Latvia's opportunity – strengthening carbon management - Zeme un valsts

Latvia's opportunity – strengthening carbon management

Reinholds Šneiders, chairman of the board of SIA Schwenk Latvija and managing director of Schwenk Northern Europe, stressed that the company is the first industrial manufacturer in Latvia to begin testing carbon capture technologies and equipment. Although decarbonisation efforts at the Broceni cement plant have been under way for several years, it is only in 2025 that the first CO₂ capture is being opened.

A carbon capture test facility has been opened at the Broceni cement plant, which will capture around 2 t of CO₂ a day, while in the longer term the aim is to capture 800,000 t of CO₂ a year; achieving that will require investment of roughly 500 million euros, as well as answers to questions about transporting and storing it

This is happening at the Broceni cement plant after several years of research, during which various technologies and their suitability for cement production were studied. The company's head pointed out that CO₂ capture is a crucial issue, because cement is the foundation of the entire construction and building materials value chain and at the same time accounts for around 8% of Latvia's CO₂ emissions. That is precisely why Schwenk Latvija intends to build a carbon capture plant at production scale in Broceni by 2030 and to capture around 800,000 tonnes of CO₂ a year. That is a large volume, and uses will have to be found for it. The production of modern fuels was mentioned as one solution, though there will also be the question of transporting the captured CO₂ (what form the transport might take – road tankers, rail or pipelines) and storing it (where the storage site will be – in Latvia or abroad). In any case, these are costs that someone will have to bear.

The specifics of storage and the purpose of the test equipment

“Current legislation provides that the company is also entitled to free CO₂ emission allowances, but from 2034 all CO₂ emission allowances will have to be bought at the market price prevailing at the time, and from 2040 an instrument such as allowances will no longer exist at all,” says Krists Mertens, director of decarbonisation and energy projects at SIA Schwenk Latvija, in answer to a question about purchasing emission allowances. He points out that the current installation should be seen more as a test, since it can capture only one to two tonnes of CO₂ a day, whereas the plant emits an average of around 2,500 t of CO₂ daily. “Even though several million euros have been invested in carrying out the test project, its capacity – the scale relative to production and the volumes of CO₂ it generates – is not yet comparable,” K. Mertens acknowledges. He notes that it is precisely for this reason that investment is needed in order to capture almost all the emissions arising in the production process. “The purpose of the test equipment is not to assess and calculate what CO₂ capture costs, but we do follow the market price of CO₂ emission allowances, because it is significant in the context of building an industrial CO₂ capture system,” says K. Mertens. He adds that the cost of capturing one tonne of CO₂ is very similar to the current market price of CO₂ emission allowances – around 70 euros/t. “CO₂ is a potential raw material, and there are already potential consumers who want to use it in making their products,” K. Mertens notes. At the same time, there are currently no consumers for the entire volume of CO₂ captured.

“The pressing question is the fate of the captured CO₂, and at present that means transporting it via some Latvian or Lithuanian port to Norway's offshore storage site in the North Sea,” K. Mertens notes. He acknowledges that transport and storage cost money. “The question is what scope there is to optimise the value chain, because we see alternative solutions closer to home, including here in Latvia, which could cut costs by as much as three to five times; that is precisely why the company has an interest in fostering dialogue with the public sector about developing the regulatory environment, so that it becomes possible, even if only at research level, to start assessing the suitability of Latvia's geological structures for storing CO₂, much as for natural gas,” says K. Mertens. He admits that data from studies carried out in the Soviet era on the structure of the potential Dobele underground storage facility is missing. “Either the information in question has been destroyed or it has been taken out of Latvia, and on top of that not all the boreholes drilled back in the Soviet era can now be identified, so the research essentially has to start from scratch,” K. Mertens acknowledges. He stresses that Schwenk Latvija has an interest in working with universities and is also prepared to support research financially.

The longer the transport route, the higher the costs

“CO₂ is a different gas from natural gas, so the storage solutions differ, but if there is the political will to create added value in Latvia, then it can be done – though that will require appropriate regulation and investment,” explained Uldis Bariss, chairman of the board of AS Conexus Baltic Grid, discussing possible CO₂ storage in an underground facility during the panel discussion Strengthening carbon management in the Baltics – future opportunities and action today. He pointed out that the longer the transport route, the higher the costs.

“Either Latvian consumers will pay more, or the company will find it harder to compete, because a large share of its output is sold on international markets,” U. Bariss remarked. He noted that the company is engaged in storing and transporting natural gas, and now biomethane as well, while the possibilities for transporting hydrogen are being studied. U. Bariss also expressed his pleasure at the chance to take part in choosing the route for locally captured CO₂.

Contradictions in the legislation

“Storing CO₂ on Latvian territory is possible, because the Saeima amended the law during the spring session,” explained Jānis Irbe, parliamentary secretary of the Ministry of Climate and Energy. That said, one of those present drew attention to the fact that the Saeima has amended the law on subterranean depths, which sets out how CO₂ storage would work, how an operator would be selected and so on, yet the law On Pollution still states: “The storage of carbon dioxide in geological structures, as well as in the water column, is prohibited in the territory of Latvia, its exclusive economic zone and on the continental shelf.” That essentially rules out the possibility of storing CO₂ in Latvia. J. Irbe acknowledged that this provision has not been forgotten and expressed the hope that it will be changed in the near future.

Electricity consumption is rising…

“Time is passing, and the moment when everyone will have to do this is approaching, but as long as it can still be put off, many companies are also putting off the relevant decisions,” J. Irbe replies when asked when other companies in Latvia will follow Schwenk's example. He stressed that capturing CO₂ is a highly significant but also fiscally demanding project. “The cement producer has no scope to wait any longer and must take the relevant steps today in order to meet the targets in 2030,” said J. Irbe. He points out that Schwenk Latvija is already energy-intensive, and CO₂ capture technology will make it an even bigger consumer of electricity, which in itself raises questions about electricity generation and transmission. “That makes it a project of national rather than regional importance,” said J. Irbe. K. Mertens is quick to add that the plant consumes around 140 GWh of electricity a year, but with the introduction of CO₂ capture a further 300 GWh or so of electricity will be needed.

“If the country's total electricity consumption is a little under 7 TWh, then the company's consumption is 5 to 6%, not to mention the possible further use of the CO₂, where electricity consumption is higher still,” K. Mertens explained. He mentioned that the increase in electricity consumption could therefore be around one TWh. Among those listening to the discussion there was a rhetorical question as to whether, with electricity prices high, this CO₂ capture can be carried out at an economic gain, since it will automatically make the core product more expensive.

The Nordic countries – our competitors

“Competitors in Sweden and Norway are working on similar development projects too, and what is more, they receive many millions in state funding for feasibility work and project development; on top of that, the CO₂ captured under one project has already been stored in the North Sea,” K. Mertens replies to a question about competitors' activities. Since CO₂ capture is not a free undertaking, it will affect the cost of producing goods and hence the level of sale prices too. “In future we don't want to depend on market fluctuations; we want to keep this risk under our own control with the help of technology,” said K. Mertens. He points out that around 67% of the cement produced in Broceni is sold on foreign markets – Sweden and Finland – where demand for decarbonised, sustainable cement is already high enough and buyers are prepared to pay a premium for a sustainable building materials product.

“Through the industry association, we are working intensively in Brussels to ensure that cement, like electricity, has a guarantee of origin,” K. Mertens notes. He acknowledges that at present the company is in some ways limited in its ability to sell higher-value cement, but if there were a corresponding certification system it could attract those buyers (consumers) who want greener cement. “Existing production capacity has not been exhausted and the plant can produce more, but that has to come as market demand,” K. Mertens replies when asked about the scope for increasing production capacity. He stresses that Schwenk Latvija is a vertically integrated company with reserves of the raw materials needed for cement production to last many more years. So Latvia does have growth opportunities in this field, and they must be seized.

Add a comment