Hybrid hope. “Eurobarometer survey shows the highest support for the EU in the last 35 years.” - Zeme un valsts

Hybrid hope. “Eurobarometer survey shows the highest support for the EU in the last 35 years.”

In one of Kurt Vonnegut’s novels, a lady from the American “upper crust” asks her maid to thank her even for the sunset. It is much the same with these European Parliament press releases, in which the MEPs praise themselves between the lines: look, they imply, see how well we are working. Yet, accusing them of arrogance is wide of the mark. Clearly, they cannot do otherwise; a sterile self-confidence in their own necessity and excellent work is a prerequisite for the operation of Brussels institutions. It is a peculiar kind of bureaucratic tightrope walking where the main rule is not to look down: that would make a fall inevitable. This is an art that can truly be mastered with virtuosity. Much like a good ballet dancer executing the most complex “pas” without the slightest change in facial expression, a proper eurocrat must not express even the slightest doubt about the correctness of their chosen path and mission. However, whether one likes it or not, it is in exactly this sterile and comically detached-from-reality form that European unity and solidarity are possible.

This paradox is also vividly demonstrated by the cited data. The data mentioned in the press release are formulated as answers to the question “has your country benefited from being a member of the EU?”, to which 67% of those surveyed across all EU countries currently answer in the affirmative. Moreover, this is not an “average temperature in the hospital” scenario where growing enthusiasm in some countries balances out scepticism and depression in others. No, out of a total of 28 countries, only three have seen a slight increase in scepticism over the past year—Croatia, Germany, and, comically, Great Britain, where people are apparently beginning to explain their sleepwalking Brexit decision as something sensible: well, when you haven't got it, you haven't got it. Overall, the figures have indeed improved since last year, even if the answers to other questions differ significantly. For example, when choosing whether membership of the EU is a “good” or “bad” thing, the biggest eurosceptics again turn out to be the much-suffering Italians, the newly admitted Croats, and, strangely enough, the Czechs, who have otherwise strengthened their conviction that their country has benefited from EU membership. Those are the figures.

People who juggle survey numbers with virtuosity prefer not to interpret them. To the uninitiated, it might seem odd: how is it possible for the conviction that there are positive benefits from the EU to go hand-in-hand with growing dislike for this organisation? Of course, to a humanist, it goes together quite well: receiving benefits often creates hatred towards the giver, because the very necessity of accepting something is humiliating. But only a socially uninitiated mind can think that way. Those who are happy about the benefits and those who consider the union a bad thing are not necessarily the same people, and, in any case, public opinion is only a metaphor, because only individuals think.

And yet, some of these “cognitive dissonances” are truly surprising. Currently, there are two countries in the EU whose eurosceptic governments cause serious headaches for Brussels: Poland, where Jarosław Kaczyński’s party is still leading in the polls (elections will take place there next year), and Hungary, where Viktor Orbán’s FIDESZ has just been re-elected with a huge majority. The second case is particularly telling. Unlike the Poles, the Hungarian government’s strongest opponents are the openly neo-fascist Jobbik, rather than some vegan liberals on bicycles. So, there we are: the majority of both the Polish and Hungarian public are very pro-European. Furthermore, the figures here rule out the possibility that Kaczyński’s and Orbán’s supporters have accidentally ended up outside the sample. 70% of Poles and 61% of Hungarians are convinced that their country’s membership of the EU is a good thing; moreover, this exceeds the EU average (60%) and also the level in Latvia (52%). Those who deny that their country has benefited from the EU are, in fact, laughably few—6% in Poland and 12% in Hungary, respectively (the EU average is 23%). And these people vote in huge numbers for eurosceptics?

Someone will surely argue that the leaders of Hungary and Poland are not actually eurosceptics at all. That is said to be malicious defamation; they are allegedly for a “better” and “fairer” Europe. In my opinion, that is nonsense: it is impossible to be a nationalist xenophobe and simultaneously credibly stand for some “better Europe”. My explanation is different. It seems we do not always realise the extent to which politics today has become a realm of virtual reality. Specifically, the exalted fight of Orbán and Kaczyński against eurocrats, Soros, migrants, and evil liberals is simply a show to watch, a multimedia series capable of captivating people. Furthermore, all these “eurocrats” and “liberals” in this series also diligently play their roles. Just look at this Jean-Claude Juncker—he does everything in his heart to live up to the image of the arrogant eurocrat assigned to him by the directors in Warsaw and Budapest. It is a charming phantasmagoria that allows us to turn away from our everyday problems and become participants in some global drama, where globalised, cold-blooded fat cats pick on the “common folk” with their local lifestyle and traditional values. But then the European turns away from the screen for a moment, looks around, and admits to the survey interviewer: actually, the EU does bring us a lot of good. In any case, nobody here would want to give up either the opportunity to travel and work freely in other EU countries or the money they didn't earn themselves that flows from Brussels accounts into our empty pockets. It is significant that exalted advocacy for the rights of one’s fellow citizens to live and work freely in other EU countries is part of the rhetoric of “eurosceptics” and “nationalists”. In practice, this means the right of fellow citizens to leave as freely as possible and assimilate somewhere else: to a classic nationalist, that would seem like unimaginable heresy. But we are dealing with hybrid nationalism here—so let us not rush to conclusions.

Words starting with “hybrid-” have become a kind of lexical fidget spinner—stylish, pointless, and briefly very popular. Yet, in one specific sense, this word truly describes today’s reality, in which a vividly constructed picture coexists without worries with a completely different reality. For instance, Putin “bombs” Miami in his cartoons while simultaneously trying to cosy up to Trump; Ukraine “is at war” with Russia while simultaneously happily noting an increase in trade turnover with that country; we successfully scare each other with bloodthirsty hordes of refugees and fail to notice that the flight is primarily happening from here, not to here. In short, the human head tolerates much more contradictory information than previously thought—such is this hybrid existence. One should not really hope for the picture and reality to coincide. It is better to hope that the picture will be able to hold the public’s attention effectively enough to discourage them from any practical action to put the picture into practice.
Article first published in the July 2018 issue of "Rīgas Laiks" magazine

Add a comment