“I wish for all residents of Latvia to realise their value as people and as Latvians,” former President Vaira Vīķe-Freiberga says to the readers of the portal Delfi.
Delfi, 1 January
Every genre has its own rules. For example, it is often said that one should not say anything bad about the deceased in funeral speeches. A birthday greeting usually cannot do without a sentimental four-line verse by Ārija Elksne or Kornēlija Apškrūma about the passing years. But in New Year's wishes, of course, one must wish for something good. In this regard, New Year's wishes are not much different from birthday greetings. Moreover, either because birthdays and the New Year tend to repeat with the same frequency, or for some other reason, they both share a flaw: in both cases, their only content is often form, or, more precisely, they have no content at all. In the case of some speech acts, this satisfies us completely. When, for example, an American meets you and says, “How do you do?”, it would be entirely out of place to start detailing your difficult life story. Conversely, with regard to New Year's wishes and greetings, one might desire for good intentions to be accompanied by some meaningful content, as one wants to understand exactly what is being wished for us. Except, of course, for cases when someone wishes us “all the best,” which, no doubt, is pleasant, yet, you must agree, quite non-specific. Admittedly, one cannot even say that much about the “May you have a red one!” exclaimed by participants of the popular radio show Zvaigznīšu brīdis in the distant nineties. In contrast, the greeting “May you live on your salary alone!” which characterised the Soviet economic reality, is very precise in its message, although, perhaps, not particularly benevolent.
Where in this catalogue of various wishes should we place the former president’s call for all residents of Latvia to “realise their value as people and as Latvians”? It is clear that we are being invited to perform some cognitive act (i.e., to realise) that could be to our benefit. True, it seems that is where the clarity ends, for all residents of Latvia could validly ask – what does it actually mean to realise one’s value as a person and as a Latvian? And how can such a realisation be of benefit? One must assume that the call is based on the premise that being a person is, in some sense, good. Perhaps that is so, but in order to understand it, one must first come to terms with what is meant by it. Asserting that being a person is good can mean at least two different things. Firstly, it can mean that it is good to be a living being belonging to the Homo sapiens species. If the word “person” is understood in this sense, then the statement becomes either questionable or meaningless. Questionable because it would not be at all difficult to point out the harm this being has caused to its own kin and other living beings. The list of species that have become extinct as a result of human activity is quite long and can hardly be a source of pride. Meaningless because those beings that are already people have no way of being anything else (e.g., platypuses). On the other hand, the word “person” is also used in another sense, where being a person means being endowed with certain qualities that ancient thinkers called virtues – courage, wisdom, justice. It is precisely in this sense that we speak of humane treatment, humane action, and humane behaviour. In other words – to be a person in this sense is the same as to be a good person. But in that case, the assumption that being a person is good is trivially true, which, on one hand, is good, but on the other – one must doubt whether all residents of Latvia are such people. But that, in turn, means that the former president’s wish, although ostensibly dedicated to all residents of Latvia, actually only applies to a certain portion of the population.
It is even harder to come to terms with the call to realise one’s value as a Latvian. I assume the former president did not mean those described by Garlieb Merkel: “Undeveloped, dulled, the vast majority of them wander through life and know no higher happiness than to eat chaff bread with a whole back, knowing no other wisdom than not to let oneself get caught stealing.” But if not these, then whom? I confess, I have no idea, which, of course, does not mean that it is the former president’s fault. Membership in a nation is, in itself, a value roughly as great as living in Straupe or London. That, as people say now, is clear even to a rabbit.
Perhaps thinking about greetings in this way is the same as trying to write a review of a children’s New Year’s play. Therefore, I will rest my case. May you have a red one!
The article was first published in the February 2016 issue of Rīgas Laiks magazine



