On 21 May, Governor Jay Inslee signed a law that made Washington the first state to allow composting as an alternative to the burial and cremation of human remains. It allows licensed companies to offer clients “natural organic reduction”, which turns a body into about two wheelbarrows of soil within a few weeks.
Gene Johnson. “Washington becomes first state to allow human composting”. Associated Press, 22 May.
In my time teaching cultural history at the Faculty of Geography at the University of Latvia, we dedicated one session to a field trip to learn more about a religion. When we were discussing where to go, one student suggested they could arrange a visit to an Orthodox nunnery on Barona iela. We didn’t see anything particularly special at the nunnery, other than the realisation that you had entered a world of nuns. We also stopped at a display of relics. If my memory serves me correctly, it reminded me of a coin collection – many small indentations containing tiny pieces of an unidentifiable material. Our guide explained that the corpses of holy people do not decay, so they can be divided into small fragments and distributed among churches and monasteries.
Later, I read that in the Orthodox view, a holy person has not only an incorruptible soul but also an incorruptible body, and a pleasant scent often emanates from their remains. This, in turn, reminds me of my visit to the Temple Mount in Jerusalem. A few moments after entering the area, an Arab man approached me and offered his services as a guide. I declined, but when I tried to figure out where to buy tickets to enter the Dome of the Rock (in the centre of which lies the rock that God created first during the creation of the Earth and upon which Abraham prepared to sacrifice his son), another helpful local showed me the way; he also helped me buy a ticket, instructed me on mosque visiting etiquette, kindly walked me around the Dome of the Rock and the Al-Aqsa Mosque, and at the end, asked for money. Unlike the first guide, he unfortunately had a speech impediment, and I didn't understand half of what he said. But he, for instance, showed me a reliquary containing a hair from Muhammad’s beard and invited me to put my hand inside, which I certainly would not have done on my own without encouragement. He asked if I could smell the sweet scent coming from that hair, but my hand smelled only of perfumed soap. I felt like I was in an Arab version of the Brigadere fairy tale about Maija and Paija, where I was cast in the role of Paija, and somewhere out there, there surely lived a figurative Maija who was not stingy, heard a wonderful story from the guide, and smelled the captivating scent of Muhammad’s hair.
There is something challenging about the idea of composting corpses, although it is not at all easy to say exactly what. The bodies of saints do not decay, but there are relatively few saints, so most people must accept that their bodies will eventually decompose and turn to dust, grass will grow from them, a cow will eat the grass, the cow will leave it in a field in a processed form, the smell will no longer be pleasant, and others will be able to say: “Jānis, Jānis, how you have changed!” Even for believers, they must accept that their bodies will become earth. What is the difference if this process is delayed slightly by putting a body in a coffin or, as is quite common in the USA, in a concrete-lined pit pumped with embalming fluid?
Partly, of course, this is just a prejudice created by our culture, as Muslims, for example, traditionally bury people wrapped in a shroud, which generally corresponds to how Katrina Spade, an advocate for body composting and creator of the first human remains composting company Recompose, has envisioned the burial ritual. However, it is doubtful that all Muslims would easily agree with the idea that humans could be buried by composting. Does the backlash arise only because of what this process is called?
Partly that might be the case, although words only gain meaning within a network of other words, meanings, and beliefs. By calling something composting, we activate certain links and associations. Firstly, compost makes one think of rotting, and due to various circumstances, thoughts about the decomposition, putrefaction, and rotting of our bodies are not pleasant, even if they are not melancholic reflections on the shortness of life. This could be one of the reasons why cremation is becoming increasingly popular in Europe and North America. In 2015, for the first time in US history, the number of cremations exceeded the number of burials, and it is predicted that by 2035, almost 80% of the deceased will be cremated. Latvia is also following this global trend, as evidenced by the first columbarium opened a couple of years ago at Meža kapi.
However, attitudes might be influenced even more by the pragmatism of composting, as indicated by both the word itself and the associations with gardening. It is unlikely that composting is more theologically problematic than burial in a coffin or cremation, but by calling the process composting, we indirectly admit that we do not hope for the sanctity of the body or its resurrection.
The idea of recycling human remains into compost is not exactly new; it has been played with from time to time in science fiction. For example, in the young adult book “The Opal Deception” from the Artemis Fowl series, which has been translated into Latvian, there is a description of a “recycling ceremony” and a “compost pit” where the buried corpse decomposes in six months, and the humus is used for soil enrichment. The idea of Katrina Spade and her colleagues is quite similar. The service offered involves burying corpses in shafts built into towers, which are seven metres high and filled with woodchips. About six bodies one on top of the other. To speed up decomposition, air is specifically piped into the layer of woodchips, and according to the project's concept, in a couple of months, microbes have turned both soft tissues and bones into compost. Every so often, the resulting compost is removed from the bottom of the shaft, the column of earth shifts downward, and the shaft is ready to receive a new corpse. The confusing aspect is that no one can say how much of that human, whom they buried here, is in the two wheelbarrows of soil returned to the relatives. Spade claims that this is not important; returning the compost is a symbolic act, and in any case, the human body is being returned to nature.
Care for the environment is the main driving force behind the idea of composting corpses. Allocating land for cemeteries, concrete-lining, embalming corpses, making coffins – all of this has a significantly greater impact on the environment than composting. There are so many people that burying them in cities is becoming a problem. According to the creators of the project, cremation of people is not a solution, because its impact on the environment is also quite large: it generates about 270,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions annually. Composting, on the other hand, is not only more environmentally friendly, but it also clearly has a symbolic aspect: the deceased effectively returns to the cycle of nature, both during the decomposition process and also if the relatives decide to use the resulting compost in their garden, for example.
Although there is currently no indication that composting as a form of burial will immediately become very widespread, one can never predict whether an idea that currently seems exotic will not be mundane and self-evident in twenty or a couple of hundred years. And this should be thought of as part of an environmentally friendly lifestyle: we are increasingly noticing that seemingly innocent and customary actions have ecological consequences, so preserving the natural environment requires not one big push from people, a gigantic clean-up drive, but the systematic and meticulous replacement of harmful practices with something more meaningful.
However, one must not forget that humans have a tendency towards self-deception and it is easy for us to believe things that are evident from our direct experience, but difficult to grasp complex, broad processes that cannot be easily observed. Just as plastic drinking straws, which are planned to be banned in the European Union, are a tiny part of the overall plastic pollution, traditional human burial methods are far from the greatest harm that people do to the environment. Let's assume that cremation emits 270,000 tonnes of CO₂ into the atmosphere annually, but the European Union alone produces about 8 tonnes of CO₂ per capita, and there are about 512 million inhabitants in the EU… This, of course, does not mean that one should not give up plastic straws or corpse compost, but it is worth noting that these are quite trivial problems. There is no doubt that it is easier to ban straws than, for example, the chemicals we use to wash laundry or clean sinks. Likewise, enthusiasm for corpse composting and returning to the cycle of nature can act as an anaesthetic that helps one come to terms with much larger problems. One must think ecologically, but in my opinion, one should not ignore the question of why the era since the 1960s, when the modern ecological movement was formed and flourished, is also an era of unprecedentedly rapid depletion of natural resources. Why is the popularity of veganism growing simultaneously with the increase in meat consumption? And again: this does not mean that ecological ideas or veganism have no meaning and do not influence anything. One simply must remember that the question of lifestyle and aesthetics is only the beginning of ecological wisdom, not its culmination. For example, one can choose an environmentally friendly funeral, but an even more effective method of nature conservation would be to reduce the number of people on the planet. Who knows how to do that in a smart, rather than an idiotic, way?
Article first published in the July 2019 issue of Rīgas Laiks magazine.



