Why the offshore wind energy sector in the European Union is struggling - Zeme un valsts

Why the offshore wind energy sector in the European Union is struggling

Despite growing demand for clean energy and political enthusiasm, offshore wind projects are being cancelled or delayed due to rising costs.

A few months after Russia invaded Ukraine, five European leaders and the EU Commission signed the Esbjerg Declaration. Named after the Danish coastal city, the document set out plans in May 2022 to transform the North Sea into Europe’s green power station – an offshore renewable energy system connecting Belgium, Denmark, Germany, and the Netherlands.

The coalition, which has since been joined by France, Ireland, Luxembourg, as well as non-EU members Norway and the UK, wants to build a massive, interconnected offshore wind farm system. By 2050, it could produce 300 gigawatts (GW) of energy – ten times the current capacity and enough to power 200 million homes.

With little suitable space inland and extensive coastlines (the UK coastline alone stretches for 17,820 km), offshore wind energy appears poised for a major breakthrough. However, despite the growing demand for clean energy and political enthusiasm, offshore wind projects across the North Sea coast are being cancelled or delayed due to rising costs.

Zero-subsidy bids expose project developers entirely to price risks, creating 'worse financing conditions' (higher costs of capital), researcher Max Dukan from the Climate Finance and Policy Group at ETH Zurich pointed out to EUobserver. Yet, no-subsidy bids are attractive to finance ministers who can 'sell' them as a big win for taxpayers. This has been the standard in Germany. The Netherlands also only allows for negative or zero-subsidy bids.

One example of an auction this year involving unlimited negative bidding was the victory of two major oil companies – British Petroleum (BP) and Total – for all available sites in the first of Germany’s two offshore wind auction rounds. They paid 6.7 billion euros and 5.8 billion euros respectively, which equates to 1.8 billion euros per gigawatt.

In a recent statement, the lobby group Wind Europe wrote that 'governments must not be tempted to run unlimited negative auctions' as energy companies will simply pass these extra costs on to consumers or manufacturers 'who are already struggling'.

Flexibility

However, not all countries follow this system. The UK and Denmark are negotiating what are known as two-way contracts, which introduce a profit cap but also guarantee a minimum price for developers. This system reduces price volatility because it requires producers to pay back excess profits, while lowering investment risk by guaranteeing future revenues.

Industry representatives and academics agree that price predictability under two-way contracts reduces risk and lowers the cost of capital for offshore wind projects. Furthermore, the EU Commission has firmly advocated for so-called 'two-way CfDs' (a two-way contract for difference is a contract between an electricity producer and a public authority that sets a strike price through a competitive process, which is being adopted across the EU).

Yet this form is not without its problems either. For example, in recent projects implemented in the UK, previously agreed prices quickly became unviable because development costs rose sharply by 40%.

The Swedish company Vattenfall is trying to renegotiate last year’s contracts to guarantee higher minimum prices for cancelled projects and those still under development. However, re-negotiations have proven difficult as the government is insisting on low prices since the contracts did not include an inflation indexation clause.

Therefore, Wind Europe is advocating for fully indexing auction prices to cover inflation between the auction and the actual procurement of equipment. The procurement process usually takes a year and a half.

Investment in new offshore wind projects fell by 40% in 2022, reaching its lowest level since 2009. No commercial offshore wind project was granted consent in 2022.

“A perfect storm”

The lobby group Wind Europe blamed last year’s revenue caps and government-imposed clawback measures in a recently published market report. These were intended to help protect households and businesses, as market uncertainty deterred investors from making final investment decisions. The delays in decisions, in turn, made it difficult to predict future developments.

There are signs of a resurgence in 2023. In the first half of this year, 212 wind turbines were connected to the grid. However, to meet its goals, the EU needs to add an average of more than 11 gigawatts per year by 2030. That means approximately 1,100 wind turbines. Moreover, there are signs that the recovery remains quite fragile. The Swedish clean energy developer Vattenfall recently shook the market by dropping the Norfolk Boreas offshore wind farm project in the UK, citing a 40% increase in costs within one year. This was linked to difficulties in securing necessary components from China and general inflation.

Supply issues and general inflation are likely to be short-term problems. However, industry leaders clearly see that the business environment is deteriorating and are warning of long-term challenges ahead.

'Offshore wind has hit a “perfect storm”,' Vattenfall’s Senior Vice President Heleen Biström (Heleen Biström) emphasised in June while presenting interim financial results. 'We still believe that offshore wind is essential for the transition to clean energy, but the profitability challenge is also a structural issue.'

One of the most significant factors undermining the perceived offshore wind boom is the somewhat abstract concept of 'cost of capital' (CoC).

Developing and building offshore wind projects is complex. It requires higher initial investments than onshore wind farms and solar energy. Investments in this sector are considered riskier, which encourages investors to seek higher returns and forces project developers to increase loan interest rates.

In the best of circumstances, this can be significant. According to recent research published by researcher Max Dukan from the Climate Finance and Policy Group at ETH Zurich, rates for offshore wind projects in Germany between 2017 and 2020 were 3.3% higher than for solar and onshore wind projects.

The combination of interest rate hikes by the European Central Bank, geopolitical unpredictability, and price volatility has brought the industry to a critical 'breaking point'.

'The cost of capital is affecting the entire energy sector,' Vattenfall CEO Anna Borg noted in the company’s interim financial report. 'Offshore wind projects have thus been rendered “particularly vulnerable”'.

It must be admitted that it is not only external shocks that threaten offshore wind energy. Flawed domestic policies are also hindering the development of offshore wind energy.
https://euobserver.com/green-economy/157369

Add a comment