As the conversation took place with one interlocutor in Jelgava and the other in Dubai, the first question concerned events in the Middle East.
Life in Dubai is fairly normal, except that the tourists have disappeared. The last two or three weeks have been quite calm; hotels and restaurants are certainly missing their usual visitors, but it should be remembered that Dubai is a city of four million people, and life goes on. Of course, the nearby war has brought its own adjustments, though without significantly affecting the pace of life.

The media, too, have been describing the situation over the past few weeks as fairly calm...
That's true! An agreement or deal between the US and Iran is expected, and after that we'll have to see what happens next and how. I'd add that the country's air defence systems are coping very successfully with drones and missiles. In my view, Europe, and the Baltic states in particular, should take a serious interest in how this kind of defence has been achieved and what lessons could be drawn from it. It should be stressed that a great deal of serious, careful work, money and time have gone into building air defence stability in Dubai.
Coming back to current issues in the forestry and wood industry, is there a single word that could describe the present situation in these sectors in Europe?
Challenge (challenge). The construction and forestry sectors are currently facing a considerably more serious crisis than the one we remember from 2007-2008. The situation now is considerably worse than it was then.
Worse even than in spring 2022, when Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine began?
Exactly, it's worse now! I'd add that the severity of the situation hasn't built up overnight; it has literally been accumulating for some time. The sector is affected (hampered) by a whole range of situations and developments, for example the decline in construction activity, which in turn has been driven by inflation and by uncertainty and insecurity about the situation (people have money, but they're saving it rather than spending it). Low construction activity has been observed for quite some time now, and this in turn hits the sawn timber production sector very hard. The escalation of the situation around Iran has only made things worse - logistics costs have jumped, and as a result buyers won't accept the prices the sector needs to charge (because those are the prices that allow businesses to operate). The wood industry is currently losing money, of course with some exceptions. We can describe the price situation very simply - there is a selling price and a purchase price (lock price). If the difference is positive, a company operates successfully and makes a profit. At present that isn't the case, and the ratio between selling and purchase prices isn't healthy for normal business operation.
Are the European Union and the European Commission, who undeniably care about the situation on the EU market, trying to resolve it somehow, or is finding a solution left to the sector itself?
The EU wants to promote and support sustainable buildings, built using sustainable construction materials, in various ways. This support is voiced in many different political speeches explaining what should be done, but... it all stays at the level of political rhetoric. At the same time, the EU argues that larger areas of forest should be protected, which means logging would have to be reduced - and that is in fundamental contradiction with the desire for sustainable buildings.
In short - we're told there is loud support for timber construction, or for using wood in construction, while at the same time being told that less wood should be harvested (cut fewer trees!). Forgive me, but that's simple arithmetic - if there's less wood, we'll also build less! Or will we build with concrete instead, and will that be better?
The situation isn't simple, but... without giving it much thought, we accept beautiful political speeches about a greener and more sustainable way of life, which (and this is forgotten!!!) requires a certain amount of raw material - in this case, wood.
The forestry sector in Europe has been managing forests successfully for many years now. We have far more forest than we did 10, or 20, 30, 40 years ago. What is the clear justification for the call to start protecting forests?
In my opinion, what's missing here is a short, clear message from Brussels, namely that the forestry sector has worked successfully, that today we have more forest, and so on. We haven't heard that message; nobody has thanked us for the good work. Instead of thanks, we hear politicians pontificating about forest protection and cutting back logging. Well, if you politicians want to act this way, please forget about timber buildings, toilet paper, and so on! Forget it! Just tell us - what will you put in their place, and what are your proposals? Concrete, steel? If so, let them come and explain to us how these building materials are better than those obtained from sustainably managed forests.
Your life experience is bound up solely with an independent country. Latvia has 50 years of occupation behind it, which left a large part of society with an aversion, passed down to later generations too, to beautiful, empty political speeches - the kind the then-ruling regime relied on. Is there any explanation for how this problem of empty political speech has now spread across the whole EU? Fine words, with no substance behind them. And people listen.
Of course people listen, because there's no alternative.
You can listen to speeches without actually heeding them or taking them into account. If someone is competent in a field, the speeches can flow on by, while real work and knowledge remain.
That's right! I always find it interesting to hear good words about our sector, including suggestions for what good things we could achieve, but... of course, we want to and can do many good things, but we need the opportunities to do so - laws, rules, permits. We can paint beautiful pictures of the future in words, but we need the roads that lead there.
Europe has more forest than it did 30-40 years ago, and that's an undeniable fact. At the same time, it should be remembered that the European Union at its founding and the European Union now are two different things - what we're talking about today is a machinery riddled with bureaucracy, producing ever more rules, requirements and regulations, which cost EU member states dearly. The inefficiency caused by bureaucratic requirements, and the vast sums of money spent on it, is simply colossal. The Deforestation Regulation (EUDR) and its fiasco, for example, are a vivid illustration of how work goes on in Brussels on some imagined plan, without any real understanding of what is being done, and without sensible discussion with industry representatives. Work on this regulation is still ongoing, it has been postponed for nearly two years now, and we still don't know either the outcome or exactly how it will work. Businesses spend time and effort trying to keep up with the changes taking place, trying to understand them and, where necessary, influence them. At the same time, as I mentioned earlier, the forestry sector is facing the worst crisis in decades. One has to ask - do the people working in Brussels know, or have any sense, of what's really happening: companies are losing money, companies are closing down, plants are being shut, no money is being invested in development, and yet... at a genuinely difficult time for businesses like this one, officials are drafting new rules that only strengthen the bureaucracy.
In my view, they live in an ivory tower and have been cut off from everyday life and the real world for quite some time now.
When forestry matters are discussed in Latvia, our nearby neighbours across the sea - the Finns and the Swedes - are often praised. How is the bureaucracy problem handled in Finland? In Latvia it often happens that when something is decided in Brussels, Latvian representatives resemble little toy soldiers before a stern general: “Yes, sir, that's exactly what we'll do!”
Unfortunately, my answer will disappoint you, because Finland has exactly the same problem.
So we just want to hope that things are better and brighter in Finland, when that's not actually the case...
Bureaucracy is a huge problem in Finland. Relative to our population, we have an enormous administrative apparatus. Finland currently has the highest unemployment in Europe, even higher than Spain's. Finland's economic situation has been disappointing for at least 20 years now. In my view, from an economic standpoint, Finland isn't the best example of things being done right.
I imagine you'll have heard that, according to some surveys, Finland is home to the happiest people in the world. I've thought about this often, and I'm genuinely curious how that's calculated or established - if we have the highest unemployment in Europe, if the national economy isn't doing well, how can we be the happiest? I have only one explanation - the bar for happiness is set too low, and if you need little, if you want little, you can be happy.
An unexpected answer... You've caught me off guard! Coming back to the reason we got in touch - the events in Latvia three years ago and government support for the wood industry. A few years ago (in 2023) you commented on the situation* for colleagues at “Dienas Bizness”, stressing that the Latvian government had acted correctly. Have you changed your mind since then?
The root of the problem lies in fixed selling prices. 70% of a sawmill's costs are made up of raw material prices, and if those aren't at the right level, you have a problem. You can own the best sawmill in the world and use the most modern technology, but if the raw material price isn't right, you'll lose money. That was the situation in Latvia three years ago: the timber prices set by Latvijas valsts meži (LVM) were “detached from the reality of the time”.
If the situation hadn't been changed or influenced in 2023, the sector would have faced huge problems, such as company bankruptcies, which would obviously have harmed the national economy too. Looking back today at the raw material prices in LVM's contracts, they weren't adequate and weren't realistic, even compared with the corresponding prices in Sweden and Finland. Intervention was needed in that situation to prevent serious problems arising. I won't comment on how the intervention or the attempts to regulate the situation actually happened, because I don't know the details. I'm familiar with the situation in Latvia, I follow developments closely, and I know the matter has now taken on the shade of an investigation, but I'll stress once again - intervention in that situation was necessary!
A question about another still-unresolved matter in Latvia, to make things topical. Several years ago, at an industry conference (at Ogre Technical School), a representative from Finland spoke about cooperation in nature conservation. She was asked whether a situation is possible in Finland where someone turns up on your property, finds something there that needs protecting, and the forest owner only learns of the consequences of that discovery much later. The question had to be repeated, because the Finnish colleague didn't understand it (or rather, she couldn't understand how such a situation could arise). You have a forest, some environmental expert has been on your property with or without your knowledge, has found something requiring protection, and you only find out about it afterwards, when you run into restrictions on your economic activity. Finland is said to base its nature conservation entirely on cooperation.
True, that's very true! I'm not a nature conservation expert, but in Finland it isn't possible for a forest owner to be forbidden from logging or carrying out other work in a forest they own. If you do everything correctly, you're entitled to act on your own property as and when you wish. In my view, one important thing to understand in discussions about environmental protection is this: many environmental organisations, in both Finland and Latvia, talk about “Finland's forests” or “Latvia's forests”, but... the Latvian state owns the forests managed by LVM, while a large share of the remaining forests are private property - the basis of capitalism. A private owner can do as they see fit with their own property, their own forest; neither environmental organisations nor state institutions have any say in how you've decided to manage your own property. I'll repeat - this is one of the points that some participants in discussions about nature or forest protection conveniently forget or ignore. “We must protect Latvia's forests” - hold on - these forests belong to someone, they're somebody's property!
Thank you, a great answer! When do you think the economic situation in the sector might start to stabilise?
I'll joke - my crystal ball no longer works. We're in a situation where what was decided yesterday is no longer relevant today (coyotic world). I'm trying to adapt to that. I'd hoped the situation might start to normalise by the end of this year, and then... the US-Iran conflict began, along with the crisis in the Strait of Hormuz, which affected practically everything - fuel prices jumped, so did transport costs, which only deepened the uncertainty. There's one thing I suspect many people want - clarity, faith in the future, a stable job, a stable salary, which creates a sense of security, and as a result people start spending money instead of putting it away for a rainy day. The statistics show that a lot of bank accounts are quite healthy, people have plenty of money they aren't spending, and that's creating serious problems for Europe right now. We need stability, predictability, something to get the wheels of the economy turning again so that life can return to its normal track. Enough of running into one new crisis after another.
How are the shifting US tariffs affecting the situation in the sector?
They keep changing, and they're a significant part of the “new uncertainty”. For Canadians, for example, these tariffs are causing enormous problems, because Canadian sawn timber producers rely heavily on the US market. The US imposed tariffs in the hope of making its own wood-processing industry more sustainable, by importing less raw material from abroad. That isn't really working very well, though, because Canadians have always accounted for a significant share of the US timber market, since the United States doesn't have enough sawmills to meet domestic demand, nor does it have the corresponding logging capacity or the necessary infrastructure. President Trump imposed the tariffs; we don't know what the next president after him will do. The uncertain situation and the tariffs are effectively preventing investment in sawmill development.
Forewarned is forearmed - have you heard of any possible new problems for the sector that might again come out of Brussels? What should we be ready for?
First, I should say that new regulations and plans come out of Brussels almost every day. The recently launched Omnibus project to cut red tape is a good thing, but if you look at other plans, legislation just keeps being produced. The Omnibus might slow the pace at which regulation is created, but regulations are being made and will keep being made regardless. This is something the sector should think about and be cautious of - I'd say the sector needs to follow events in Brussels closely, and there are far too few industry representatives in the Belgian capital. The EUDR is a vivid example of how a seemingly good idea has developed in a literally awful and wrong direction; it would certainly have taken less time and effort if the whole thing had been planned clearly and comprehensibly.
* https://www.db.lv/zinas/balku-cenu-limenis-latvija-aped-starptautisko-konkuretspeju-513921



