Every representative of the forestry sector sees the forest broadly and in different ways. A conversation with Armands Krauze, Minister for Agriculture. Part II - Zeme un valsts

Every representative of the forestry sector sees the forest broadly and in different ways. A conversation with Armands Krauze, Minister for Agriculture. Part II

(Continuation of the conversation. Beginning: https://www.zemeunvalsts.lv/zeme-ir-bija-un-bus-latvijas-labklajibas-pamats-saruna-ar-armandu)

The Minister for Agriculture is interviewed by journalist Māris Ķirsons and Pauls Rēvelis, editor of zemeunvalsts.lv

Can we speak today of a level playing field between Latvian farmers and those in the “old” EU member states, who receive far higher subsidies while incomes and costs are similar for everyone?

The fact that Latvian farmers have always received a lower level of subsidies is not fair. It may well be one of the reasons that has held back the competitiveness of our agriculture and the processing of our produce. A number of large Latvian farms operate at a European level, although the number of small farms has dwindled, even though such a trend is not nearly as pronounced elsewhere in Europe, because the level of support there is higher. Of course, the EU is large, and land quality (measured in soil scores), climatic conditions and so on differ greatly, so in my view common EU policy should work on the principle that where conditions for agricultural production are good, the level of support is lower, and correspondingly higher in places where conditions for farming are harsher. The aim is to preserve agricultural production everywhere. It should not be the case, for example, that if climatic conditions in Latvia or Finland are harsher and yields lower compared with some country in southern Europe, agricultural activity ought to be abandoned and forestry, say, developed in its place. Such an option carries considerable risk, particularly in crisis situations: the Chernobyl nuclear power plant accident, for instance, contaminated land that until then had been used to produce agricultural output, and the Covid-19 pandemic at one point halted the flow of supplies and broke logistics chains that had been working successfully up to that moment. A country cannot be left without food, without which no person can manage! Food is just as significant a factor in national security as external security. Supplies come by road through the Suwałki corridor; if something happens there, the whole Baltic region will feel the shortage of the product concerned. There is, of course, the sea route, but in the conditions of such a conflict there is no guarantee whatsoever that shipping will be safe and that cargoes will reach their destination. This only confirms that Latvia has needed, needs and will continue to need agricultural production and food processing. If we grow grain, there will also be grain products, including bread and animal feed; if we have cows, there will be dairy products; if we raise animals for meat, there will be meat products. Relying solely on imports creates additional food supply risks in crisis situations.

Are food reserves necessary?

In Soviet times there was an entire system of warehouses in which food reserves were kept; after Latvia regained independence, this arrangement was abandoned following an assessment of food security. In most European countries, such as Germany and Sweden, food stocks are not built up, nor is there any common policy on the matter at EU level. A food stock system exists in Finland and in Switzerland (where everyone is advised to keep food stocks at home). In my view, in Latvia's situation a food stock system should be built at state level, not by buying stocks and later selling them, but by involving food processors; at the same time, households could build up at least a small share of the stocks in their own homes. The state could create a system in which food producers increase the volume of produce held in their warehouses and the state pays those companies for doing so. For example, a food processor holds four weeks' worth of goods in its warehouse, whereas under a food reserve system it would hold six to eight weeks' worth, or three to six months' worth, depending on the produce. In conditions of disrupted logistics, such a system would make it possible to survive for a considerable time. Of course, such a system costs something, but that is not and cannot be an argument for doing nothing, particularly in light of the geopolitical risks that have grown in recent years.

What is the situation in Latvian forestry, which is just as significant a land user as agriculture?

As an agronomist, I look at forestry much as foresters do, because the forest is and will remain a very significant resource. Unlike farmers, who sow in autumn or spring and harvest a few months later, the forestry cycle lasts decades. To obtain a sawlog, a tree must first be planted and tended, and only after several decades can the harvest be taken. Forestry in Latvia is at a high level, because forest scientists have done an enormous amount of work that makes it possible not only to grow higher-quality, higher-yielding tree seedlings, but they have also drawn up recommendations for making forestry more efficient.

Alongside forestry, the timber industry has also shown good development, even though in the 1990s there was a great deal of talk about unprocessed sawlogs being exported from Latvia. Today the situation is considerably different, although roundwood is still exported, for which there is at least for now no corresponding processing capacity, but I hope such capacity will be built and in place within the next few years. Forestry cannot yield only sawlogs or veneer logs; alongside them there will also be small-diameter roundwood, for which, although processing capacity exists, its volume does not cover the annual volumes of wood harvested. Several significant wood product manufacturing projects are currently at various stages of development, and they will not only increase the sector's added value and export earnings but will also create new jobs and larger tax payments into the state coffers.

Although in certain respects Latvia is ahead of Sweden, a major power in this sector, foresters working in Latvia have far less freedom than in the Scandinavian countries (and not only there). Latvia has retained a peculiar Soviet-era system that arose under a planned economy, when there was a need for roundwood of a particular diameter and it was accordingly calculated how long a tree of each species had to grow before being felled; at that time there were also none of the glue-laminated timber structures that are so popular now. Unlike in France or Sweden, in Latvia there is a fear at the political level of giving private forest owners the freedom to work in their own forests. Oddly enough, these communist-era attitudes have been joined by environmental organisations that cultivate a fallacy: as soon as forest owners have freedom, they will pick up a saw or an axe and cut everything down. This situation showed itself harshly during the outbreak of the European spruce bark beetle. A forest owner may not fell a spruce stand because it has reached neither the felling age nor the required diameter, even though a bark beetle infestation is clearly forecastable and inevitable. Once the bark beetle has done its “work”, the stand in question can be felled, but the owner will receive considerably less for the wood obtained from it than if the stand had been felled untouched by the insects. I do not understand the logic! The Scandinavian countries are invoked in Latvia as a benchmark of high welfare to be emulated, yet at the same time we are unwilling to give foresters freedom of action. As soon as we urge that forest policy in Latvia be shaped along Scandinavian lines, environmental organisations object, because that is supposedly “very bad” practice.

How realistic is it to make forestry in Latvia freer and more favourable to owners, given that there will always be opponents of such a step?

Forest sector policy is based on policy guidelines. Work is currently under way on drafting such a document, because the previous guidelines for the forest and related sectors (2015–2020) expired in 2020; nothing has been done in the years since, even though work on this document essentially should have begun back in 2018. I inherited this situation as minister. I hope the sector will support my vision of greater freedom of action for foresters. Of course, all interested parties will be invited to take part in discussing the draft guidelines for the forest and related sectors, regardless of the position they represent.

On this question, which is very significant precisely in the context of regional policy but where resistance appears, is the Ministry of Agriculture not left on its own? Both VARAM and the Ministry of Finance ought to have an interest in the sector's development.

In my view, the ice has been broken on this question too, because quite recently a Cabinet of Ministers sitting approved both the maximum permissible felling estimate (in hectares) for 2026–2030 in forests owned by the Latvian state and the informative report on habitat mapping, which specialists from the Ministry of Agriculture discussed with VARAM specialists for a very long time. As a result of the work of both the ministers and the ministries' specialists, a kind of balance was found. A limit has been set: 30% of the territory will have various protection statuses, which will ensure the preservation of natural values. Interestingly, this 30% threshold has already been reached (it stands at 30.6%), yet the requirements for a strict protection regime covering 10% have not been met (it is only 6.2%). It is very important to mention that the agreement approved by the government provides that if there is a wish to add new protected areas, the existing ones are reviewed. Foresters will finally have clarity: 30% for natural values and biodiversity, and 70% for economic use. Environmental organisations often insist that absolutely everything must be protected — 100% of it — including potential natural values; logic dictates protecting what is of the highest value, all the more so since everything in nature changes.

An example: last year I visited a habitat within the territory of the Gauja National Park (boreal (old-growth) forest with a herbaceous ground layer) where nothing may be done, but the bark beetle has “done a good job” — the spruces have died off and fallen over; the aforementioned habitat no longer exists, yet “it must be protected all the same”. Unfortunately, the fact is ignored that as the condition and species of the trees growing in the stand change, after some time the ground layer will change too and other plants will naturally take the place of the herbaceous vegetation. Environmental organisations want literally to preserve natural values in aspic, in the hope that nothing will change, even though in nature that is impossible. In my view, if a habitat no longer exists in nature, the status of the particular site (territory) should be removed and management allowed there. What is more, the forest owner in question should have been allowed to remove the dead trees earlier, because every process in nature has its positive consequences. When a forest is felled, raspberries appear after a certain time, and as the trees grow they are replaced by other plant species. I would stress (and this will sound surprising to environmental organisations) that many natural values arise as a result of human economic activity. Foresters are not destroyers of nature but its friends — environmental organisations are unwilling to accept this.

Should the commercially usable forests owned by the Latvian state, currently scattered across three ministries — Defence, Agriculture, and Smart Administration and Regional Development — not be concentrated in one place, under the management of the joint-stock company “Latvijas valsts meži” (LVM)? Would the additional resources available each year not thereby be an excellent opportunity to dispel concerns about a future decline in the availability of wood resources, while at the same time yielding larger dividends for the state budget?

The best solution would be for all commercially usable forests owned by the Latvian state to come under LVM's management, while protected forests would be transferred to VARAM's remit and managed by the Nature Conservation Agency. In this way, an additional roughly 750,000 cubic metres of wood would be available from forests owned by the Latvian state that are currently all but inaccessible to wood users. The state budget, which needs additional funds for a great many areas, could receive dividends from the use of these resources. I can say that the first steps in this direction have already been taken, because the leadership of the Ministry of Agriculture and the Ministry of Defence (the state secretaries) are discussing the use of forests under the defence sector's remit for economic purposes, particularly since soldiers must be able to carry out their tasks successfully not only in forests but also in clearings and young stands.

In the context of security, would it be worthwhile for the Latvian state to purchase the land put up for sale that belongs to the Swedish forest owners' cooperative “Södra”?

This is a question of strategic significance. It is in progress — LVM, the manager of Latvia's state forests, has contacted the seller; I cannot disclose further comments or details, as this is commercial information. At the same time, consultations are under way on how significant these properties are for Latvia's national security, since sizeable areas of land are located in Latgale near the eastern border. From an economic perspective too, these forests are a significant asset that ought to remain in economic circulation. It would not be good if these areas ended up in the ownership of parties who would turn them into CO₂ storage, from which there would be no economic benefit either for the Latvian state or for domestic timber processors. This question is made all the more topical by the matters being discussed at EU level as to who acquires CO₂ sequestration rights — the country in whose territory the property in question is located, or the landowner, who may also be a foreign national and may credit the sequestration to their company operating in another country. Of course, in such a situation there is a risk that large European companies could buy up forests and bogs in Latvia, turning them into their own contribution to CO₂ sequestration, with no benefit whatsoever to Latvia. Perhaps in such a situation Latvia could no longer keep as many dairy cows or beef cattle as it does now, to say nothing of preserving industry, which would generate some emissions, and any development of production would also have to be forgotten. Otherwise the Latvian state will have to buy CO₂ emission allowances, and as a result of rising market prices we may have to spend hundreds of millions (perhaps even a billion) euros every year, which also has to be earned somewhere.

How could the purchase of these areas be carried out? Perhaps by setting up an LVM subsidiary? Could the money be raised from Latvian pension funds, perhaps by issuing bonds or shares on the stock exchange?

It is clear that neither the Latvian state budget nor LVM has the kind of money that would be needed to buy the forests “Södra” is selling in Latvia. The only solution would be to set up a separate company whose participants would be the pension funds operating in Latvia, the forest sector — foresters, timber processors — entrepreneurs from other spheres, banks, including “Altum”, and whose management would be entrusted to LVM. The shares of such a company could be listed on the stock exchange, because I think there could be great interest among people in becoming part-owners of 2% of Latvia's territory. I will do everything I can, but I cannot claim that this plan will be carried out.

Today there is talk at many levels about reducing bureaucracy. Do you see opportunities to reduce bureaucracy in the sectors you oversee?

There is no doubt that public administration must be efficient, but it must be remembered how many people work in public administration and are directly tied to the functions laid down for them in directives, regulations, laws and rules. First and foremost this means that there are too many functions, not too many people working in public administration. For example, in order for a forest owner to do anything in their forest, they need a forest inventory plan and a felling permit, which cost money and take time to obtain, while the responsible authority — the State Forest Service — has to check and control it all, which requires staff, time and money. Essentially we come back to what was said above: we want to control and restrict too much.

Another example — the felling of trees outside forests. If a silver spruce grows on a person's private property (next to the house) and has tilted and threatens to fall on the house or a neighbour's structures, an application must be written to the local council, which requires an expert opinion, following which the council's commission decides whether or not to allow the tree to be cut down. I know of a case where a person submitted an application in July and by October it still had not been considered, while at the same time such trees posed and continue to pose a risk of substantial damage to property, as last year's August storm demonstrated. Meanwhile, outside populated areas that are not national parks, all trees may be felled next to one's private house without any permits or fees, yet to environmental organisations' great surprise, private homeowners in these places do not cut down everything around their houses. Paradoxical. Absurd. I will initiate a change to the current arrangement so that trees on private property next to a house — anywhere, whether in populated areas or on individual farmsteads — can be cut down without permits or fees, with the exception of parks, public gardens and the like.

Add a comment