It has been claimed publicly that the Cabinet of Ministers' order requiring the state forest manager a/s “Latvijas valsts meži” (LVM) to make adjustments to its long-term cooperation agreements, changing the price indexation mechanism and applying weighted average prices, has created a situation in which the state budget supposedly failed to receive some 30 million euros.
This claim is not true, because the figures show something quite different. The state budget law provided that the state forest manager (LVM) would pay into the state budget no less than 58.574 million euros in dividends for 2024; in fact the company paid slightly more than 111 million euros, that is, 52.9 million euros more than was originally forecast. Instead of the 90 million euros of profit LVM had planned, it earned 150 million euros. Is that a lot or a little? Between 2011 and 2021 LVM's profit averaged around 70 million euros a year, while at the same time the industry made significant investments and doubled its added value. In 2021 LVM earned its largest profit up to that point – 112 million euros – while producers of sawn coniferous products earned 178 million euros.
Why is 2021 a special year?! It was the “peak” of the Covid-19 pandemic, with restrictions of every kind (some sectors working under enormous limitations, others closed altogether, people confined to their homes, travel impossible), and many developed both a strong desire and the opportunity to improve their living conditions. As a result, building material prices rose to an unprecedented degree – by up to 300% in the USA, for example, with similar increases seen in the United Kingdom and other markets that matter to Latvian producers.

In 2022, seeing how selling prices had risen, timber processors bid prices at auction for resources (longer-term cooperation agreements) that matched the situation of the moment, and in that year (2022) LVM earned an even more impressive profit – 242 million euros – while the largest coniferous timber processors earned 91 million euros, which is 87 million euros less than in 2021. The reason? Timber processors were paying the very high prices they themselves had bid for coniferous sawlogs, while the market prices of the corresponding products were falling. In 2023 everything continued much as in 2022 – prices for finished coniferous products on foreign markets kept shrinking, yet in Latvia producers were buying coniferous sawlog resources from LVM at the prices they themselves had bid. As a result LVM earned 221 million euros – only slightly less than in 2022 – while the largest coniferous timber processors ended the year with heavy losses. Such a situation could not continue for long.
![]() |
![]() |
But those coniferous sawlog prices had been bid by the timber processors themselves!
Yes, the timber processors did bid those prices, but it must be borne in mind that in 2021 a new longer-term (three-year) cooperation model was created between LVM and the timber processors, the roundwood processors, which also included a timber indexation mechanism based on the prices for the particular roundwood assortment in competitor countries (Lithuania, Estonia and Sweden).
At the end of 2021, the basket of prices in those countries produced a calculated price index – the price determining the price of coniferous roundwood – of 90 euros/m³, and accordingly, as befits a careful manager, the budget assumed a price of 94-95 euros/m³. It was precisely from this price that the auction started, and the timber processors, caught up in the price euphoria of 2021, drove it up to 114 euros/m³. You do not change the rules while the game is under way – except, it seems, this time. The auction step was initially 0.15 euros/m³, and at that price increment the buyers changed over roughly 80,000 m³ of coniferous sawlogs; since the bidding dragged on for days, LVM decided at one point to double the auction step to 0.3 euros/m³, then a while later to 0.6 euros/m³, then later still to 1.5 euros/m³, finally reaching 3 euros/m³, and reduced the time allowed to consider a bid from 40 minutes to 25 minutes. In practice a single step cost around 0.5 million euros. The reason given – we want to finish the auction before Christmas. Legally, after several years of litigation such a change to the rules of the game would be found improper, but the timber processors had no reserves of such years to “sacrifice” to the courts.
At the same time, this cooperation model between LVM and roundwood buyers included a price indexation model that had never been tested anywhere. Indexation would begin from 114-115 euros/m³ (the highest price being around 134 euros/m³) rather than from the original 94-95 euros/m³, and consequently a reduction in the price of coniferous sawlogs was simply impossible under any conditions whatsoever. As head of the association I insisted that LVM should take the auction's starting price into account rather than its final price, because 114-115 euros/m³ had never been planned for, and the prices of sawn products continued to slide. If, in those circumstances, the sawlog price had been indexed downwards from the original auction starting price, the timber processors would have paid it.
The question is being asked: why were coniferous timber processors unable to pay the prices they themselves had bid, if they had previously been earning tens of millions of euros?
A private entrepreneur may see things however they wish, but the market is unrelenting and imposes significant corrections. There was a time when both LVM and coniferous timber processors were making money; then came 2021, in which both sides unexpectedly made large profits; after that LVM still makes large profits while coniferous timber processors operate at a loss, and operating at a loss means selling products on the market at a price lower than the cost of producing them. That means the companies have lost their competitiveness and must take measures to return to at least a modest profit zone. Production volumes were cut (from 4.25 million m³ to 3.54 million m³) and staff were laid off. Whereas coniferous timber processors employed 2,225 people in 2022, by the end of 2023 there were only 2,070, so the wage fund was also cut, from slightly more than 61.07 million euros in 2022 to 59.99 million euros in 2023, and the labour taxes paid by the companies (personal income tax plus mandatory state social insurance contributions) fell accordingly, from 26.965 million euros in 2022 to 25.62 million euros in 2023. The capitalisation value of the companies also fell – by 40% – which hit painfully those firms with debt obligations measured in millions of euros. The cause of all this was a single one: the very high prices of coniferous sawlogs in Latvia compared with those in competitor countries.
What was the difference in coniferous sawlog prices between the longer-term contracts and competitors in neighbouring countries?
Just a few figures. In the fourth quarter of 2022 the price of spruce sawlogs at the buyer in Latvia from LVM was 127 euros/m³, from the Lithuanian state forests 109 euros/m³, from the Estonian state forests 91 euros/m³, and in Sweden, which is essentially the maker of this market, 78 euros/m³. In the second quarter of 2023 the price of spruce sawlogs at the buyer in Latvia from LVM was 118 euros/m³, from the Lithuanian state forests 96 euros/m³, from the Estonian state forests 96 euros/m³, and in Sweden 72 euros/m³.
![]() |
![]() |
In the fourth quarter of 2022, meanwhile, the price of pine sawlogs at the buyer in Latvia from LVM was 126 euros/m³, from the Lithuanian state forests 112 euros/m³, from the Estonian state forests 132 euros/m³, and in Sweden 75 euros/m³; in the second quarter of 2023 in Latvia from LVM it was 119 euros/m³, from the Lithuanian state forests 95 euros/m³, from the Estonian state forests 103 euros/m³, and in Sweden 74 euros/m³.
In short, from the second quarter of 2022 the coniferous sawlog supply contracts under the longer-term cooperation programme lost their competitiveness, because they were 40% more expensive than in the main competitor country, Sweden. Coniferous timber processors in Latvia could not keep quiet and do nothing, so as early as October 2023 letters were written explaining the problem and calling for a solution to be sought.
What else did the coniferous timber processors do?
First of all, coniferous sawlogs were sought beyond Latvia's borders: coniferous sawlogs were brought in for processing in Latvia from Finland, southern Sweden and Norway, where they were 40-50% cheaper than in Latvia. We showed these figures to the LVM board and to the specialists responsible. Another proposal was to reduce the supply volume of the super-expensive local logs by 10%, which the contracts concluded allowed for. Since the LVM board replied that there was really nothing it could do, the timber processors turned to the LVM Council (at that moment the Council's members were being replaced), which in turn advised them to approach the owner – the Ministry of Agriculture (Minister of Agriculture Didzis Šmits and State Secretary Raivis Kronbergs). At the meeting, in the presence of the ministry's leadership and LVM's leadership, I set out all the arguments already mentioned regarding the price scissors, with sawlog prices very high while the prices of sawn products were falling. It must be stressed that at that moment Latvia had the highest coniferous sawlog prices in the world, as a result of which Swedish forest owners' cooperatives concluded long-term sawlog supply contracts with processors from Latvia – a situation that would previously have been unthinkable.
In the autumn of 2023 the government changed and Armands Krauze became Minister of Agriculture; he not only understood the situation but began to act as a careful manager should. As a result a report was prepared and considered by the Cabinet of Ministers. The Ministry of Agriculture, as the holder of LVM's shares, was instructed to require a/s “Latvijas valsts meži” to introduce, from 1 January 2024, adjustments to the longer-term cooperation agreements, changing the price indexation mechanism and applying weighted average prices calculated for the relevant period from LVM's short-term sales procedures.
As President of the Latvian Timber Producers and Traders Association, I express the highest appreciation to the Minister of Agriculture, Armands Krauze, for his ability to get to grips with the situation and assess its impact on the national economy, and still more for his courage in going to the Cabinet of Ministers, setting out the situation to the government and standing up for a concrete decision to reduce and remedy the negative consequences it had caused – as a result of which the state earned several tens of millions of euros more in LVM dividends than it had originally planned.
What were and are the benefits of Minister of Agriculture Armands Krauze's actions?
We can see the results in the figures. First, in 2024 it proved possible to halt the decline in the total volume of coniferous sawlogs processed, which reached 4.056 million m³; the number of people employed in 2024 at the largest coniferous sawlog processing companies reached 2,137, whereas in 2023 it was 2,070 (it should be recalled that in 2022 there were more still – 2,225). The amount of labour taxes paid by timber processors in this category also rose, to 28.26 million euros. The state budget accordingly gained 2.6 million euros. The investment climate in coniferous sawlog processing in particular recovered. I do not know Armands Krauze personally, but his ability and conviction in taking responsibility and acting as a careful manager have resulted in the restoration of jobs that had been eliminated and in millions of euros paid into the state budget in labour taxes, as well as in dividends from the state forest manager.
What were, or are, the conclusions?
First of all, it seems no one expected such an active stance and such action from the Minister of Agriculture. The LVM management of the time was not interested in the competitiveness of timber processors, and that in turn meant hampered opportunities for the companies to develop in future; yet this uninterested attitude on the part of LVM's management essentially stimulated the consolidation of coniferous sawlog processing companies. The first to understand this and react quickly were the owners of “Vika Wood”, who sold their shares to an Austrian company that made the owners an offer they could not refuse. It is bitter, but as recently as 2022 companies in the sector had prepared investment plans for large-scale projects, and by the end of 2023 it was clear that they would not be realised. In Germany and Austria, meanwhile, where there had been considerable damage from the eight-toothed spruce bark beetle, spruce sawlogs were selling at around 50 euros/m³, which meant producers there could earn well and either invest in development or acquire valuable assets, as can be seen today. Had LVM not changed its position at a time when timber product prices were falling while log prices remained at their previous level, there might have been just three coniferous sawlog buyers left on one bank of the Daugava and perhaps only two on the other. The question would then be: at what prices could those logs be sold, and how large would the dividends paid into the state budget be? The size of LVM's dividends in the state purse depends not only on roundwood selling prices but also on competition for the resources in question. At present there are already several European-scale players in the coniferous sawlog processing sector, and so the question is: what decisions will the owners of the few locally owned companies take? Beyond supporting competitiveness, the government's decision also made it possible to preserve jobs and the amount of tax paid into the state budget.
The government's understanding and the decisions that follow from it are the main factors on which locally owned companies can base their plans for growth and secure their competitiveness on international timber markets, thereby promoting the development of Latvia's economy.
Businesses in the sector are not of one mind about the fate of the long-term logging contracts once concluded for 50-100 years by the chief foresters of the State Forest Service. As is known, this happened before the founding of a/s “Latvijas valsts meži”, which was to take these contracts over. Some entrepreneurs support continuing these contracts, others support terminating them.
The story of these long-term logging contracts, concluded a good while ago now, has dragged on for many years. At one time LVM's management intended to transform these contracts. The members of the Latvian Timber Producers and Traders Association did not know what the mechanism would be, which is why in 2013, as president of the association, I wrote a letter to LVM in which, on the association's behalf, I urged that as a result of the intended transformation the holders of such contracts should receive timber resources – roundwood assortments – corresponding to what was available in the areas covered by the contracts concluded with them (rather than receiving all their timber in the form of coniferous sawlogs, for example).
The result was a situation in which the holders of such contracts could, “at the expense of the future”, discounting the last 10-20 years, buy sawlogs at today's prices from a forest that has not yet grown, even though no such sawlog assortment yet exists in the areas concerned. This can be seen as a peculiar way of picking the raisins out of the pie. In essence, in order for the holders of these contracts to receive the sawlogs in question, everyone else (those without such contracts) had to make do with a smaller volume of logs of that assortment. Many timber processors had no idea of the true situation; an idea began to form when, seemingly by accident, a Competition Council report addressed to LVM and to the holder of its shares, the Ministry of Agriculture, became public, indicating deliveries worth around 200 million euros over a period of 10 years. The largest recipient accounted for 14% of the timber deliveries made under these contracts, and moreover this company also took part in the roundwood procurement auctions organised by LVM. Unfortunately, in 2018 the LVM management of the day extended the term of these contracts to 2023, and in 2022 it contrived to extend them by a further three years – that is, to 31 December 2026. Industry associations urged both the Ministry of Agriculture and LVM not to extend the operation of such contracts. We have submitted a proposal to terminate these contracts as early as 2026, because they distort competition. There are companies that, in the fight for the immediate termination of such contracts, use methods that are not in the sector's interests, because in this fight mud is thrown over practically the whole industry, casting a shadow of suspicion over the sector as a whole rather than over individual players in it. That is precisely why I distance myself from activities of that kind, content and form, and cannot support them.
It should be mentioned that the situation would change radically if, for example, the volume of coniferous sawlogs channelled to the holders of long-term logging contracts in 2021 had gone into the roundwood assortment auction instead. Why? Timber processors would not have faced the pressure they faced then, and the level of prices bid would in all likelihood not have been what it was. Since there is a Competition Council opinion, the owner – the state – has the right, for example by an order of the Cabinet of Ministers, to terminate the further operation of these contracts. If, for whatever reason, these “historical” long-term logging contracts are still not terminated, they should be handed over to the respective contract holders in the historical scope of rights and obligations that they envisaged – forest tending, regeneration, logging and maintenance of forest infrastructure. It must be borne in mind that LVM at one point transformed these contracts into ones under which the company has the right to receive a certain quantity of timber, while at the same time releasing the company concerned from obligations such as tending the relevant forest areas, logging, forest regeneration, and maintaining and restoring forest infrastructure. It is understandable that any change will require holders of long-term logging contracts to change their existing business model.
There is a further question: do those who do not yet have the relevant capacity or production plant at all also have the right to receive roundwood resources of the relevant assortment from LVM?
One has to begin with whether the entrepreneurs genuinely had the intention and the desire to build the processing capacity in question. Of course, one can study the potential market for the products concerned, look for partners to develop the plan (a factory), identify suppliers of technological equipment and so on, followed by the commercial calculations, which, given very changeable and unstable economic and geopolitical conditions, may also change. At the same time, companies (entrepreneurs) that were still only exploring the creation of processing capacity for the relevant assortment could take part in LVM's roundwood supply programmes, and did so. It has already been said publicly that overall neither LVM nor the state lost anything, since the money was received, but… I cannot really agree with that, because the sector lost out; this was not fair competition in the struggle for access to the timber resources obtainable from state forests. One can calculate how much each company in the sector has lost from such a situation, and conclude that companies with a special status enjoyed advantages that others did not have.







