European clean technology exports account for 23% of the global market.
The race to 'win' in the field of clean technology is becoming increasingly intense, yet according to new information, European policymakers are overly concerned about the competitiveness of green technology.
In March 2023, the EU Commission presented its Net-Zero Industry Act, which aims to produce at least 40% of strategically important clean technologies within the local market. With this, Europe hopes to counter the growing dominance of China in the field of green technology and competition from the US Inflation Reduction Act (IRA).
However, in a policy report published on 12 June by the independent Centre for European Reform (CER), senior economist Sander Tordoir and deputy director John Springfield urge moderation and warn that the European Union should not overreach by engaging in a subsidy race or rivalry.
The US and China are directly subsidising eco-friendly production, but the authors warn that copying such policies in Europe could create unfair competition between countries, as wealthier nations can afford more than smaller ones.
This, in turn, could threaten the European single market, which, as stated in the document, is the 'main reason for the European Union's manufacturing excellence, as it strengthens competition and innovation'.
The analysis also reveals that the EU is already in a strong position compared to its main competitors – China and the US. While China’s low-carbon technology goods exports hold the largest share of the global market at 34%, the EU is comfortably in second place with 23%. Moreover, the EU has increased its export share in recent years, whereas the volume of US exports remained stagnant at 13% between 2019 and 2022.
As clean technology markets consolidate and manufacturers discover more efficient production methods, profit margins are becoming smaller, making long-distance transport less attractive. For example, in 2022, electric vehicle exports decreased by 1.3% for every one per cent increase in distance between trading partners, compared to 0.9% in 2017.
Increase local supply
Protectionist measures could hinder the green transition by increasing the prices of raw materials necessary for decarbonisation, which could slow down the shift. Instead, the EU should focus on expanding local supply, the authors argue.
They point out that the demand for clean technologies, such as heat pumps, electric vehicles or solar panels, currently exceeds EU supply.
'It is not surprising that the EU’s emission reduction policy has triggered a rapid demand for green technologies that EU manufacturers are not yet able to meet, but will be able to over time,' notes CER deputy director John Springfield.
EU imports of lithium batteries have increased from 900 million euros in 2017 to just under 60 billion euros in 2022. However, the authors point out that many battery production plants are being developed in Europe, and total production volume is expected to meet domestic demand by 2030.
'This optimistic outlook should make European policymakers think twice before granting even more subsidies for the construction of factories,' the specialists argue.
CER senior economist Sander Tordoir believes that the EU should focus subsidies on the domestic production of emerging technologies such as hydrogen, and that they should be used to 'avoid dependencies' in markets where a global 'oligopoly or duopoly might arise, for example in the field of wind turbines'.



