, when the Law on the Management of Public Persons and Capital Companies was prepared and adopted, the section of the law dedicated to strategies was mostly based on our experience. How so? We were not satisfied with the version of the draft law, the Ministry of Agriculture protested, as a result of which we received the answer: 'If you don't like it, propose your own!' That is what we did. A good example of when a company's successful development creates a model for normal corporate governance in other areas.
Another essential thing in the development of the industry, which is not overly public but well known to colleagues – in the mid-90s, there was quite an intense discussion – how to correctly measure trees, who should do it, whether it should be done by the State Forest Service, or if another institution is needed. We agreed that measurements should be performed by an independent person or company operating based on standards. Measurement is not politically approved by the government, but there is a professional agreement about it. In my opinion, this was a very important thing because the principle has developed further, and the industry concluded over time that it could provide measurement services itself. Measurement, as I already mentioned, is not publicly 'well visible', but it is a very important everyday process for the normal functioning of the industry.
If we talk about the development of the industry, it has so far continued to operate in accordance with the forest policy approved in 1996 that I mentioned. There have been crises, including the financial one, when the principle inscribed in the 1996 policy document worked, at that time not understanding what it really meant and how to use it. Namely: 'The management of state forests serves as a stabilizing factor in the development of the industry.' During the crisis, prices fell, which had previously been quite high; the industry was threatened with a standstill because private forest owners were not selling timber, which meant that 'dozens of thousands of people' would have appeared in the country, turning from taxpayers into unemployed people and welfare recipients in a short period of time. What happened? The government decided to increase the allowed harvesting volume in state forests by 2+2 million m3. Effectively, they harvested what had previously been saved (which had not been harvested in previous years). The compensating mechanism acted (was activated), which saved many.
What is happening now? A part of the world is worried about climate change, about the loss of biological diversity. There is a basis for concern – for example – if the water level rises by even a few meters, coral atolls, island nations, the Netherlands, etc., disappear. The conviction is strengthening (or being strengthened) that human impact is driving these changes. But! If one reads about events that took place centuries or thousands of years ago – in a review about climate and ice ages, it can be seen that after the last ice age, a period of 3-4 thousand years followed, when the average temperature in our latitudes was 2-3 degrees higher than it is today – that was the time when people arrived here and moved further to Scandinavia. After some time, the temperature fell, stimulating the great migrations of peoples. The situation can be perfectly seen by studying the pollen composition in the sediments of swamps and lakes. In Latvia, there has been a period when broad-leaved forests were dominant here – so warming in Latvia can only mean history repeating itself. Of course, there are benefits and risks. For example, species ranges shift; the question becomes relevant – is it appropriate to grow spruce or pine here, or should we think about something else; the range for pathogens also changes.
Forest industry colleagues know very well the nun moth and the spongy moth. The nun moth lives here constantly; the spongy moth appears because its range is further to the south. Where is the difference? The nun moth's larvae eat spruce, the spongy moth's larvae – they eat everything they can. You can ask Prof. Agnis Šmits at 'Silava' for more details, but this is one example of how a species undesirable to us reacts quite flexibly to changes in the thermal regime.
In the world, biological diversity is discussed a little differently than it is in Latvia – here we have 1/3 science, 1/3 belief, 1/3 desire. In the world, biological diversity is a potential source of human salvation; for example, we know about antibiotic resistance, where antibiotics no longer work on microorganisms because they have been used too much in the past, and bacteria have become more resistant through evolution. There is a risk that there is a part of genetic diversity that we have not yet identified and which may be important to us, for example, it may have significant applications, etc.

Many unknowns.
Of course, many know what a horse looks like, more than one can distinguish a spruce from a pine, but – that is the big, visible world; very, very few people know the Small world. If you walk into a forest barefoot, under your feet there are many species you wouldn't even imagine. The Convention on Biological Diversity has spoken about its conservation, sustainable use, and fair use, so that those peoples who live in places where particularly valuable species are found would gain some benefit from knowing and using the properties of these species. For example, the largest corporations begin to cultivate these species, leaving nothing for the local residents, whose lifestyle and work have helped the species be preserved and thrive.
They speak of doing as little harm as possible.
Evil and good are ethical categories, just like the 10 Commandments. But! How do we evaluate what is happening, what do we conclude? The processes I mentioned are long-term, which must not be forgotten! A long time ago, around the turn of the 50s and 60s, a conference was organized about global cooling, so... A paradox? No, human understanding and feelings about what is happening! Thoughts and plans about what and how to do must be based on long-term scientific data.
There is too little knowledge.
It happens that policy is formed based on emotional considerations or based on faith. The desires of society can be different; a politician cannot ignore the emotional component. One cannot say – it is good or bad – that is how it is! One thing characterizes a person's ability to learn – the more you know, the broader your horizon – the more you realize that there is still so much you do not know. That also somewhat characterizes the current situation.
In the context of biological diversity, it is good to link together forest statistical inventory, growth conditions, and quantitative and measurable biological diversity parameters. If we look over time, we see trends. There is an old truth – you can improve what you can measure. Not everything can be measured directly, there are correlations, etc. Looking at decisions, economic management methods, etc., one can see what has influenced what. Furthermore – elements or the value of biological diversity have certain optimal conditions for existence, from which we can conclude the risks that disturb or threaten this existence, selectively concluding from that what should or should not be done. You cannot preserve something by doing nothing! Much of what is 'preservable' very clearly demands that something be done for its benefit.
Biotopes also form through 'work'.
At one time, the Grīņi Nature Reserve was created, where the well-known Grīņi heather (and others) grew. What happened? The Grīņi heather is a plant of open, clear places; when economic activity in the reserve ended, the areas began to overgrow, tree canopies closed, and the Grīņi heather is no longer in the reserve. The plant grows and blooms beautifully in the nearby clearings.
The same is the story about the pine.
Exactly! The pine naturally regenerates after a major windthrow or a significant forest fire, which effectively creates an open area.
Biological processes have their own time dynamics. If we talk about land-use change, it has time dynamics and time inertia, which is neither 2, nor 5, nor 10 years. The actions or instruments we choose must correspond to the natural characteristics of biological systems. For example, carbon sequestration, which we have agreed upon. If the EU needs carbon neutrality by 2050, but we know there will be emissions, we must think about their capture. In EC projects, emissions can be captured in the land-use sector and with technological solutions (carbon capture and storage device), for example, there is a filter on a chimney that captures CO2, which is then chemically sequestered or pumped into the ground.
Three serious issues to be solved: technologies are not developed enough to be used on a serious (full) scale (there are pilot projects), equipment also consumes energy, and CO2 has to be used somewhere. We must get energy that does not create emissions so that an ideal circular economy does not start. I suspect there will be a scientific solution for this. By the way, people started talking about carbon storage 10-15 years ago, it is not a recent novelty. At that time, the chairman of the British Forestry Commission showed in a picture at a meeting in Geneva the most ideal carbon storer (carbon capture and storage device), which best meets scientific parameters. It is a tree! Of course, there are also grasses that have a short life cycle. This would be the land-use sector I mentioned, which captures CO2, basically, therefore, the forest. Theoretically, carbon can also be sequestered on agricultural land, but it is complicated.
In Latvia, soil mapping has concluded that in 50% of cases, there are organic soils under agricultural land.
Here we are talking about human understanding – what is needed at what point in time. The idea about the necessity of soil mapping is old, I think at least 15 years. At the time, it was estimated that mapping would cost about 4 million lats over a 4-5 year period. It was concluded that it was not a priority and not worth spending anything on. We reached other projects, involved the LLU, the LU Faculty of Geography and Earth Sciences, 'Silava' – Latvia's best forces, to clarify this issue. If we speak of agricultural land, soil mapping was carried out in the collective farm days, but a considerable amount of time has also passed – the geological foundation will be the same, but the top part might have changed a little – it was concluded that old data could be used, in a modern calibration, which is actually being done within the framework of the project. Deep misunderstanding is caused in me by the hopping and twitching from the European Commission. In 2018 and 2019, serious negotiations took place about the climate regime and targets for 2021-2030, which an agreement was reached on. With the change in the composition of the European Parliament, opinions and goals changed; currently, they are trying to offer us an action plan with the feeling of a burning house.
A panicked style of activity can be observed.
Panicked, chaotic, and contradictory action. The land sector was given the task of being neutral (an agreement on which was reached in 2018-2019); now they propose to change two significant things – the accounting and calculation system and to set other goals. If only one of these were changed, one could think about it; if both are changed – a problem arises. The EC's approach is flatly mechanical: 'In 2050, carbon neutrality is needed, emissions will be so-and-so, we draw a curve to 2018 and...' 'Damn, you can't reach neutrality in 2050 like this!' The goals must be changed. For whom are they set? For biological systems. What creates emissions – soil and economic activity. Forestry operates sustainably – so that there are more forests in the future – or – so that today's choices do not reduce the choices of future generations. I like this formulation! We do not know what the next generations will want, but we cannot reduce their ability to choose. Currently, an administrative goal is being set for biological systems – sequester more carbon!
An order to the spruce, pine, and cedar – sequester more carbon!
It is important to understand – whether to sequester more effectively (practically) or to sequester more 'on paper'.
Several years ago, it became clear in Latvia that there is no better carbon storehouse than a forest, but – what is important – a managed forest! Speaking of carbon stocks, it is not only in the forest stand but also in the soil; a stock is a passive warehouse, and every warehouse has its capacity. A forest ecosystem has a maximum capacity it can accumulate to maintain its viability. If someone thinks that economic activity in the forest is not needed – 'let it just store, and we will stuff in a lot, a lot', one must remember that the ecosystem has a limited volume; it happens that the warehouse is full and can no longer take in more. If we do nothing, natural systems 'go' their natural way, they start to age, becoming carbon neutral. The question is not about how much carbon is stored, but – how much 'can be brought in or stored' annually – that is sequestration and the active part. Emissions are every year, regardless of the warehouse volume.
For the forest to ensure C sequestration, economic activity is needed, namely, the 'extraction' of C from the forest to create free space in the ecosystem for carbon to 'join in' again. What is extracted is converted into long-life cycle, high-value-added products. If a table is made of metal, glass, or plastic, a certain amount of fossil products is consumed for production; if we make this same table from wood – fossil product consumption has been replaced.
Speaking of the forest industry, while preparing the guidelines on C neutrality, we included the thought about the need to increase the productivity of our forests by 25% (by 2050). Initially, it was an emotional desire, as we asked the scientists of the forest science institute 'Silava' to calculate in modeling systems whether it was practically possible. 'Silava's' answer was: '25% is a good goal, but 2050 is a little too soon for that. In 2050, we could talk about 20%.' And here again is the great paradox – what we were talking about – increasing sequestration in practice or on paper. Where is the trouble? We are talking about a short period of time when, by reducing logging, we end up in the CO2 emission zone due to the change in the age structure of forest stands.
Biological diversity is evaluable. Nature Restoration Law – if to restore, 'from' or 'to' what state. If one wants to restore – what to restore? The situation 50, 400, or 4000 years ago? Or to restore the state that we consider nature should be? There is no clear reference point. What is more important – biological diversity or reducing CO2 ? When the impact assessment for 2020-2030 was discussed – the basic assumption was that 0.5 million ha could be afforested in Latvia. LLU data showed that 80-90 thousand ha actually remain.
Forest management is a significant reservoir of biological diversity. We can preserve biological diversity, of course, the way we want. For example, in the Grīņi reserve, we will cut to restore a mosaic landscape. If economic activity in forestry had not been wrongly interrupted in the past, nothing like that would be necessary. Everything happening is planned in a short time, in different directions. Currently, the most important thing is – not to lose common sense and find a balance.



