No solution to a problem that works elsewhere in Europe is right for Latvia - Zeme un valsts

No solution to a problem that works elsewhere in Europe is right for Latvia

“European requirements based on the problems of the relevant (other) European regions are neither applicable nor workable in Latvia, particularly if their implementation substantially increases the cost of production, in some places making it almost impossible,” Rolands Feldmanis, chairman of the board of the Latvian Agricultural Cooperatives Association, says in an interview with “Dienas Bizness”. In his view, the Latvian government must be able to show courage and clearly reject a great many of the solutions proposed by the European Union that run counter to the interests of domestic growers and processors of agricultural produce, and to their competitiveness.

Which requirements should Latvia reject?

In recent years many rules relating to food production have changed substantially – lower use of plant protection products and mineral fertilisers, greater emphasis on organic farming, and also less pollution, a cleaner environment and cleaner air. All these rules are understandable and logical, yet complying with them may become a peculiar obstacle to the development not only of agriculture and food processing, but of other industries too, such as forestry, woodworking and other manufacturing sectors, especially if the production facilities are located in or near a populated area. Specifically, the Nature Restoration Regulation entered into force in 2024, the draft Air Protection Law is being prepared, and the European Union has literally just published a new water resilience strategy. These significant documents will affect not only a few residents or land managers, but the whole of Latvian society, especially farmers and, even more so, manufacturing industry.

Unfortunately, no one has guaranteed that further rules or requirements affecting business in Latvia will not appear – all the more so if the Latvian government does not defend the industries that operate successfully in Latvia. There is no need to reinvent the wheel – the Latvian government must state a position appropriate to the country: if the conditions or their consequences harm the interests of those working in Latvia (demanding disproportionate capital investment, or creating a risk that a company or companies will close), then documents containing such requirements or conditions must be vetoed, or an exemption from applying the requirement in question must be secured. The state can develop such a position for all areas, basing it on the opinions of scientists (bringing in the industries the specific requirements affect) grounded in research carried out in Latvia, rather than on assumptions built on assumptions, or on generalisations created in a completely different setting.

How should that be understood?

Quite simply – measure seven times and cut once, rather than immediately implementing requirements that, even if only at the level of an initiative, come out of Brussels, while ignoring the negative side effects they will cause. Just one example that creates a sufficiently large risk for Latvian land managers, and for farmers in particular. Specifically, the Nature Restoration Regulation provides for restoring at least 20% of the EU's land and sea areas by 2030 (irrespective of the area of protected nature territories), promoting sustainable farming practices that will help conserve and restore natural resources, and increasing green zones in cities in order to reduce the effect of heat and frost (sharp temperature fluctuations) and to encourage recreational opportunities. All lovely and agreeable to everyone, only Latvia itself has to draw up a National Restoration Plan setting out how the objectives laid down in the regulation will be met, including which nature restoration measures will be carried out, to what extent and where. All industries and sectoral ministries must certainly be involved in drawing up the National Nature Restoration Plan. The plans must be drafted within two years of the regulation entering into force, that is, by mid-2026, setting specific goals and tasks. Less than a year remains. What is a land manager to do, and how? Is there a risk that some portion of the land currently in use, especially land where drainage was carried out at one time (in the Soviet era), will have to be left under water? If such a risk exists, there is a question for those who prepare and take the decisions – how large an area will be “let go” under water because of the Nature Restoration Regulation by, say, the Netherlands, which has reclaimed very significant areas from the sea, and where the price of a hectare of agricultural land is tens of times higher than in Latvia? If such restoration of natural water levels also takes place in Latvia, over how large an area, in which places, and how will it affect the population of the areas concerned, economic activity (the volume of harvests obtained), jobs, the taxes paid, and the timely servicing of debt (most farmers have borrowed money for development and to make work more efficient, buying machinery)? These are extremely important questions for many – not just for a handful of land managers who might be affected by such a risk. Perhaps, for instance, some flood-protection dyke could be left unreconstructed, or demolished? Would that really be a solution befitting the 21st century, and is that exactly what the European Union wants? I doubt it! That is just one example of how Latvia can lose yet more land usable for economic activity, even though in Latvia's climatic conditions there are quite enough uncultivable bogs and low-fertility land unusable for agriculture. Yes, Latvia has neither the magical Alps, nor the Andes, nor the Scandinavian fjords, where there is almost no vegetation and these areas are hard to use for any economic activity, which is precisely why they are easy to include in reports on meeting nature restoration requirements.

The Nature Restoration Regulation is by no means the only document loaded with uncertainties and risks. Latvia already has a target to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 17% by 2030 (and also to ensure the sequestration of 364,000 t of CO₂), yet there has not even been any discussion of the instruments with which to deliver on such a commitment, and of which industries (and why precisely those) should increase greenhouse gas sequestration or, on the contrary, substantially reduce their volume of CO₂ emissions.

Since Latvia essentially has had no large production complexes for a long time in which some measure could deliver substantial savings in CO₂ emissions, what remains are areas such as transport, private cars in particular, agriculture, and peat extraction, which is closely tied to the production of the substrate needed in agriculture and plant growing. Latvia has essentially shut down its industry over the years since the collapse of the USSR, and consequently the baseline reference point is very low. That is precisely why agriculture and transport are named as the biggest CO₂ emitters, or culprits. If we set about reducing CO₂ emissions in agriculture, then we have to consider whether we will even be able to supply ourselves with food produced in Latvia. Will food produced in Latvia be competitive? Latvia's food exports may shrink while food imports grow. What might food prices be, when there is already such a commotion about them?

So what else creates risks?

Quite recently the draft Air Protection Law came to public light; it has supposedly already been written, but has not really yet been through scrutiny by decision-makers. Although part of the public may not even have heard of it, let alone read it and understood the risks it creates, among food processors it is causing concern and yet more risks to sustainable development. Why? Very simply – in many places in Latvia, including in Riga's residential districts, for example Sarkandaugava, Purvciems and Pļavnieki, prosperity was historically based on factories which, as the built-up areas grew, suddenly found themselves moved from the outskirts to almost the centre of a populated area, or very close to it. Of course, nobody says out loud that in many places, as a result of such requirements, the production facility in question will have to be relocated, which will cost millions and even tens of millions. Is that really in Latvia's interests? Has the preparation of such a draft regulatory act been thought through sufficiently so as not to create obstacles and risks to the development of the national economy in Latvia?

Why would a factory have to be moved out of the city if the law does not require it?

It does not require it directly, and it is not a matter of relocating some production facility out of the city and having to build new infrastructure for that purpose – for electricity, water and sewerage – which demands enormous additional investment.

Any food and, to some extent, woodworking production facility, even one equipped with the best available technology and various filters, nevertheless creates air pollution – in other words, there is an odour, and in the case of certain factories, condensate as well. We can see such a picture even in Riga. So what? Well, people living in the neighbourhood who do not themselves work at the company in question, and whose relatives and friends do not either, can write a complaint and ask the local authority to adopt appropriate measures. Of course, the councillors elected to the local authority can find a way to do nothing and adopt no measures, but then they are gambling with their political careers. Will elected councillors want to hand their seats to others who will have promised to listen to residents calling for measures against the production facility in question? That possibility exists; there are no guarantees and no insurance against such a situation. Do such risks allow sustainable business to be carried on? Not at all! They create nothing but threats and risks; the owners of the production facility concerned may develop an appetite for making no investment at all and running the factory for as long as they are allowed to – in effect maximising profit and, after a while, deciding to close the plant. That means both a loss of jobs and a shortfall of tax revenue in the state budget, both from the specific facility and from the raw material suppliers and service providers connected with it. Is that in the interests of Latvian society? I doubt it! It might be in the interests of competitors, of foreign business – helping to close things down and gaining additional opportunities to expand markets at the expense of the closed facilities. A draft regulatory act created with good intentions can in essence make society much poorer, and if state budget spending already has to be cut, tax reliefs reduced, existing tax rates raised or new taxes introduced, what will we do when very large and labour-intensive producers have to solve the puzzle of the draft air protection law? Oh yes, and of course there are also people who, in cities, use not the centralised heating system but fire their own stoves, using wood pellets, briquettes or, still more, firewood as their fuel, and who have not stopped to think that this draft may prohibit them from doing so. In effect that would mean a chimney tax, all the more so when we are constantly reminded from various quarters, even in a manner friendly to Latvia, that CO₂ emissions must be reduced. At the recent local elections, in one city a political force promised to implement measures so that by 2030 that city would be free of CO₂ emissions – meaning without industry, with a chimney tax and without people, since people do breathe and therefore produce CO₂. One can be ironic and say that anything at all can be written in pre-election programmes, but it creates uncertainty about the future, which does nothing to encourage predictability and, still more, does not create any desire to make additional investments in order to expand, to produce higher value-added goods and to pay more taxes into the state budget. Latvia is already not the most attractive place for industrial production, starting with bureaucracy in construction and ending with the low purchasing power of the population compared with even our neighbouring countries.

Which food processors might these risks “hit”?

I will not name anyone; those who wish to can look into it and find where each producer is located and what is currently around it – an empty field, forests or residential districts. I can point out that Latvia has factories whose origins date back to before the Second and even the First World War, which have been modernised and operate successfully, providing jobs, maintaining infrastructure and creating added value. It is precisely these factories or processing companies that come under attack – everyone plans to live in a place with developed infrastructure, and wants peace and quiet and clean air all around. And so we arrive at a contradiction – cities as centres of urbanisation, the millions that, thanks to production, were invested over decades in developing infrastructure, a town or village that concentrates the workforce needed for production, can be closed to industry for the benefit of some well-off resident who does not work at the factory and does not earn from it. Will a city be attractive if it has no industry? Do we think we will earn a living from consultancy and entertainment alone? Have we imagined that this is the navel of the world in terms of resorts, architecture and culture, and that we have no competitors? Do the statistics not warn us that Latvia lacks industrial capacity, lacks companies that create added value? How is it possible to talk of developing production and giving the green light to investors who want to produce in Latvia while at the same time preparing regulatory acts to punish those investors? It is nonsense, all the more so when there is nothing else on which to base the Latvian state; the transit dream has been dreamt to the end, and we effectively no longer have such a service. Will the air protection regulatory act be the one to “knock off its feet” some dairy processing cooperative, or perhaps a meat processor, because well-off people can buy properties nearby and lawfully demand that their right to clean air be respected! And that is to say nothing, to put it mildly, of the strange and utterly unready ideas about creating a zero-emission or low-emission zone in the centre of the capital, Riga, where the major cultural venues are concentrated – theatres, hotels and, ultimately, state administrative institutions too!

Less motor traffic in the centre of Riga – cleaner air and more room for people!

That is one facet of this issue, and it rests on an assumption – less traffic, more people – but in the Latvian context this axiom will not really work. Why? Are we going to turn the centre of Riga into a peculiar paradise for millionaires, or better still billionaires, where, apart from emergency and rescue vehicles and public transport, everyone will drive only electric cars? I doubt it! Perhaps tourists will change the sad picture in the centre of Riga, with its “to let” and “for sale” signs? It is not impossible, but Riga has neither Paris's nor London's nor even Tallinn's magnetic pull for foreign tourists.

What attracts tourists? International events and competitions, such as the world ice hockey championship and the like.

Given that ideas were initially voiced quietly and reluctantly to the effect that from 2028 at the latest a zero-emission or low-emission zone could be on such a scale that the only bridge connecting the two banks of the Daugava that cars with internal combustion engines could cross would be the Southern Bridge, it seems that traffic jams on it (with all the consequences that follow – exhaust fumes, noise and also road accidents) would become an everyday occurrence. Are those preparing and taking the decisions thinking about such a risk? What will we do about the vehicles of ministries and state institutions? Will the staff themselves buy the relevant entry ticket, or will it once again be put on the taxpayer to pay? Will Riga City Council deputies get yet another discount, or will they pay for their decisions out of their own pockets? That is only part of the questions, but people in the countryside may have quite a different kind of question – if they travel by coach to the theatre, will the coach be fined if it is not a zero-emission vehicle? All the more so given that the Puppet Theatre is also in the centre of Riga. What about children and school buses? Perhaps everyone travelling to the theatre will have to stop 5 or 10 kilometres from the centre, park the coach in a paid car park and work out which Riga public transport to take to reach the chosen theatre and then get back to the same place? How will such a solution affect Riga's public transport? Perhaps such solutions will attract people from Latvia's regions to take a trip to the centre of Riga? These questions must be answerable before decisions are taken, rather than – first decide, implement, and then clutch our heads at the result and look for ways to fix everything. That is nothing new or unique; Latvia has seen no end of such scenes over the past 25 years.

You mentioned the European water strategy...

Fresh water was, is and will remain a significant resource, without which human life, and food production and processing too, are impossible. The European Union is vast; in some regions fresh water resources are very limited and under threat, while at the same time in Latvia this year it rains for a month or two on end and there is water in abundance.

What does that mean? It means that it is impossible to measure southern countries and the Baltics by the same yardstick, because the situation here is entirely different. There is no need for it in Latvia, and we must not be subjected to the same requirements as would objectively have to be set in southern countries.

Understandably, that does not mean polluting the waters. Farmers have something to worry about, because there are institutions that regard agriculture as the main culprit in the water crisis, holding it responsible for 60% of Europe's water consumption. Such news does nothing but create yet more anxiety and risks for farmers in Latvia; they may have to reckon with some additional report at best, and at worst with some maximum volume (quota) of water consumption, or indeed a tax (a higher charge) for water, even though our country has no water crisis situation of the kind seen, for example, elsewhere in the world, where you can receive an impressive fine for watering your lawn.

Do Latvia's decision-makers explain what Latvia's situation is, and are they heard in the offices of the European Union?

Good question! It would be interesting to know whether the impact of the European water strategy on agriculture (its total output), on food processing, and on human hygiene and health has been assessed in Latvia. If it has, it would be good for everyone to see it, including farmers and the food industry, who provide people's sustenance yet are declared to be the culprits of the water crisis in southern countries. There are also risks of famine if farmers have to reduce water consumption, which leads to smaller harvests and higher food prices. There are many different facets whose assessment is either not known or does not exist at all, because there is a group of people who, with good and noble intentions, saving the world, want to overturn everything else.

In my view, introducing in Latvia conditions that would be appropriate for, say, southern Italy is madness. We could export water by ship, but it would be far more sensible and economically advantageous to bottle drinking water and export it – at least some higher added value and at least a few jobs. A reasonable, considered approach that understands the specific local situation, rather than blind submission and the unconditional fulfilment of every whim from Brussels – that is what Latvian state policy ought to be. No one will come and do anything in our place; we have to make the effort ourselves to obtain a sensible, good result, because the position of “those are the requirements, we cannot do otherwise” is the road to ruin, as was starkly demonstrated by decisions taken earlier, as a result of which Latvia lost significant production and service assets and with them jobs, which in turn triggered the emigration of working-age people, taking their children with them; in time such a situation will raise existential questions about the Latvian state. It is harsh, but unfortunately it is inevitable, all the more so when, as experience shows, other EU member states manage to do what in Latvia is not even contemplated.

Add a comment