Germany's systemic errors – why is Europe's largest economy stuck and what will the government change? - Zeme un valsts

Germany's systemic errors – why is Europe's largest economy stuck and what will the government change?

Germany – the engine of the European economy – has been experiencing a prolonged industrial downturn in recent years. In public debates and political battles, the primary scapegoats most often cited are strict climate policy, the abandonment of nuclear energy, and the expensive energy transition, or Energiewende. However, a study by the German Economic Institute IW Köln suggests that this explanation is overly simplistic and even slightly misleading. The true causes of the crisis lie much deeper – in the country's internal structure.

Climate policy is not the only culprit

IW Köln researchers compared Germany's industrial development with other European Union countries that are bound by the same European climate targets and similar regulations. It turned out that in other parts of Europe, industry has been able to grow over the same period. This proves that the Green Deal alone does not explain the weakness of the German economy.

The institute concludes that Germany has lost competitiveness due to internally created obstacles. There are several problems. German companies have some of the highest labour costs among all industrially developed countries, which makes local production unprofitable. High corporate taxes reduce the willingness and ability of companies to invest in Germany; furthermore, the country has excessive bureaucracy and complicated permitting procedures, while a heavy reporting burden paralyses new projects and innovation.

Political battle in Berlin and public sentiment

These findings shed light on the sharp political debates in Berlin. While so-called populist forces are, for understandable reasons, calling for a complete abandonment of climate targets, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and his coalition (CDU/CSU and SPD) are looking for the most pragmatic middle ground – to maintain European market mechanisms, such as the emissions trading system, while simultaneously easing life for entrepreneurs.

The better-educated part of German society, the academic community and business leaders think similarly. Public opinion polls show that people with higher education still support climate protection and understand the need for a long-term green transition, but they are increasingly criticising the inefficiency of public administration, slow digitalisation and outdated infrastructure. The educated part of society sees that the old German success model, which relied on cheap Russian gas and traditional industrial exports, has been exhausted, and the country needs change to maintain prosperity.

The deep divide between Germany's West and East

Economic stagnation is affecting different regions of the country unevenly, exacerbating the historical divide between the former West Germany and East Germany. More than three decades after German reunification, the economic power of East Germany remains stuck at approximately 79% of the levels seen in the west.

The East lacks the headquarters of large corporations and private sector research centres, household incomes are significantly lower, and the population is rapidly ageing. Very much like in Latvia, just on a different scale... All of this creates fertile ground for political discontent and the popularity of radical parties. West Germany's traditional industrial centres, especially the automotive and chemical industry regions, are feeling the drop in exports and high production costs most severely.

The government's response – a wide range of reforms

Aware of the gravity of the situation, F. Merz's government has begun extensive structural reforms to regain investor confidence and kick-start the economy. Key steps include several measures, the most significant being the slashing of bureaucracy. A principle is being introduced in Germany whereby if an authority does not provide a response regarding a project within four months, the permit is considered granted. The planning time for infrastructure and power grids has been significantly shortened. Companies are being given broader opportunities to enter into fixed-term employment contracts, telephone-based sick leave issuance is being restricted, and more flexible working time tracking is being discussed. Tax relief amounting to approximately 10 billion euros is planned from 2027, and a special “Germany Fund” is being created for infrastructure, microchips, artificial intelligence and clean technology development. Due to the demographic crisis, the government is looking for ways to motivate experienced workers to remain in the labour market longer.

Germany's example clearly shows that even the most powerful economy cannot rely on past successes for long. Whether the reforms planned in Berlin will be able to break through the decades-accumulated bureaucracy and trade union resistance will determine the economic future of both Germany and Europe – including the Baltic states.

Sources: German information sites

Add a comment