After the First World War, all countries in Central and Eastern Europe (12 in total) situated in the territory between Germany and Russia implemented land reform. The state confiscated and redistributed noble estates, although the compensation mechanisms and the progress of these reforms varied. In Latvia, the transition from a feudal to a capitalist system—or land reform—was the most radical in Europe (if one excludes the Bolsheviks); the vast majority of nobles whose properties were expropriated by the state received no compensation whatsoever.
"Land reform was an absolutely necessary political step that governments after the First World War had to take. Everything had changed. From dietary habits to the role of women and the structure of society. The importance of food at the end of the First World War had clearly grown in Europe, and all governments understood how crucial food stocks were. In Germany, for example, there was real famine. What are the main components of famine? A lack of agricultural products, a lack of bread. Naturally, for the countries of Central and Eastern Europe, the bread factor and winning the favour of the peasantry were extremely important," historian and University of Latvia professor Ēriks Jēkabsons tells the "Delfi" portal.
Agrarian reform entails legislative changes that create a new order in rural areas under state supervision. "We cannot look at Latvia in isolation; land reform was happening everywhere. This land reform was influenced by various components. In the countries between Germany and Soviet Russia, politics and previous historical relations played a large role. Starting from Bulgaria, where estates were taken from Bulgarian Muslims and divided among Bulgarians. It was the same in Yugoslavia, where estates were taken from Muslims, Croats, and Austro-Hungarian Germans. In Poland, land was taken from Germans, Russians, and Poles themselves; in Lithuania, it was taken from Poles; and in Estonia, from Germans and Russians. In Finland, estate lands were taken from Swedes and Russians, and in Czechoslovakia from Germans. Here, both political and ethnic factors go hand in hand. And in all these countries, the so-called 'leftist' element was very important—it was essential for the government to gain the trust of the farmers. So that farmers would finally feel at home in their own country."
In Latvia, due to special circumstances, this 'leftist' sentiment was even stronger than in other countries. There are reasons for this, such as the level of education, which allowed a farmer or a simple working lad to understand that something in this land was not right. Another factor was 1919, when Latvia became a crossroads of military operations. In Estonia, the First World War arrived only in 1918, while Lithuania is Catholic, so this 'leftist' sentiment was not as topical there. A churchgoer will never be as radical," Jēkabsons notes, highlighting the differing circumstances in the Baltics.
Thanks to the reform, Poles strengthen their position on the periphery of the state
On 10 July 1919, the Polish Sejm decided that the land of large landowners would be redistributed in favour of the farmers. A year later, it was decreed that the maximum amount of land that could remain in the hands of a private owner was 150 hectares. Some exceptions remained in the eastern and western territories of the country, writes Lithuanian historian Gediminas Vaskela in the study "1919–1940 Land Reform: Lithuania and the Countries of Eastern and Central Europe." For example, in the eastern parts of Poland, where farmers were mostly Ukrainians and Belarusians, nobles were allowed to keep up to 300 hectares of land, thereby strengthening Polish positions in these regions.
"In Poland, there were problems with land distribution; there was little land, and it was not enough for everyone. Furthermore, in Poland and several Southeast European countries, the land reform was unsuccessful. The reason for this was the principle of inheritance. After a father's death, land property was divided equally among all sons. Consequently, small plots of land were split into tiny fragments. A similar principle also existed in Latgale," Jēkabsons points out.
On 15 July 1920, Poland adopted a decree on land reform, but the law was only approved by the Polish parliament in December 1925. Professor Ēriks Jēkabsons emphasises that in the summer of 1920, Poland was seriously threatened by Soviet Russian troops, which is why the Polish government needed to quickly get the farmers on their side. Once the Soviet forces were driven out, there was no longer any rush for land reform; moreover, the reform bill faced significant resistance from nobles in parliament.
The land distributed to Polish farmers was not given for free; it had to be purchased from the state by taking out a loan. By the Second World War, 2.6 million hectares of land had been distributed as part of the reform, and 734,100 new farms were created in Poland.
(Here and further on, we warn the observant reader that this is not a mistake—indeed, outside the Baltic states, the size of a plot for a new farm during the reform was a mere few hectares; there are several reasons for this: a broad layer of already existing farmers, different geographical conditions, etc.)
A different approach in the new states
Czechoslovakia, which was by no means an agrarian country, also initiated land reform after the First World War. The law on the reform was adopted on 16 April 1919; it stipulated that land properties where cultivated land exceeded 150 hectares or total land area exceeded 250 hectares would be divided, notes Vaskela. Land was mostly taken from German nobles, and these properties were compensated over a long period. In total, land reform in Czechoslovakia affected 4,066,000 hectares of land, but in reality, approximately 1.8 million hectares were distributed to farmers. Thanks to the reform, 634,700 farmers received land.
In Hungary, the law on land reform was adopted in 1920; it did not specify a maximum land area that could remain the property of nobles. However, even in Hungary, land was taken from certain German nobles, which the state pledged to compensate over 50 years. 411,879 people received distributed land, for whom a total of 505,100 hectares of land was measured out.
Yugoslavia adopted a law on land reform on 27 February 1919. The maximum land area that nobles could retain varied in different Yugoslav provinces. While in Dalmatia, for instance, it was 50 hectares, in Serbia, it was up to 500 hectares. By 1931, 2.1 million hectares of land had been distributed to 669,100 Yugoslav families. New settlers had to pay the state for the acquired land within 20 years.
In Bulgaria, laws on land reform were adopted in 1920 and 1921. The land area to be left to large landowners varied: 30 hectares in lowlands, 20 hectares in mountain valleys, and 50 hectares in the mountains. If the owner did not cultivate the land themselves, they were left with only 10 hectares. Land was taken from nobles, monasteries, and various organisations and added to the state land fund, totalling 420,000 hectares. Approximately 200,000 farmers received distributed land, with a total area of 380,000 hectares.
On 29 December 1918, Romania nationalised 2.2 million hectares of land with a special decree. The state took all land from owners who were foreign citizens, whereas local nobles could retain 100 hectares (certain large landowners whose main source of income was agriculture were allowed to keep up to 280 hectares of land). By 1934, 2.3 million farming families had received 2.2 million hectares of land. Farmers had to pay for the received land within 20 years.
Finland began land reform in 1918, but the law for it was only adopted in 1922. It allowed the state to expropriate land properties larger than 200 hectares. Land was distributed to the landless and former tenant farmers, resulting in the creation of approximately 90,000 new farms in Finland.
Estonia and Lithuania pay compensation to nobles
Our northern neighbours, the Estonians, began land reform as early as 1919; 1,065 estate properties covering 2.3 million hectares were expropriated. Along with the land, the state also took livestock, agricultural tools, and buildings from Baltic German and Russian nobles. Nobles could retain 50 hectares of their land. Approximately 53,000 Estonian new settlers received 1.2 million hectares of land.
As Latvian journalist Oto Nonācs noted in 1926, in Estonia, new settlers had to pay for the land: "But freedom fighters get land for free, up to 30 hectares. If, however, someone does not want to receive land, they are paid in money up to 300,000 Estonian marks. Furthermore, there is special compensation money in Estonia associated with the Estonian Cross of Liberty—the highest military order." Estonian farmers had to pay for the land within 60 years; the calculated sum was two to three times less than the actual value of the land at the time. Former Estonian nobles began receiving compensation from the state for the confiscated land in 1926, but this sum was six to nine times less than the real market value.
Although the law on land reform in Lithuania was only approved in 1922, as early as 1919, the newly founded state promised approximately 20 hectares of land to soldiers who had participated in the Lithuanian War of Independence. The land reform law stipulated that nobles could keep up to 80 hectares of land; in 1929, this limit was increased to 150 hectares. In total, the Lithuanian state expropriated 7.2 million hectares of land, part of which was subsequently distributed to approximately 65,000 people. Farmers had to pay a state-determined fee for the acquired land, which was on average six to seven times lower than the market price of the land. Lithuania also paid compensation to former landowners; up to 1939, 1,429,000 litas were paid out in compensation to former nobles. Of this, only 20% received actual cash; others were compensated for their confiscated properties with forest areas or other properties.
When speaking about the Baltic states in the context of agrarian reform, it is interesting to compare the figures on how much land was taken from the church in each country. In Latvia, it was 83.52% of land belonging to churches, in Estonia 88.41%, but in Lithuania only 12.89%.
"Nobles whose land was taken could not be satisfied, that is logical. For example, in Poland, the eastern nobility was considered the most reactionary part of society. They demanded the return of all ancestral properties and almost the restoration of serfdom. There was a Polish noble, Studnicki from Latgale. He was extreme right-wing and said that here, in the Baltics, there are no real nations at all, so why should any property be given to them. He was insulted. And he was not the only one. Polish nobles viewed what was happening through 19th-century traditions and believed that they had brought culture to Latgale. A Polish writer once depicted Latvian farmers as savages living in a swamp," Jēkabsons characterises the mood of the Polish nobility during the agrarian reform.
Baltic Germans complain unsuccessfully to the League of Nations
Even until the conclusion of the First World War, it seemed to the local German nobility in Latvia that noble land ownership was an untouchable tradition of local 'Germanness', notes historian Raimonds Cerūzis in his work 'The German Factor in Latvia (1918–1939): Political and Inter-national Aspects'. "The reform had caused deep dissatisfaction in Baltic German circles and among those in Germany connected to the Baltic Germans. The German and Baltic German press, as well as many Baltic German politicians who were not connected to government circles, allowed themselves much more than mere declarations of sympathy or regret. A common phenomenon in the journalism of the time were slogans about 'agrarian Bolshevism' (Agrarbolschewismus) and 'barbarism' in the once-German Baltic lands," writes Cerūzis.
In 1924, a group of Baltic German Saeima deputies demanded compensation—1,200 million gold francs for the expropriated land properties. Before the decisive vote on 30 April of the same year, the German faction left the Saeima chamber, and as a result, the demand was rejected by a small majority.
In April 1925, two deputies of the 1st Saeima's German faction, Wilhelm von Fircks and Manfred von Fēgezaks, submitted a complaint to the Secretariat of the League of Nations regarding the inequality of minority rights in Latvia, claiming that land and estates were being confiscated without compensation only from inhabitants of Baltic German origin. In its response to the League of Nations, the Latvian government emphasised the socio-political justification for the reform, stating that without agrarian reform, social peace would not be possible in Latvia. Latvia stressed that the agrarian reform was not directed against any national minority, but was a social restructuring directed against the aristocratic class.
The League of Nations rejected the Baltic German claim as unfounded. "It must be admitted that foreign countries paid very minimal attention to this event. Against the background of other major international and national problems in Central and Eastern Europe, the Baltic German problems seemed insignificant to the representatives of the states belonging to the League of Nations, because, for example, minority complaints from Poland were being submitted almost continuously," adds Cerūzis.
A secret diplomatic move—Poles receive compensation from Latvians
It has often been emphasised that after the First World War, the land reform in Latvia was the harshest against nobles, but this is only partially true. Despite the fact that Latvia's agrarian reform law did not provide compensation to former nobles, following a secret agreement with Poland concluded in 1929, the Latvian government paid it compensation for the confiscated estates. In accordance with this agreement, from 1929 to 1937, Latvia paid Poland 5,297,500 gold lats. This fact was hidden from the Saeima in Latvia, and only government ministers knew about it. The Latvian government had also adopted secret decisions on compensation for some nobles—citizens of Italy, France, Switzerland, Austria, and Finland. The total volume of compensation was 877,000 lats.
"There is a myth that Latvia was the most radical in the agrarian reform and that no compensation was paid to anyone for confiscated land. But that is not true. In 1929, Latvia concluded a trade agreement with Poland, which had a confidential annex regarding the payment of this compensation to Polish citizens for the confiscated lands. If you look at the land value, it was quite negligible, a rather symbolic sum. But in any case, it is a precedent that in Latvia, these compensations were paid depending on realpolitik. In this case, Latvia hoped to buy coal and oil from Poland. I have studied these documents in Poland; the former Latgale nobles themselves received only a small part of this sum, the majority of the money went to the Polish state," says Jēkabsons.
Was agrarian reform dictated from 'Washington and Paris'?
Looking today at the broad wave of agrarian reform in the former territories of Russia, Austria-Hungary, and the German Empire, one is tempted to assume that the plan was dictated centrally. However, this is not the case. At least Latvian historians do not have any such information.
Both Latvia and other new European states were told that they should form democracies according to Western standards and take democratic constitutions, such as the Weimar Constitution, as examples, but there were no precise instructions or unified guidelines on land reform—how and to what extent it should be carried out.
Jēkabsons emphasises that after the First World War, the victorious great powers did not dictate to the new European states how they should act with the outdated feudal system and whether they should carry out land reform by distributing noble land properties. "No, there were no such instructions. For example, in Latvia, the Western allies suggested being as democratic as possible, which is why Baltic German ministers were included in the second Ulmanis provisional government in 1919. Western representatives said that Latvia should be tolerant towards the local nobility, because they were, after all, the local intelligentsia. The Americans, in particular, felt that the Baltic Germans were the local elite who were being unfairly pushed aside. At the same time, they acknowledged that the estate system in rural areas was outdated and had to be changed, just like in the rest of Europe."
"Overall, the land reform could not have been fair. It was unfair to the nobles. Firstly, families had land properties taken away that had belonged to them for hundreds of years. Their estate centres were taken, their homes with their ancestors' paintings on the walls, and so on. It is absolute Bolshevism and leftism. If your or my property were taken now, you would think the same. But the previous system was also not entirely fair, and that is why this revolution came about."



