It is the right time to look further and higher – what is above the forest and what is below it. A conversation with Jānis Lapiņš, a member of the Management Board of “Latvijas valsts meži” - Zeme un valsts

It is the right time to look further and higher – what is above the forest and what is below it. A conversation with Jānis Lapiņš, a member of the Management Board of “Latvijas valsts meži”

Jānis Lapiņš is interviewed by Māris Liopa, Chairman of the Forest Certification Council of Latvia, and Pauls Rēvelis, editor of zemeunvalsts.lv.

From the perspective of “Latvijas valsts meži” (LVM), how do you evaluate what is happening this year and at the moment – the price spikes, the energy crisis, the timber shortage?

Looking back and evaluating the last four years, we must remember what has happened in Latvia and Europe. Some time ago, we experienced a “bark beetle attack” in the European timber market. It might be forgotten now, but at the time, many felt that the timber market was “falling apart”, that there was an abnormal overproduction of raw materials because the market was flooded with timber damaged by bark beetles, and prices were falling. We thought, planned, sought possible solutions, and managed to “stabilise” our work.

What happened? The C19 pandemic began. Figuratively speaking, we moved from one whirlpool into another – we were “thoroughly spun by one washing machine (bark beetles), which then passed the relay baton to the next (the pandemic)”. The timber market took a tumble. If we recall the beginning of the C19 period, it was not clear what it was, how it would affect us, or what would happen. Many processes stopped, many things were restricted; what happened in construction? The demand for materials skyrocketed. Yes, many of us were at home! What does a person do when they are at home? They also shop, think about renovations, and do things “around the house”. The market revived, and having adapted to the new market conditions and remote work, we were successfully able to provide clients with products.

And just as we had understood how to live with C19, 24 February arrived. We found ourselves in a completely new, unprecedented situation again. Speaking of the timber market, it now “ends” at the border of the European Union. An energy crisis set in, and the demand for wood grew rapidly because part of the timber previously supplied to Europe was lost (Russia, Belarus).

What is happening in Latvia? A serious, intense struggle for raw materials is underway.

“Latvijas valsts meži” is in charge of and manages about 50% of Latvia’s forest land; they demand resources from us. This, in turn, creates another question – are we able to produce and provide this resource in such volumes? Namely, it is not just us who want to supply – as prices have increased, the private sector has also stepped up. As soon as the price is up, many are ready to start logging. The private sector is largely based on price – “if it is very high, I want (it is time) to log and sell the forest”.

The joint-stock company (“Latvijas valsts meži”) operates and thinks long-term – we work with the full forestry cycle in mind, from 0 to at least 100 years, and by increasing the value we will leave for future generations.

In the sector, there are more and more forest owners who think similarly and operate for the long term.

How does the European Green Deal affect this situation?

LVM’s main resource is land – we talk a lot about the forest or only about the forest, but the most important resource is the land, and we need to think about how to manage it correctly and as effectively as possible.

LVM manages 1.6 million hectares, in fact, 1/4 of Latvia’s territory. In the context of effective and sustainable land management – a forest grows “above the ground”, and we are very knowledgeable and responsible in its management. But we need to think broader – about what is “above the forest”, for example, about the new joint project – wind farms, which society talks about and considers little. Above the treetops, there is a good flow of energy (wind), which opens up new development opportunities.

Why are we thinking about this now? In crisis conditions, we must think about how to gain and give maximum benefit to society.

Likewise, we must not forget everything that is underground. As I mentioned, the forest is only part of the resources that LVM has successfully and responsibly managed for 20 years. It is the right time for us to look wider and higher – at what is available above the forest and what is below it.

Speaking about the European Green Deal – the land is our resource. The Green Deal can affect us in different ways, especially if its policy is not well-thought-out and decisions are rushed or ill-considered. If you remove X hectares of land from an enterprise’s or owner’s economic activity or turnover, it means that the company’s economic activity from logging decreases accordingly. What does that change? Long-term plans – today’s decision can change quite a lot, as we will certainly have to ensure that we can just as successfully continue to manage the remaining land resource (area) effectively in the long term.

It is important to find a balance between economic, social, and environmental needs. We must not think only about how to make maximum profit; we must think broader, but – we must remember the balance.

Latvia is part of Europe, and decisions made in the European Union apply to the whole of Europe. It is very important to be loud enough because we are a forested country. The sector, which contributes nearly 6% to the national GDP and 20% to exports, must come together, agree on a common opinion, and present it, actively explaining its position to both Latvian and European policymakers. The Green Deal is also an opportunity, because by intensively growing forests, planting genetically high-value seedlings, and ensuring optimal growing conditions for tree stands, we can make a significant contribution to collecting carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequestering it in tree biomass. It is also an opportunity to make Latvia less dependent on foreign energy resources and imported building materials.

Definitely by cooperating with the Scandinavians and neighbouring countries!

That is lobbying work – finding allies to walk into the halls of Europe with and explain.

Quite a few EU decisions are formed in a “could be, that’s how it should be” format, which often does not match reality... In Europe, there are many very different countries.

Exactly, European countries are very different economically, culturally, in their perception, emotions, etc.! We cannot compare, for example, the Italians and the Scandinavians – two completely different cultures, different approaches to building prosperity. But we live in the EU, and we want and try to be united – that requires seeking compromises. At the same time, in countries where forests are scarce or almost non-existent, they do not really understand forestry, but they are happy to live in houses, build them from wood, or use environmentally friendly items.

Southern European countries “shift” their large nature conservation areas to the mountains or the seaside, where it is impossible to use the land for other purposes. We do not have such opportunities.

This is a question of shared land resources and their use. We often hear that it is necessary to grow more and more forest. A good thought, but... From whom in Latvia should we take away or where should we “take” land to grow more forest? Should we leave agriculture in the background?

The Swedish approach to agricultural land is to be viewed positively – they look at soil fertility indicators. For example, I think that in Latvia, “semi-utilised” (partially used) agricultural land could certainly be afforested.

Undoubtedly, there are parts of the land that should certainly be afforested. Here, one must think about the balance we mentioned earlier, and one cannot do without forward-looking policy.

In a recent interview with “Neatkarīgā”, you highlighted the “Latvijas valsts meži” forest land acquisition plan.

LVM’s plans regarding land acquisition have not changed. I admit that we have been a passive participant in the land market for a long time, which, in turn, has created a misleading impression of what is happening. “Latvijas valsts meži” must become more active in this regard. Very many people do not even know that we are buying land. We buy forest land, we buy logging sites, for example, we will plant the purchased cleared areas and include them in the long-term forest management cycle.

Of course, we are quite cautious about the potential purchase of agricultural land because we do not want to be a hindrance to farmers, who also have a great desire to buy land.

I would like to invite anyone who is planning to sell their land property – come, make an offer, we will talk, we will reach an agreement – the land will remain with the state and will be managed sustainably and in the long term!

Of course, various investors with different goals are also interested in land; there is quite a serious turnover in this sector, where everyone is interested in their own business. LVM looks at this from a national perspective – I think selling land to “Latvijas valsts meži” is one of the best investments for future generations.

A state-owned enterprise is usually accused of slow processes and complex selection criteria.

It is known in the company; specific work has been done – the complex process has been reviewed and changed so that all formalities proceed faster. But! We must not forget the law that determines the order in which we can acquire land. We can decide faster, act faster, but we will follow the procedure established by law – we cannot change that.

Continuing about the Green Deal, we see dual manifestations – there is the industry or industry practitioner who sees the idea and sees it being overgrown with mountains of regulatory documents, and there is the emotion-filled “greeter of all things green” who pretends not to see the piles of documents. Here too, it is necessary to balance enthusiasm and the practical side.

One must always remember the information overload of modern times. Industry representatives must tell, explain, and very seriously educate the public so that members of society better understand what the “Green Deal” is, what it will affect, and how the whole of society will feel this impact. I will certainly emphasise – such an explanation must come not only from the forest sector but from every sector and person that the Green Deal will affect. In my opinion, politicians should also delve deeper and understand the essence of the Green Deal. It is one thing to tell society something populistically and beautifully; it is another thing to explain what changes need to be introduced and how exactly and specifically it will affect society and entrepreneurship, by delving in and analysing.

The simplicity of the explanation is especially important and significant, which is often forgotten. As soon as we start speaking too cleverly, mentioning taxonomy, quotas, and everything else, a person will get confused and will not be able to follow the further narrative. The language must be simple.

The problem also lies in another circumstance, namely, that this clarity and simplicity are often used to present distorted data or non-existent facts to society. Therefore, I will repeat, the industry must educate, talk, and tell more and more! Lobbying will also be important here – discussions and consultations so that regulatory acts and decisions are not only clear and understandable but also acceptable and implementable.

Speaking of lobbying, as soon as one of the industry representatives starts to explain this or that decision, industry opponents remark: “Look, the industry lobby has spoken up!”, well aware of the Latvian public’s negative attitude towards the word “lobby”.

I agree, lobbying is considered something bad in society, associated with corruption, etc. That is completely wrong!

Lobbying is the representation of interests – whether it happens at the European or national level. Many non-governmental organisations operate in Latvia, which are lobbyists for their members’ interests. The current attitude of society is a consequence of our country’s historical political mistakes – equating lobbying with corruption, which are completely different things. I think these misconceptions will clear up over time. For example, in the USA, lobbying is a sphere in which large companies and enterprises openly invest huge funds so that their interests are represented and defended, to explain them to society, and to help sort out regulations or normative acts, etc.

Industry problems, whether we like them or not, are multiplied by the media, whose representatives have chosen the emotional path – working in the field, in the forest, in the bog is not good...

Every society has known historical ailments. In Latvia, we very often look at past events, evaluating the present in their light. For the sake of social development, it is much more necessary to look to the future. If we look at the past, even the recent one, we will see too many negative things there. “Reputation can be ruined in one day, it will take years to restore it.” Unfortunately, bad fame, even about old past events, “lingers” long enough. But today it is important – what do we do tomorrow, the day after, and a week from now so that the past is not repeated, so that we do better and achieve more. The question: how to improve the future, because we will not change the past.

Entrepreneurship is a necessary thing in every country; with us, it is often evaluated in the aforementioned light of the past. As LDDK President Andris Bite mentioned in the conversation: “...one must start educating the younger generation – from the basics of entrepreneurship, for example, it is acceptable to make mistakes, it is acceptable to go bankrupt, it changes nothing, etc.” For the wider public, business failures are still recounted as something extraordinary.

In Latvia, unfortunately, the media loves to “get clicks” by publishing negative news. There are two options – either society demands the negative, or we do not know how to present the positive. One should not be shy about positive things; more should be highlighted about what has been done well. But, of course, the negative and the popular sell better today than good news.

Considering what was discussed earlier, the new LVM and “Latvenergo” wind park project must be implemented understandably and carefully enough.

If we talk about the joint venture, LVM owns 20% of it, we are a minority shareholder. Two large state joint-stock companies with very strong teams, stable financial indicators, and financial standing are cooperating in the project – “Latvenergo” – professionals in the energy sector, “Latvijas valsts meži” – professionals in land management. In the course of the negotiations, which were by no means simple, we reached a common denominator. Both companies agreed on a unified vision of how to build a wind park, the likes of which have not existed in Latvia before. LVM wants this joint project to be a beginning, a seed for future projects. Understanding of them will develop, I hope, regulations will also be sorted out, I believe there will be other ideas.

The 0.8 hectares on which a turbine is located is a very small area; the 200m tall turbine will give us the energy that flows across the treetops – it is a small but effective energy producer. Of course, the project is voluminous, investments are planned at around €1bn, so LVM has to invest about €200m. At the moment, it seems that we will finance the largest part of the investment ourselves, and for the remaining part, we are researching the most advantageous option.

Of course, I would be very happy if society were more involved in such a joint project, but the potential financing must be discussed with “Latvenergo”.

Talk about listing “Latvijas valsts meži” shares on the stock exchange has quieted down a little.

Here I would like to add and emphasise that “Latvijas valsts meži” must under no circumstances be privatised; it is, if I may say so, an object of national capital that must be kept in national (state) ownership. We can involve society through bonds.

I believe that “Latvijas valsts meži” should not be listed on the stock exchange because we manage state property – forest land, which is one of the state’s basic resources. This resource must be kept in state ownership. LVM, as a manager of the resource, is a strategically significant state company.

There are other companies in Latvia that should be listed on the stock exchange, for example, AirBaltic.

Has the company’s strategy also changed with the change of the LVM Council and Management Board?

A strategy is a document that should not be “cast in stone” and clung to. It is to a certain extent a variable, which does not have to be changed every year, but often it requires corrections. Of course, as the company’s management changes, it looks at whether the existing strategy corresponds to the current Council and Board’s vision of the company’s development, values, or whether something should be changed.

How much and how could LVM increase its cooperation with the private forest sector?

The question is about the management process. How to manage someone else’s property? If various properties of various private individuals come under management, which have different areas, different stands, a lot of resources have to be invested in such management, and it is not clear how to do it best; at the moment, we are not considering such a form of business. In our opinion, the best way, as we talked about earlier, is to purchase the property – it goes onto LVM’s balance sheet and is managed accordingly in the long term. This way, society will have and will be given the greatest benefit and gain, namely, we will be able to choose the management method, what kind of stand to grow there, etc.

Continuing about possible cooperation, that would be a slightly different business model, where each land (forest) owner could have their own view on the goal to be achieved. Such a cooperation plan would first have to be discussed with the industry.

LVM also has other opportunities to develop – looking not only at the forest sector – we have already discussed plans for wind farms, there can also be solar panel parks. There are also subsoil resources, for example, peat – an exportable, very important, and significant product for society, which must by no means be forgotten. All plant growing is largely based on peat products, and it is also impossible to grow high-quality tree seedlings for the forest without peat. In relation to peat, the Green Deal is worrying, which is why time must be invested and documents analysed, evaluated, and lobbied.

I will ask: “What does the manufacturer need today? Resources. What does the manufacturer expect from ‘Latvijas valsts meži’?”

For this resource to be available!

Exactly! For the resource to exist, be delivered on time, and in the appropriate quality. The manufacturer must think about how to sell their products and ensure an efficient production process. For “Latvijas valsts meži”, in order to supply the resource, we must also think about our production efficiency. Herein lies the dilemma – at the moment when many want to produce roundwood, a “bottleneck” is formed. Every crisis or emergency shows the company’s weak point. Currently, the weak point is the lack of capacity – because there is a huge demand. I think there is a certain similarity with IT systems – prepare a large demand for them and see if the system will work or collapse. At the moment, the market demand is so huge that we are physically unable to satisfy it. We, as a producer, need to re-plan everything.

One must also not forget that “Latvijas valsts meži” “lives” on the basis of the Public Procurement Law. We have to comply with a lot of regulations – for example – there are long-term contracts and the procurement process; changing a contract and process can take seven months. After seven months, perhaps a new contract will already be needed, which will again “take” seven months. Of course, within the company, we have started to look at where and how to look for solutions. We can solve quite a lot, but – without breaking the procurement law – that is completely clear. A solution must be sought within the framework of the existing contract, talking with service providers about how we can reorient. Of course, producers suffer, but we on our part are doing our utmost to reduce these problems. It is in our interests to supply roundwood. And – in this situation, we are starting to look at whether there are things we could do ourselves...

Add a comment