Ireland's forests, fields and peat – the fight for a “place in the sun”. Part I. Forestry “Irish-style” and nature conservation – conflicts and scandals - Zeme un valsts

Ireland's forests, fields and peat – the fight for a “place in the sun”. Part I. Forestry “Irish-style” and nature conservation – conflicts and scandals

Ireland's business environment and Irish entrepreneurial culture combine global ambition with a distinctly personal approach. Of course, Ireland has both positive and negative aspects that characterise Irish enterprise and business culture today.

Ireland is famous for its low taxes. The corporate income tax rate – 12.5%, or 15% for large companies – remains one of the most attractive in Europe. Dublin hosts the European headquarters of global giants Google, Apple and Meta , creating a strong innovation ecosystem. The agencies Enterprise Ireland and IDA Ireland provide enormous financial and advisory support to both start-ups and foreign investors. Ireland is the only fully English-speaking country in the eurozone, serving as a distinctive bridge between the US and Europe.

There are also several negative aspects, such as the high cost of living, along with office and housing availability problems in Dublin, which make it harder to attract staff and raise the cost of doing business. Public transport and energy networks are failing to keep pace with rapid economic growth. There is a wide gap in Ireland between wealthy foreign technology giants and small local businesses.

Irish sociability certainly plays a positive role in business, since the Irish are famous storytellers and find it easy to build contacts. An informal atmosphere dominates business life. Problems are often resolved flexibly, without rigid bureaucracy. Because of the small domestic market, Irish entrepreneurs think about exports and international markets from day one. For the Irish, building relationships and trust matters more than presenting “dry figures”.

What is not so positive? The Irish tendency to avoid a direct “no” can create situations in which decisions are delayed or communicated unclearly. Attitudes to deadlines tend to be looser than, for example, in Germany or the Nordic countries.

Sometimes excessive reliance on verbal agreements – “it'll all be fine” – takes the place of the legal and procedural precision Irish businesspeople actually need.

Forestry “Irish-style”

Irish forestry is undergoing a very ambitious transformation, trying to balance the economic benefits of historic conifer plantations against strict European Union nature conservation requirements and, of course, public pressure. The state's goal is to build more than 300,000 new homes by 2030 in which locally grown timber is the primary building material, while raising forest cover from the current 11.6% to 18%; the plan is to reach that target by 2046.

A little history. In the late 19th century, Irish forests were in a very critical state: as a result of human activity and capitalist development, the area of Ireland's forests fell to a historic low, reaching about one percent of the country's total territory. After independence was gained in the 1920s, a state afforestation programme was launched. In the 1950s-80s, forestry shifted towards fast-growing, introduced conifer species in order to rapidly achieve so-called timber self-sufficiency. Today Ireland's forest area has reached ~750,000 hectares. The emphasis has shifted from “pure” commercial activity towards ecosystem restoration.

A profile of Ireland's forests

Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis) dominates in Ireland, accounting for more than half of all forest stands. The second most common species is pine; broadleaves – oak, birch and ash – make up the smallest share, although their proportion in young stands is being artificially increased and subsidised. Ireland's maritime climate and fertile soils give it the fastest conifer growth rates in Europe, with trees able to reach felling age in around 30 years. Total timber harvesting volume stands at 5.2 million cubic metres. A major problem is the mass dieback of ash trees, and addressing it now already requires state support.

Forest ownership and management

The largest forest manager is the state-owned company Coillte, which manages roughly 440,000 hectares of forest land. It should be stressed that an ever larger share of Ireland's forests is owned by farmers. Through tax relief and afforestation grants, such as the new €1.3 billion programme, the state gives private individuals a strong incentive to convert pasture into forest. In Ireland, every timber harvest, road construction or afforestation project requires a special licence from the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. The €1.3 billion forestry programme approved by the Irish government is the most financially generous in the country's history. Its main aim is to motivate private landowners, especially farmers, to convert part of their pasture or low-fertility land into forest stands. The programme rests on two tiers of financial support: fully paid establishment costs, and annual, tax-free grants or premiums.

The establishment grant covers absolutely all costs associated with soil preparation, buying saplings, planting and fencing young stands to protect them from deer damage. This grant is paid in two instalments – the owner receives three-quarters of the sum immediately after the work is completed, and the remaining quarter four years later, once tending of the young stand has been successfully completed.

Annual premiums, meanwhile, are paid for twenty consecutive years to farmers and fifteen years to “non-farmers”. The level of funding depends directly on the forest type chosen, and the state clearly prioritises biodiversity. The greatest support goes to projects aimed at protecting water bodies and creating natural habitats – there the annual premium reaches as much as €1,142 per hectare, while growing native broadleaves such as oak and birch earns €1,103 per hectare per year. By comparison – commercial conifer plantations dominated by Sitka spruce, which must include at least 20% broadleaf admixture, receive significantly less support – around €746 per hectare per year. A special category is agroforestry, which combines tree growing with livestock grazing. Here the establishment grant is the highest of all, at more than €8,500 per hectare, but the premium payment period is shortened to ten years.

Nature conservation – conflicts and scandals

The Court of Justice of the European Union has found Ireland guilty of breaching the EU Habitats Directive, because the state has failed to protect hundreds of special protected areas and has allowed forests to be planted in so-called ecologically sensitive bogs. The European Commission is taking Ireland to court over the inadequate protection of carbon-rich peatlands from illegal peat extraction and unsuitable afforestation. Local activists are actively fighting so-called green deserts, or Sitka spruce monoculture plantations, which, in their view, acidify the soil, destroy biodiversity and create visual isolation for rural communities. In response, the EU Nature Restoration Regulation obliges Ireland to draw up a national plan for restoring degraded ecosystems.

Legal “guerrilla warfare”

Nature conservation activists in Ireland have now become one of the most influential, better organised, but at the same time also most controversially judged forces in the country. Their activity can be described as aggressive, uncompromising and highly versed in the law. Unlike the green activists of the past, who staged physical protests in the forests, today's Irish eco-activists employ legal “guerrilla warfare” tactics.

For example, An Taisce and the more radical local groups – Save Leitrim or the FÁILTE network, in particular, have mastered EU legislation (the Aarhus Convention and the Habitats Directive) especially well. Their main weapon is mass appeals against timber harvesting, road construction and afforestation licences to the Forestry Appeals Committee and the Irish High Court. Activists deliberately file thousands of complaints demanding ever stricter environmental impact assessments, literally “burying” state authorities and creating enormous problems.

Eco-activists have forced the state and Coillte to abandon clear-felling on steep, erosion-prone slopes and to stop using chemicals.

Thanks to eco-activist pressure, the new forestry programme requires commercial spruce stands to give up area in favour of native broadleaves and wildlife corridors. Aggressive eco-activists also achieved a halt to industrial peat extraction, stressing the particular importance of bogs for carbon sequestration.

Farmers, rural communities and timber companies often describe eco-activists as “a city elite cut off from rural reality”. They are criticised sharply for several reasons. One example is the so-called NIMBY, or Not In My Back Yard, syndrome. Activists often speak beautifully about green energy and forests, yet block any real project in their own neighbourhood. Exactly the same tendencies can be observed here in Latvia too. In Ireland, activists fight spruce forests and peat burning at the same time as filing court claims against wind farms in former bogs, arguing that the turbines disturb birds. This creates a dead end – neither peat nor wind energy. A typical outcome when eco-activist ideas are allowed to be put into practice.

Blocking licences has created a situation in which small-scale timber harvesters and local machine operators are losing their jobs and going bankrupt. Activists' actions are often seen as an attack on rural people's right to earn a living. The activists' goal has long ceased to be sustainable management and has become the complete halting of economic activity instead. Their ideal is a “teenage dream” of completely pristine nature, ignoring the fact that Irish society needs timber for house-building and jobs in the regions. As a result, the radicalism of the zealots is creating a deep rift and polarisation between city and rural dwellers. A very similar situation, it seems, is being deliberately created here – in Latvia, in order to weaken the national economy.

How Ireland's judicial system curbs abuse of litigation

In recent years, Ireland's judicial system and government have carried out radical reforms to end a situation in which environmental activists could block strategic state development projects endlessly and without financial risk. Historically, Ireland operated the so-called “costs protection rule” (Notional Costs Protection), which, under the Aarhus Convention, meant that environmental activists could take any forestry or construction project to court and, if they lost, did not have to reimburse the other side's legal costs. This created legal impunity and encouraged mass blocking of licences.

To change this, the government passed the new Planning and Development Act (Planning and Development Act), introducing significant filters and restrictions.

The law sets stricter criteria for claimants, the so-called Locus Standi test. For an NGO or a private individual to challenge a forestry licence or a building permit in the High Court, they must meet strict criteria. The organisation must be officially registered and have been actively working in environmental protection for at least two years, and it must demonstrate a direct, well-founded connection to the specific case. This prevents suddenly created “letterbox” groups from blocking local projects. The new regulation has also limited full immunity from costs. If a judge finds that an eco-activist's claim is manifestly unfounded, intended to deliberately drag out time, or legally flawed (frivolous or vexatious), the court is entitled to order the claimant to cover, in whole or in part, the legal costs of the state and the private developer, which can run to hundreds of thousands of euros. So that cases do not drag on for years, a specialised Planning and Environment division has been set up within the Irish High Court, staffed by judges who are experts in environmental law, allowing cases to be heard on an accelerated basis – within months rather than years, minimising downtime losses for foresters and builders.

Administrative barriers have also been introduced at the Forestry Appeals Committee – the FAC. Before a case reaches the courts, complaints are examined by the FAC. The government has introduced small but symbolic fees for filing each complaint and set strict deadlines within which the FAC must reach a decision, clearing the artificially created backlog of thousands of unheard licences.

The farmers' association's fight against eco-activist influence in government

The Irish Farmers' Association, IFA (Irish Farmers' Association), is one of the strongest and most politically influential interest groups in the country. Farmers see forestry restrictions, bog rewetting and eco-activist action as a direct threat to their way of life, their property rights and land tended by generation after generation. The IFA uses an aggressive, well-coordinated strategy to politically resist “green pressure”.

The IFA maintains a permanent office in Brussels and close contacts with members of the Irish parliament, especially those from rural constituencies. It worked actively to soften the original drafts of the EU Nature Restoration Regulation, ensuring that rewetting agricultural land and bogs remains voluntary for farmers rather than mandatory.

The IFA has made use of the “ash dieback” problem. This disease has destroyed thousands of hectares of private forest. The IFA used the crisis as a political weapon, organising so-called tractor protests and public campaigns to show the government and its “green partners'” inability to help affected farmers. As a result, the government was forced to approve an additional €100 million support package for forests affected by ash dieback.

The IFA firmly opposes any attempt by the state company Bord na Móna to rewet bogs if there is even the smallest risk of waterlogging neighbouring private fields. The union provides farmers with free legal assistance and independent hydrologist expert opinions so that they can block state projects, demanding huge compensation or the construction of costly protective embankments.

The IFA actively spreads a “food security” message in the media, arguing that eco-activist demands to cut cattle numbers and turn productive pasture into bogs or native broadleaf stands will lead to rising food prices and the complete depopulation of rural Ireland. It positions farmers as the “true guardians of nature”, who manage the land in a practical way, contrasting them with urban environmental activists, whom the IFA calls theorists and radicals.

The clash between the IFA and environmental campaigners has made Irish rural politics sharply polarised, forcing the government to constantly balance strict enforcement of Brussels environmental law against the fear of losing rural votes in national elections.

The County Leitrim phenomenon and the “green desert” conflict

The conflict in County Leitrim, in Ireland's north-west, has become almost a national symbol of the fight against intensive monoculture forestry, and eco-activists often use it in their attacks on the forest sector. The region is historically known for heavy, clay-rich, wet soils, which make traditional cattle or sheep farming economically inefficient. Since the 1980s, the state forestry company Coillte and private investment funds have planted Sitka spruce across vast areas here in particular.

Leitrim currently has the highest forest cover density in the country, at ->20%, though almost all of these forests are dense, uniform conifer plantations. Local residents came together in the Save Leitrim movement, launching litigation and public protests.

Local community activists call these plantations “green deserts”. Their main arguments are social and ecological: dense spruce stands completely block the landscape, visually isolate farmsteads and, in their view, literally “squeeze” people out of the region, since forestry creates no permanent local jobs – machinery and workers only come in for planting or harvesting.

Critics also point to the over-acidification of rivers and the disappearance of local salmon populations, and to the fact that spruce is planted directly in peat, destroying the natural bog ecosystem. The conflict forced the government to introduce quotas limiting the share of conifers in several counties.

Rewetting the Shannon basin and Midlands bogs

The second hottest flashpoint is the Irish Midlands and the Shannon river basin, where Bord na Móna and state agencies are carrying out an ambitious rewetting of former peat-extraction bogs. Here the state's climate goals collide with the existential interests of neighbouring farmers.

Farmers whose land borders these vast bog complexes have formed alliances and regularly block Bord na Móna machinery from accessing drainage systems. The farmers' main argument – blocking ditches also raises the groundwater level on their own private pastures. In several parishes in the Shannon basin, cases have been recorded where, after a bog was rewetted, grain fields and meadows turned into bog themselves, making them useless for livestock farming.

Farmers accuse the state of “hidden expropriation” and of failing to provide accurate hydrological modelling. The conflict is so tense that courts regularly issue temporary injunctions halting work until the state can guarantee that no private plot will be harmed.

Western coastal nature reserves and the hen harrier – Hen Harrier – conflict

In Ireland's western and south-western counties, especially Kerry, Cork and Limerick, a sharp conflict has developed between landowners and conservation authorities over special protected areas established for the hen harrier. The bird nests in open moorland landscapes, and forest planting or intensive farming destroys the areas the hen harrier needs.

When the state, bowing to European pressure, declared large areas hen harrier protection zones, farmers within them were completely banned from both planting forest and carrying out any land improvement works. Landowners saw this as a huge financial blow, since they had planned to sell their low-fertility land to forestry funds or afforest it themselves to receive generous state grants.

Farmers regarded the compensation offered by the state as ridiculously small compared with the value of the forestry premiums lost over 20 years. This has created a paradoxical situation and fierce resistance. Locals view conservation requirements so hostilely that the presence of the bird on their land is seen as a “curse”; this fosters a situation in which the regulatory regime leaves rural communities with no wish at all to cooperate on nature conservation.

The arrival of private investment funds and local community resistance

In recent years, a new socio-economic conflict has flared up in Ireland in connection with the active entry of foreign and domestic investment funds into the forestry market. Taking advantage of the fact that Irish forestry grants and annual premiums are extremely high and guaranteed for 20 years, large financial funds, including British and European pension funds, began buying up agricultural land across rural Ireland on a large scale in order to plant it with profitable Sitka spruce. This provoked a sharp reaction from the farmers' union IFA and from rural residents. Local communities point out that the funds are artificially inflating land prices, leaving young, local farmers unable to buy land to expand their holdings. A particular scandal was caused by Coillte's attempt to set up a joint €200 million fund with the British investment firm Gresham House to buy up Irish land for afforestation. This triggered mass protests outside parliament in Dublin, and the government was accused of “selling Irish land to foreign capital with taxpayers' money”. Under this pressure, the government had to change the rules, stipulating that premiums under the new forestry programme are available in full, on a priority basis, only to active farmers, in an attempt to curb speculation by investment funds and ease tensions in rural areas.

Hunting and public attitudes

Ireland has no traditional model of hunting in state forests. Hunting rights belong to the landowner. The main game species are red deer, fallow deer and the introduced sika deer (Cervus nippon), whose population is growing uncontrollably, causing damage to young stands.

Irish society supports meeting climate targets but is strongly opposed to commercial monocultures. There is demand for publicly accessible recreational forests with walking trails. There is also an enduring conflict between farmers, who demand more intensive control of deer numbers because of the damage they cause, and animal rights organisations, which oppose hunting methods and hunting as a sport altogether.

Add a comment