On 8 April, the Constitutional Court (ST) ruled that the provision by which the Cabinet of Ministers (MK) Regulation No. 935 of 18 December 2012, “Regulations on Tree Felling in Forests”, reduced the diameter threshold for final felling was incompatible with Article 115 of the Satversme. The Ministry of Agriculture (ZM) and the State Forest Service (VMD) are currently working actively on implementing the ST ruling. The number of felling sites to be reassessed as a result of the ST ruling has been established – 5874 forest stands.
Felling permits did not lose their validity when the ST ruling was handed down. This is set out in the ruling itself and also follows from the Administrative Procedure Law: annulling the Cabinet regulations does not annul the felling permits issued on their basis – those remain in force until they are used or until they expire. A felling permit will lose its validity only when the VMD, in accordance with the felling regulations, takes a decision to revoke it because the legal circumstances have changed during the permit's period of validity. If a forest owner holds a felling permit, it is to be regarded as a favourable administrative act on which the owner may rely in order to fell what was planned. Timber obtained from a felling site before the permit is revoked is therefore to be regarded as lawfully obtained timber. However, so that this does not carry on for another three years, the ST ordered the revocation of those permits where the tree diameter is smaller than the figure set previously, before the regulations that have now been annulled.
Now that, following the ST ruling, the legal circumstances have changed during the permits' period of validity, the VMD is entitled to take decisions on revoking permits. The ST has determined that the MK must take measures to ensure the revocation of those felling permits issued on the basis of the contested provision in cases where the tree diameter in the felling is smaller than was provided for in MK Regulation No. 935 up to 29 June 2022. Accordingly, in line with what the President of the Constitutional Court, A. Laviņš, has stated publicly, the VMD will assess each case carefully and individually. There is no plan to revoke the permits on one particular date. Each case will be examined separately, a decision will be taken on every felling permit to be revoked, and the forest owner will be notified of it. Information on revoked permits will also be available on the VMD website, in the public register of issued permits.



