Currently, mixed forests are becoming dominant in Finland, as they offer a more diverse range of species and are more resilient to climate change and forest pests.
“The era of spruce stands, if you can call it that, is over,” reported Metsälehti, a magazine owned by Finnish forest owners, in November 2023.
“Mixed forests reduce the risk of forest damage; they are more resilient, including against bark beetle infestation,” Antti Marjokorpi, Stora Enso’s Forestry Sustainability Director, who is responsible for forest management, tells the portal Forest.fi (Antti Marjokorpi). The logic is simple: every pest “specialises” in or prefers a specific tree species. In a forest containing different species of trees, the spread of the European spruce bark beetle will be slower or even come to a complete halt.
Forest damage is a very serious problem that threatens nature, timber availability, and carbon dioxide sequestration. According to data from the Finnish Forest Centre, more than 6,000 hectares of forest had to be harvested in Finland last year due to insect damage. The volume of harvesting carried out for such reasons has increased significantly in Europe recently. In Germany and the Czech Republic, bark beetles have destroyed vast forest areas, causing serious disruption to timber markets as well. The most important factors for the “well-being” of bark beetles are drought and prolonged periods of heat.
Mixed forests are defined differently in different countries. In Finland, they are forests containing at least two tree species, with no single species exceeding 75%. The corresponding maximum percentage in Sweden is 65.
According to A. Marjokorpi’s data, the proportion of mixed forests in Europe varies. In Northern Europe, it is approximately 15%, in Western Europe – about a quarter, in Eastern Europe – about 19%. In South-Western Europe, about 8%, and in South-Eastern Europe – about 17%.
Changes will take decades
For a long time, the most recommended forest management method was to grow only one species, chosen according to local conditions. Four-fifths of Finnish forests are dominated by Scots pine and Norway spruce. There are approximately 30 indigenous tree species in Finland, most of which are broad-leaved.
Political decisions could promote the creation of mixed forests, but A. Marjokorpi also reminds us of the long life cycle of forests. “Only about 1-2% of the total productive forest area is harvested and replanted each year. It will take time before any policy influences the entire forest landscape,” A. Marjokorpi believes.
The species most affected by pests is the Norway spruce. Stora Enso has reduced the density of spruce plantings in its managed areas from 1,800 to 1,600 seedlings per hectare. Reducing planting density by just over a tenth will encourage the natural regeneration of other tree species, especially birch. Metsä Group and UPM have made similar decisions. UPM aims to double the proportion of broad-leaved trees across approximately 520,000 hectares of forest.
“It is useful to start preparing for climate change. The presence of different species in the forest will not only ensure biodiversity but also create more opportunities and improve the resilience of the forest (to climate change),” says Tiina Laine, Metsä Group’s Head of Forest Management. This year, mixed forest stands have also been planted in Finnish forests, containing both spruce and pine, as reported by Metsähallitus in September.
Historic changes in forest management
There have historically been changes in the tending of young stands. Since spruce seedlings are easily shaded by broad-leaved trees, it was long recommended not to leave broad-leaved trees at the start of spruce seedling care. Now, there is a tendency to increase the number of broad-leaved trees. According to data from the Natural Resources Institute Finland, the growth of spruce and pine in mixed stands does not slow down if tending is carried out as intended.
“A mixed forest does not harm profitability; rather, it may enhance it in the long run, and growth is neither reduced nor hindered,” Sauli Brander, Vice President at UPM (Sauli Brander), tells the newspaper Maaseudun Tulevaisuus.
Mixed forests adapt to the environment
Broad-leaved forests are beneficial for the forest environment. Leaves shed in autumn reduce soil acidity, helping both trees and other plants to receive nutrients more quickly. In a mixed forest, different tree species can complement each other in various growth conditions.
“For example, pine and birch require plenty of sunlight, whereas spruce can grow well in a shadier environment. In a dry location, pine will dominate more because it is best able to withstand dry conditions in Finland and the Nordic countries,” explains A. Marjokorpi. Pine stands growing in normal or moist conditions often have a mixture of spruce. Birch and spruce can also coexist in relatively wetter conditions. Mixed forests improve biodiversity because each tree species has its own companions.
“Birds may prefer to nest in specific tree species. Even the fungi living in deadwood are often very ‘picky’, just like most insects,” continues A. Marjokorpi in his explanation. Despite the positive factors listed, he assesses that it is difficult to say whether the proportion of mixed forests should be increased everywhere in Europe.
“Every forest must be evaluated in the context of regional climate and human use. What is best in each place (region, situation) must be researched at the local and regional level,” A. Marjokorpi summarises.



