No, carbon markets are not a moral failure! Abolishing them would be - Zeme un valsts

No, carbon markets are not a moral failure! Abolishing them would be

The executive director of the international charity ActionAid Ireland claims in her article that carbon markets "almost always fail". The facts, and the communities that receive support from funds raised on carbon markets, tell quite a different story.

If you believe a recently published opinion piece in The Irish Times, carbon markets have "almost always failed" and offer nothing but false promises. It is a powerful headline, but an untrue one. The author of the piece, Karol Balfe, executive director of ActionAid Ireland, calls carbon markets a "moral failure". I, on the other hand, have seen them preserve forests, fund schools and provide food, particularly for local communities in the global south.

Both views may be true, so let us look at the evidence.

Karol Balfe claims that carbon markets "almost always fail to deliver real benefits for the climate", citing the well-known Guardian article which highlighted that 90% of Verra-certified tropical forest offset credits are "phantom credits".

What K. Balfe does not mention is that this article has already been largely refuted with the help of independent analysts. For example, one of the world's most influential scientific journals, Nature Climate Change, concluded that such projects rest on a solid scientific foundation for delivering high-integrity carbon emission reductions. Researchers at the University of Cambridge, meanwhile, state that REDD+ projects significantly slow deforestation and degradation, particularly in regions facing the greatest threats. Independent ratings agencies say the figures cited by the Guardian are "considerably exaggerated". The list could go on...

K. Balfe's most troubling claim, however, is that these projects "have failed, missing their targets" for communities in the global south, particularly in Africa. As an African myself and executive director of the world's leading carbon standards organisation, I can say that this is simply not true!

Yes, as in any market, mistakes have been made in some carbon projects! Yes, as in any market, there have been unscrupulous participants and even outright lawbreakers! That is the case in every industry in the world. To dismiss the entire mechanism as something that "simply does not work" is far too crude a conclusion, and it does more harm than good. One has to ask: have the critics of this "failed" system ever visited the places where carbon projects are being carried out?

Take the TIST programme in Kenya, where more than 230,000 smallholder farmers have planted 26 million trees, sequestered more than 6 million tonnes of CO₂ and used carbon revenues to fund food, education and resilience. Or the Delta Blue Carbon project in Pakistan, which has restored 600,000 hectares of mangroves, protected 11 endangered species, created 15,000 jobs and is expected to sequester 142 million tonnes of CO₂. The Mahogany project in India, where more than 4,000 farmers have planted 3.1 million mahogany trees, raising crop yields, creating new income streams and sequestering 1 million tonnes of CO₂. And the Corazón Verde del Chaco project in Paraguay, which has protected 32,000 hectares of forest while safeguarding jaguars and other endangered species, preventing 5.6 million tonnes of CO₂ emissions and offering a viable, community-led alternative to deforestation.

These are not failures. They are real projects delivering measurable climate benefits and life-changing impacts for communities every single day. And it is not only project developers who say so. Last year ten West African countries (nine of which are among the world's least developed countries) signed a letter backing carbon credits as a tool for tackling the climate crisis.

The message from the front line of climate change is clear: carbon markets are not a moral failure, but abolishing them would be.

We can agree with Karol Balfe that carbon markets must keep improving, that they must be transparent, that they must deliver tangible benefits and that there must be mechanisms to shut malicious participants out of the market. On that there is no disagreement.

But the "alternatives" Karol Balfe proposes (rapid decarbonisation, a progressive tax system, a substantial increase in public climate finance and a fully funded just transition) look more like a wish list than a workable plan. Of course we need all of these things. The question is when and how. These measures are politically stuck, chronically underfunded and often decades away from their targets... if they are ever delivered at all.

In the meantime, the communities facing the impacts of climate change today cannot live on promises of future tax reform. They cannot replace lost livelihoods with unfulfilled financial pledges. And they cannot wait for a "perfect" system while their forests are already being felled. The hard truth is that we do not have the luxury of choosing one solution and rejecting the other. We need rapid decarbonisation and high-integrity carbon markets. We need public funding and private capital flowing through proven mechanisms that are already delivering results on the ground.

Karol Balfe wants to discard one of the few working instruments we have, without a thought for the consequences for the climate or for the communities that depend on it. And that is what well-run carbon projects deliver every single day.

The alternative is not merely worse, it is unacceptable.

Add a comment