The climate crisis in our consciousness. “CO2 is plant food, therefore its increase is actually desirable, the authors of the letter state” - Zeme un valsts

The climate crisis in our consciousness. “CO2 is plant food, therefore its increase is actually desirable, the authors of the letter state”

Our advice to political leaders: science should strive to achieve a significantly better understanding of the climate system, while in politics, the main focus should be on minimising climate damage, prioritising adaptation (or adjustment to climate change) strategies based on proven and available technologies.

“There is no climate crisis”: a letter from 500 scientists and professionals

The “letter from 500 scientists and professionals”, addressed to the UN in the autumn of 2019, received wide coverage in right-wing portals, such as Breitbart. The goal of the letter, ahead of the climate conference scheduled for December in Madrid, was to create the impression that climate change is still a subject of uncertainty among scientists. Perhaps we should check how many of the letter’s signatories are scientists, how many are retired, and how many have published in peer-reviewed journals specifically in the field of climate. By searching for keywords, one can see online that such a verification has been carried out many times; one can also find critical popular-scientific commentary on the inaccuracy of these facts from scientists who do have relevant publications. Popular-scientific, because in the realm of science, the debate has long since ceased to exist, and there were no new scientific facts in the letter either.

It can also be pointed out that existing global climate models predicting temperature rises have been quite accurate. In fact, the very first quantitative analysis of the relationship between CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere and global temperature, published by the Swedish scientist Svante Arrhenius in 1896, does not differ all that much from modern calculations, if one ignores the fact that the researcher predicted a 50% increase in human-caused CO2 over 3,000 years, whereas we are already close to that level now.

If the reader has a desire to get acquainted with the facts about climate change at a popular-science level, I can recommend the climate website of the US National Aeronautics and Space Administration (National Aeronautics and Space Administration, NASA).

No, it will not reflect the opinion of US President Donald Trump. The portal provides a graphically clear description of climate issues that will be understandable even to a reader with no prior knowledge. However, the reader is unlikely to have any desire to look at it, because they likely already have a clear opinion on the climate issue, and one can always find a Nobel Prize winner who says the same thing. Which Nobel Prize winner? That can be selected depending on one’s views. Nowadays, there is an increasing number of studies showing that views on the climate are linked to other political, economic, and religious opinions, to the mechanisms of social media bubble formation and their influence on group views, and to the human desire to maintain the identity of one's chosen liberal or conservative group. This means that rational arguments and facts work poorly. The first level of the climate crisis resides in public consciousness.

But let us return to the quoted letter

Is it true that, because of climate change, extreme natural phenomena are not actually becoming more frequent, as the authors of the letter claim? It must be admitted that there are not many comprehensive studies, even though growth trends can be found; however, it is not correct to label any specific heatwave or hurricane as a direct consequence of climate change. Climate change increases the probability of such events, and there is a correlation with rising temperatures, but an individual event could have occurred even without climate change.
CO2 is plant food, therefore its increase is actually desirable, the authors of the letter state. True, but the plant kingdom can only partially absorb the increasing CO2 concentration. Yes, indeed, in some places one can find positive effects for agriculture and forestry, but in many places, the increase in CO2 is already having a negative impact. As its concentration rises even further, there is a risk that tropical forests will transform into savannahs, releasing even more CO2 into the atmosphere. This is one of several climate change-reinforcing feedback loops studied by scientists that could further accelerate temperature rise.
One could highlight and refute several more claims in the justification section, but the overall conclusion of the letter is not entirely wrong. The climate problem will be the greatest problem for civilisation over the next decades or even centuries. Over such a long period, it cannot be solved with crisis or emergency management methods: it must become a permanent, long-term policy balanced with other national priorities, yet it will change many areas of societal life. At the European Union level, this transition is, in principle, already prepared, which is most vividly marked by the recently published “European Green Deal”. China, many US states, and global companies are also working in this direction, albeit using slightly different approaches than in Europe. Countries and companies that are quicker to embrace innovation and economic change will be the winners in the global competitive struggle.
Unfortunately, due to political and social realities, this transition will be slower than the objective of the Paris Agreement, which is to limit global temperature rise to well below 2 °C. Therefore, greater importance will be placed on adaptation measures – how to mitigate the consequences of more frequent floods and heatwaves, how to respond to changes in the habitats of animal and plant species, etc. – as pointed out by the authors of the letter. It can also be agreed that both in terms of emission reduction and adaptation, one must rely on proven and cost-effective technologies. Although science, contrary to the view of the letter's authors, is already able to predict many climate impacts quite well, research must, of course, continue, not only in the field of climatology, including research into feedback loops, but also in the fields of economics, technology, and the aforementioned social sciences. However, just like the climate problem as a whole, differing perceptions of the climate issue will persist. Therefore, it would be more appropriate to focus less on general ideological discussions and more on solutions to concrete problems. Buildings will need to be renovated regardless of climate targets; renewable energy technologies have already become cost-effective and allow for a reduction in dependence on fossil fuel imports. More cycle paths in cities will be needed from the perspective of transport planning, as well as to reduce air pollution, improve public health, and achieve other goals. Thus, the discussion must be about the best solutions, the availability of investment, and more effective market mechanisms for implementing these technologies. Specifically, past experience shows that by using the climate crisis as an argument, over-subsidised and even fraudulent support schemes are created in many places in the interests of individual political businessmen, as happened in Latvia with the mandatory procurement component of electricity, or OIK. For that not to happen, a sceptical approach can be useful.

Finally: why should Latvia be among the leaders in changing attitudes towards the climate crisis? We have a green country, our total global impact is negligible, and besides, climate models show that as temperatures rise, we will not be among the most threatened territories. In addition to the already mentioned arguments about global competitiveness and the fact that the European Union has already set such a policy, it is significant that geopolitically we already live in a rather threatened place, and in a world that does not limit global climate change, geopolitical risks will only grow. However, the main question is what goods and services – preferably innovative and with high added value – Latvian entrepreneurs will be able to sell in a changing world. If you wish, you can disbelieve in climate change, but your customers will most likely believe in it. That is regarding entrepreneurs, but we can all do something – insulate the house, ride a bicycle more, plant several trees: all of this will be useful even if you do not believe in global climate change.
Article first published in the February 2020 issue of Rīgas Laiks magazine

Add a comment