The premiere of Aigars Grauba’s film “Defenders of Riga” (Rīgas sargi) on 11 November at the Congress Centre was met with enthusiasm. Prominent guests stood up and applauded, and later many acknowledged the film's great national importance in both television and the press. It is possible that for both those who liked “Defenders of Riga” and those who liked it less, a few episodes from the film stuck in their memory. For me, there were two. In the middle of the night on the Iron Bridge, Kārlis Ulmanis and his acquaintance, the film’s protagonist Mārtiņš, discreetly sip vodka. Ulmanis notices the word on the label “Sibirskaja”, but Mārtiņš just sighs: “That’s how far the riflemen’s paths led me!” The second episode was the symbolic duel between Lāčplēsis and the Black Knight, which Mārtiņš fights with his fists against a one-eyed German in the church bell tower. This finale strongly reminded one of Alfred Hitchcock’s “Vertigo”, and, remembering the intro to “Defenders of Riga”, where Mārtiņš walks along the roof ridge of the church, it seemed that his “bear’s ears”, similar to “Vertigo” protagonist Detective Scottie Ferguson, are hidden in the courage to overcome his acrophobia. Both episodes were for me a sort of reminder of the Latvian tragedy (Red Latvian Riflemen, alcoholism, Ulmanis’s death) and the prospects of national awakening. Furthermore, it was also a reminder that films can remind us of things at all, as well as a reminder that historical war films are programmed to remind.
In Bertolt Brecht’s play “The Caucasian Chalk Circle”, one of the characters is asked a tricky question: “Why do people love their country?”, to which he, after thinking, replies: “Because there the bread and wine always taste better, the air smells sweeter, voices sound louder, the sky is higher, and the earth is easier to walk on!” Similar views regarding national cinema were recently expressed by the French in the magazine Total Film, choosing Jean-Pierre Jeunet’s “Amélie” as their most patriotic film, and the Americans also overcame their sympathies for national heroes, placing Michael Curtiz’s “Casablanca” in first place. Previously, however, Umberto Eco had noted that “Casablanca” deserves this honour only thanks to the motif of “La Marseillaise” during the opening titles. Both harmless films were the only ones among the vast majority of war narratives that people had preferred, regardless of whether they are considered patriotic, educational, or propagandistic. The choice had fallen on those films where there is a confrontation – the liberal world against the totalitarian, civilisation against barbarism, etc. – the only question was which nation (or part of it) was against which.
Such an attitude once again confirmed a truth that was revealed back in the early days of Hollywood. There, in the 1920s, the biggest studios united for a joint research project to find out how to create productions for people who do not go to the cinema at all. A huge survey campaign was carried out and, as it turned out, the greatest response was to the battle scenes seen on screen, especially details such as a soldier with a weapon on the attack, a soldier with a flag, and also the demonstration of military equipment – warships and armoured trains. Washington later got involved in the project, and it was unofficially included in the government’s Practical Patriotism plan. As far as can be understood, there was far too much practicality in this plan, because individual cinemas began to play the national anthem before films, and once a US Navy sailor even shot one of the viewers with three bullets in the back simply because the unfortunate person had refused to stand up during the singing of the anthem. The public is said to have been enthusiastic about this execution.
By the end of the 1930s, a system for creating ideologically precise war films had already been established in Hollywood, and this system exists in one form or another to this day. At its core is the blending of rituals of order and integration. Assuming that there is a battlefield order ordained by God, providence, or materialist determinism, where “the others” stand against “our own”, the film is intended to make the viewer feel a concrete psychological threat. In an ideologically unstable environment, soldiers on screen fight against an enemy whose past actions and presumed beliefs are politically, ethically, nationally, or even racially different from those defended by “our own” with their last strength. However, the authors take care to ensure that for most of the screen time, the viewer is on the right side of the trenches, where instead of violent impulses (realised in the film by episodes from the enemy’s positions), the emphasis is placed on national unity and teamwork, thus freeing the viewer from the previous sense of threat. Special attention was also paid to the characters of the main protagonists. Most often they are not typical macho loners like Humphrey Bogart’s private detectives or Clint Eastwood’s cowboys. When listing the qualities of a fighter, it was important that he had previous combat experience, was practical, ideologically unyielding, a bit tough, did not belong to the elite, and was a relatively low-ranking officer. Roughly like the Colonel Davy Crockett played by John Wayne in the film “The Alamo” (1960). Thanks to him, the catchphrase “love it or leave it” stuck to the scheme of patriotic films, or the words with which Crockett inspired US soldiers in the film to fight against the Mexicans. It is a strange coincidence that many in Hollywood accused the “perfect hero” Wayne of cowardice when he did not respond to the call to volunteer at the beginning of the Second World War.
The Second World War proved the effectiveness of all the measures listed above, because when the government had to look for additional funds to continue the war, patriotic films became the best advertising for the huge war bond sales and recruitment campaigns. The work of great directors such as John Ford, Frank Capra, William Wyler, and John Huston in the first half of the 1940s consisted mostly of “reels” whose goal was the justification of war and the support of the ideology of Americanism. But when, for example, it turned out that that same John Huston had made the documentary “Let There Be Light” in 1946, which served as proof that about 500 thousand soldiers had returned from the war with deep psychological trauma, the director was asked, in the style of the Politburo, to put the film “on the shelf” until 1981.
Since the war, nothing has changed – the producer must know what the nation needs, long before the nation itself senses it. For example, Hollywood’s “most expensive” modern producer Jerry Bruckheimer counted on the fact that 2001 was the 60th anniversary of American participation in the Second World War: another film was made about the 1941 Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. The premiere of the film took place in May 2001, but just three months later, Bruckheimer, along with other major producers, refocused on a new historical theme. The reason for this was the simple arithmetic calculation that World Trade Center employees did not serve in the US military on 11 September, and thus were twice or even three times as much victims compared to those soldiers who fell at Pearl Harbor or on the shores of Normandy. After the events of 11 September, an agreement was reached between the US government and the major studios to support the country’s new foreign policy course through cinema. Producers like Bruckheimer, who created the series “E-Ring” to rehabilitate the Pentagon’s anti-terrorism course abroad, only repeated earlier examples. Already in 1984, Paramount Pictures concluded an agreement with the Pentagon’s naval department regarding what the duration of transport ship and military airstrike scenes would be in the film “Top Gun” (1986), which, by the way, is also included in the top ten most patriotic US films. It turned out that in this way, the army was trying to obtain additional funds from the state budget for the purchase of F-14 fighter jets. In the end, after this and all other subtle profit calculations, those same patriots hissed at director Michael Moore’s criticism directed against Bush and the war in Afghanistan during the 2003 Oscar ceremony, and the studio Miramax refused to produce his “exposing” project “Fahrenheit 9/11” – even though Moore uses their own techniques, just in a different camp.
The world has inherited much from this Hollywood experience in patriotic education. In new countries, they now know that in addition to the civic function, it is also a good business – which, after all, does not require large financial investments. They always turn out to be the most expensive films of their country of all time, and I assume that this psychological condition makes patriotic films engaging even for those who do not visit cinemas at all. In 2002, Elmo Nüganen made the most expensive Estonian blockbuster of all time, “Names in Marble”, a weakly romanticised film about the 1918 wars of independence (it is ironic that the authors of “Defenders of Riga” later admitted it as their source of inspiration, although some of the main villains in the film were Latvian riflemen). In the same year, Géza Bereményi made the most expensive Hungarian film of all time, “The Unifier”. The film tells about Hungarian freedom efforts in the middle of the 19th century, and its 7.5 million dollar budget significantly exceeded the annual funding allocated to Hungarian national cinema. Our own “Defenders of Riga” also turned out to be the most expensive Latvian film of all time.
However, the investments pay off, because the “young ones” sometimes do not even suspect the merits of their parents in the Singing Revolution, let alone the twists and turns of the century-old wars of independence. That is now the priority of post-totalitarian Eastern Europe – to remind our own people of national history, so that, as Valdis Zatlers said in his speech on 18 November, no one thinks to receive love for their country by post like a newspaper, but rather tries to find it in their heart. And cinema, as Lenin said, is also work with the heart.
Article first published in the December 2007 issue of Rīgas Laiks magazine



