The road to the draft FSC Interim National Forest Management Standard has been a long one. How would you characterise the result? It is a little surprising that the recently received draft standard is being very carefully evaluated and analysed by the forestry sector, while representatives of the environmental sector have said they have not even really looked into it...
It is true that the forest management standard (hereinafter – the Standard) has been discussed in Latvia for years. There is a previous standard, and there are principles and criteria in the new version of the standard which were created through years of work, involving representatives from environmental, social and economic sectors, as set out in the FSC core principles. As is well known, within the FSC system, these sector representatives are strictly separated, and only the FSC, as an organisation, has the right to decide who belongs to which sector.

Situations often arise, as we have encountered in Latvia, where environmental organisations walk out of the standard development working group; this happened at a moment when a large portion of the standard's criteria (indicators) had already been discussed and agreed upon. What was left? A series of essential indicators and definitions where, as is typical in Latvia, the environmental sector’s viewpoint differed from those representing social and economic spheres. Prior to the environmental sector’s walkout, there were two possible versions of the standard: one proposed by the environmental sector and/or a joint effort by the social and economic sectors.
As can be gathered from the draft standard received in May 2021, the mysterious (anonymous) consultant from Latvia has been working with the previous draft of the standard. Opinions vary, but in reality, we did not receive a translated or slightly amended version of the previously developed draft, but a third version of the standard project. Of course, the FSC representative currently responsible for Latvia from Lithuania spoke about technical or translation details, but upon receiving and reading the text, it became clear: serious editorial changes have been introduced into the standard. This – the third version of the standard – is something else entirely. For example, on the issue that is essential to us – what should be considered high-value forests – a compromise has not been found or created; instead, the definition invented by the environmental sector has been strengthened. Specifically, Category III of high-value forests now includes not only habitats of European Union importance but also potential habitats (i.e. forests that could become habitats over time*). Looking at it professionally, this could be one to three age classes before the lowest quality average age class for habitats. Professionals evaluating forest inventory data will be able to statistically plan at what age forest stands are already to be assessed as protected habitats, and if we talk about potential ones, in how many years they can turn into “FSC high-value forests”. We could be talking here about hundreds of thousands of hectares that are being pushed towards being equated with high-value forests. What does this mean? If habitat mapping data shows about 300,000 hectares of EU-importance habitats, most of which are located outside existing protected areas, equating potential habitats to these 300,000 hectares will “add” another 200,000 hectares. In the current wording of the standard, this effectively means the potential prohibition of managing these territories without an expert opinion. I foresee that, mostly, knowing the situation in Latvia, the expert opinion will be: “No economic activity.”
Potential. The synonyms for the word “possible” are ringing out again...
This is where one should turn to any standard developer and ask: if there is a standard, it must very specifically define what is meant by the term “potential habitat” and what can or cannot be done with such territories. Currently, this has not been done; references must be sought in documents that are being developed independently of the standard and, very likely, are not based on parity between environmental and socio-economic interests, but on ecosystem theory as such. This has been discussed in Latvia for a long time. For example, speaking of the FSC standard and certification – there is no FSC representation in Latvia, these duties are performed indirectly by a Lithuanian colleague. This was also proven at the stakeholders' meeting scheduled for 3 June to discuss the standard: who represents Latvia's interests in the context of the FSC is deliberately hidden, and the FSC is unable to answer questions asked by stakeholders.
Assumption: it may happen, it may not happen
Certain habitats at the block level were first defined as high-value forests with the advent of SBP (Sustainable Biomass Program) certification. At that time, it was estimated that habitats in Latvia covered 51,000 hectares or 1.7% of the forest area.

It must be said that those presenting the risks at the time were wrong by a factor of six. Currently, various classifications – EU importance, local importance, natural forest (also “key forest habitats”), and potential – are all being lumped into one category.
Most significantly, if we look at “potential natural habitats”, we are no longer talking about ~300,000 hectares (which I mentioned before and which is not acceptable to the economic and social sectors), we are already talking about at least 500,000 hectares. What is that? Taking into account the distribution of habitats in state and private forests – that is almost 1/4 of the managed state forest area and effectively all stands that have reached the felling age!
Is it worth the sector being concerned?
Yes, indeed! Moreover, if we see that in the current consultative forum, there is talk of a so-called compromise... What could that be? For example, if we keep the found habitats and remove the potential ones, the reduction in productive forest areas even in this case is catastrophic with very grim consequences for the state. In fact, the standard allows timber extraction only for those forest managers who have a distinctly young forest composition, whereas for those who have managed their forests truly sustainably until now and who have a high proportion of mature and over-mature stands, management could be severely restricted. Even more significant is the fact that the definition of high-value forests also affects holders of the controlled wood standard. By adopting the standard in its current wording, even if companies renounce their 100% FSC certificate, the extraction of FSC-controlled wood and its presence throughout the supply chain is also under threat.
Does certification based on such principles achieve the goal of certification?
I could not describe it with the word “sustainable”.
Habitats of EU importance exist in all three Baltic states. In my opinion, it is important to look at how many mapped/listed habitats each country has. The SBP Regional Risk Assessment mentions that in Estonia, the habitat area is just under 21,300 hectares, or 15 times less than in Latvia! If you compare... in Estonia, these habitats are truly a rarity! The definition of high-value forests is being pushed in a very similar way in all three countries. However... the same scheme can work in different countries, but, undoubtedly, one must know the specific territory and its situation. A country-specific standard is pointless if it is written to be the same for everyone, because, with the situation differing in different countries, the standard is very beneficial for some and completely unsuitable for others. The standard must be based on data and an analysis of the actual impact, not on opinions about something...

We spoke exactly a year ago. In short: your view on the sector during the pandemic year (March 2020 – June 2021).
The year has been varied, but it has brought the understanding that every country must have great self-potential. As the saying goes: “Everyone is the architect of their own fortune.” In many countries, they will have understood this because... what if a situation arises where you cannot purchase essential goods because a ship is stuck in some strait or canal, because... all the absolute essentials are already being produced elsewhere? What is this and what does it mean in the 21st century? In the context of production and other matters, countries must have a strong backbone and be self-sufficient; this year has vividly demonstrated that. Hoping for foreign money is a very dangerous game.
Speaking of the forest sector, we must examine the standard so often mentioned in this conversation, which, if approved in the proposed version, could effectively mean a reduction in the work of the logging and wood processing sector by almost 50%... In that case, there is no talk of the state's sustainable existence! More than ever, one must think in terms of the state. One must be very responsible for everything that is happening. If we talk about international schemes, certification is one of the basic conditions for export, and a reckless attitude towards it can later cost dearly.
Explanation:
* Potential natural forest habitats. Forest stands managed for the preservation of biological diversity that could become protected forest habitats within 20 years in pine and spruce stands, 30 years in oak, ash, linden, elm and wych elm stands, and 10 years in aspen, birch and black alder stands. To be determined in accordance with: Ek T., Suško U. & Auziņš R. 2002: Methodology for the inventory of key forest habitats. State Forest Service, Riga, 76 pp. https://www.daba.gov.lv/lv/media/4679/download
Natural Forest Habitat (NFH) (also key forest habitat) – a habitat in which species are found, or where signs (appropriate substrates, indicator species, etc.) suggest they might be found, that are disappearing in forests managed for timber production. So-called Potential Natural Forest Habitats (PNFH) are also distinguished – forest stands that could become NFHs at a certain time, depending on the dominant tree species, if the main goal of management were the preservation of biological diversity.
Graph from: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02827581.2010.497160



