Climate investors defend Stobo forestry project in Scotland - Zeme un valsts

Climate investors defend Stobo forestry project in Scotland

Now that a group of environmental activists in Scotland has been granted permission to bring a court claim against the Scottish forestry department (Scottish Forestry, hereafter referred to as Scottish Forestry), the situation has also been commented on by investors who have put money into offsetting the effects of climate change by establishing plantation forest. The activists insist that, in allowing the project to go ahead, Scottish Forestry failed to comply with environmental protection rules. Much as here in Latvia – anything foresters do is challenged and condemned, without anyone looking into the substance of the matter…

The 700 ha Stobo plantation near Peebles, in the south of Scotland, is being created by True North Real Asset Partners, the largest investor in afforestation projects in Scotland.

Harry Humble, chief executive of True North, stresses that the company's business is investment in mitigating the consequences of climate change: “It is regrettable that, after three years of public consultation, this matter has ended up in court, which will mean additional costs for taxpayers.”

Those pursuing the objection (the court claim), Stobo Residents Action Group Ltd (SRAG), lodged a petition for judicial review, arguing that Scottish Forestry had not followed the proper protocols and had not carried out an environmental impact assessment of the “visual impact” of the new forest on local walking routes. In July, SRAG was granted permission to take the case to court.

H. Humble, for his part, explains: “We have carried out an extensive, thorough and responsible design and consultation process together with Scottish Forestry and all other interested parties in order to develop the Stobo forest project in accordance with the environmental impact assessment rules.”

He added: “In design work of this kind, every issue is recorded precisely. Together with Scottish Forestry, which acts both as arbiter and as regulator, agreement was reached on proportionate mitigation of environmental impacts, or on improving the situation where that is necessary.”

The management of True North maintains that it did sufficiently serious preparatory work, commissioning CGI modelling of the area in order to show all interested parties, including Scottish Borders Council, the real visual impact of the planned forest on the walking route in question – the John Buchan Way.

The chief executive of True North added: “We held public consultations four times. The people associated with SRAG (those who brought the case to court) did not engage at all during the forest design stage. The objections appeared (were raised) at the last moment – after the mandatory 28-day consultation period had already passed, immediately after Scottish Forestry had approved the afforestation project.”

Add a comment