An industry story. How to collect more tax without significantly increasing the national debt - Zeme un valsts

An industry story. How to collect more tax without significantly increasing the national debt

Over the past 30 years the forest sector has become a cornerstone of the Latvian economy. It not only "brings in" money from abroad by exporting a wide variety of timber products, but is also a very significant employer, particularly in rural regions where there are effectively no alternative jobs. If one were to "remove", purely speculatively, from the employment figures all the people who work in timber processing and forestry companies or who provide services to them, the result would be very bleak indeed. In essence, the forest sector both sustains itself and provides work for other spheres that need employees just the same. A kind of "echo" effect.

The forest sector is a significant earner and payer of taxes. Calculations show that in 2024 companies in the sector paid almost 391 million euros in taxes (not counting value added tax); in 2018 the figure was around 223 million euros, which means an increase of 168 million euros. That is a great deal.

Yes, there are companies whose total volume of taxes paid differs, which is related to the specific nature of their operations; for the most part the labour taxes paid by such companies are measured in the hundreds of thousands or even millions of euros. It is possible to calculate how much tax money is "brought in" by one cubic metre of timber harvested in the forest. If last year we harvested 16 million m³ of timber, on average one cubic metre "brought in" 24.5 euros to the state purse in labour taxes alone, and once value added tax, real estate tax and corporate income tax payments are added, the sum rises considerably. For example, in 2024 AS "Latvijas valsts meži" topped up the state budget with almost 49 million euros in taxes, plus impressive dividends, which (perhaps) made it possible not to raise the rate of some tax and provided extra money for national security, the health sector and so on.

Despite the fact that the forest sector is the very foundation of rural employment, there are still a number of people who proudly call themselves "friends of nature" ("environmental activists" and other fine terms) and do a great deal to reduce the number of jobs and the volume of taxes paid by companies in the countryside. (It should be added that these same people are ready to demand taxpayers' money for anything at all.) Unbelievable, but true! How do they do it? By laying it on thick about biodiversity problems and about excessive timber harvesting volumes, persistently calling them "deforestation", even though Latvia has no such problem. There are quite enough people (some, it seems, lack knowledge and understanding and rely blindly on authorities; others are shrewd, deftly using the first group in order to secure funding and not only that...) who once again go "looking for the Congo" in Latvia, provoking loud outbursts from a minority of society in order to "force" decision-makers to respond with new restrictions or bans on economic activity in forests. It is a peculiar sort of struggle: how to make forest management harder, how to prevent timber from being harvested for the manufacture of industrial products and high value added goods. All of this is pursued through various new bans and restrictions on the extraction of timber resources. Paradoxically, this is happening at a moment when defence is a major national priority, one requiring substantial additional resources. Moreover, it is very important to recall that those who want to restrict economic activity do not come forward with proposals about what to do instead, how to earn money and so on.

The "security billion"

Forest sector entrepreneurs have come forward with an initiative on how to collect more tax without significantly increasing the national debt (because the money would be earned, not borrowed), namely, to increase the output of the forest sector over a period of 3-5 years by raising the annual volume of timber harvested in state forests by approximately 2 million m³ (or ~15% of the average volume over the past 5 years). The positive impact of the initiative on the budget would be roughly 200-300 million euros a year (direct and indirect taxes plus increased dividends from the management of state forests). Over a 3-5 year period that would amount to around 1 billion euros — or, symbolically, a "security billion" from the forest sector. The sector can see that the state could gain more; this requires a degree of mobilisation of timber resources. Can it be done? It can — this is not science fiction! What would need to happen?

Fear of acting

The commercially usable forests owned by the Latvian state, currently "scattered" between three ministries — Defence, Agriculture, and Smart Administration and Regional Development — should be concentrated in one place, under the management of AS "Latvijas valsts meži" (LVM). As a result, with no changes to legislation but within the maximum permissible felling quota for state forests, timber producers could obtain each year at least an additional one million cubic metres of timber in final felling and several hundred thousand more in thinning. These additional resources, available annually, would be an excellent opportunity to dispel concerns about a future decline in the availability of timber resources, while at the same time bringing larger dividends into the state budget. Of course, this solution alone may not be enough, but the second phase of timber resource mobilisation could be the transfer of commercially usable forests owned by local authorities into the management of "Latvijas valsts meži". Local authorities own tens of thousands of hectares of forest in which, very often, nothing happens at all. An earlier assessment of how local authorities were getting on with forest management revealed an absence of forest management plans, which meant that valuable assets were being left to their own devices. On closer examination, it had to be concluded that often this was not an unwillingness to manage valuable assets — forests — but rather a fear of acting, because reproaches might follow: "they're cutting it all down"... Presumably nobody who wants to be elected to a local authority wants to hear the words "bad for nature" directed at them. In total, local authorities own or lawfully possess approximately 122,714 ha, or 4% of the country's total forest area. A performance audit by the State Audit Office into local authorities' handling of forest resources concluded that local authorities do not manage the forest resources they own in an economically sound way, failing to derive the greatest possible benefit from the stewardship of these valuable public assets. This only confirms that the question of transferring commercially usable local authority forests to LVM for management is a legitimate one.

And once again, BUT!

There is also a third possibility for mobilising timber resources, and it could well be the most difficult of all — how to persuade the private owner of a forest that has reached felling age to go to their property and harvest the timber. While the first points in the timber mobilisation action plan can in a sense be implemented by administrative means, in the context of privately owned forests what is needed is the granting of greater economic freedom and additional motivation (the creation of it).

One might ask whether timber resources are needed at all, all the more so given that forest sector export revenues in the first half of 2025 have shrunk, if only within the margin of statistical error. Granted, it is a negligible decline against the background of 1.7 billion euros earned from abroad, but one has to reckon with the fact that the forest sector's import spending has risen. Let us remember that Latvia had a comparatively large number of companies that used timber products originating in Russia and Belarus (~1.5-2 million m³) to manufacture their own goods, and following the introduction of sanctions these are "out of the game". The European market needs timber products and, if the raw materials for them can be obtained in Latvia, that means additional money for foresters and for everyone connected with the sector. In fact everyone would gain — the state, forest sector companies and employees, and in essence everyone living in the countryside; jobs in the private sector are the basis for there being any need for nurseries, schools, health centres, community centres, and also shops, canteens, cafés and the like. And once again one has to say: BUT... Seven years have passed since the so-called nature census, yet the problems have not been solved. Nature was counted, more or less, but "afterwards" is still "afterwards". All the more so given that the habitat inventory cost approximately 9.5 million euros, which by Latvian standards is a fairly impressive sum, so it is no wonder that there was enough money for a philosophical survey on "What nature means to a Latvian", for hiring a PR firm, for unveiling the "Great Nature Counters", and for other activities, not to mention roughly one hundred and seventy nature experts who were guaranteed work and pay for several years. These friends of "nature and the state" did not succeed in their wish to withdraw an impressive quantity of forests from economic circulation while they were in the timber harvesting cycle, but a great deal of fuss was kicked up. In short, what is happening can be judged as the creation of unfair competition for those working and doing business in Latvia. There is also the question of the economic return on the millions spent, because for that kind of money one could build a comparatively large production plant with several dozen new jobs. Is it really better if there are no new jobs and the existing ones are eliminated?

One single question

Undeniably, there have been, are and most likely will be questions about how (how effectively, how usefully) taxpayers' money is spent. Unfortunately, as the twists and turns around "Rail Baltica" show, nobody is accountable and nobody knows how much this "project of the century" will cost or whether it will be built at all, even though the state lacks money for things far more important to society. It sounds paradoxical, but the news agency LETA reports that "former transport minister Tālis Linkaits prevented the government from being fully informed about the increase in the costs of the Rail Baltica railway project." Specifically, the Ministry of Transport states that in March 2022 it had prepared an informative report containing information about the cost increase in the Rail Baltica project, but, as the ministry notes, the further progress of this report was halted by the transport minister of the time, T. Linkaits, who later submitted to the government an informative report setting out lower estimates of the project's costs. The costs of the main route in Latvia have risen sevenfold, to 8.7 billion euros, the State Audit Office revealed. How is one to judge this particular minister's attitude and working style overall? Is it total irresponsibility?! ... Some politicians "know how" to spend money; they ought to learn how to earn it. There is no shortage of examples of what entrepreneurs have earned being spent simply and thoughtlessly. The essence of the problem is that those taking the relevant decisions either do not understand (which one would rather not believe) or place too much trust in certain "doers" and "advisers". In the current geopolitical situation the state budget cannot afford to lose a single job in the forest sector or in the other sectors connected with land management — food and peat. Political decision-makers and those who prepare their decisions must understand how large a contribution to the state budget a single job generates, directly and, all the more so, indirectly. Unfortunately, the fewer jobs there are, the fewer people will live in Latvia, and at the same time they will have to pay higher taxes.

The forest sector can fulfil the role of a "strategic reserve" in the Latvian economy as a whole. What is needed? Only an understanding of the situation on the part of decision-makers and, accordingly, decisions based on one single question — are we in Latvia ready to make use of the assets that society has at its disposal?

It is precisely in connection with the forest sector and related industries that a fundamental problem has come to the fore in Latvia, one encountered fairly regularly by almost the entire business environment and which the political environment all too conspicuously pretends not to notice — seeing and raising only individual details in the overall picture, while forgetting how they are connected. While a large proportion of Latvia's entrepreneurs are already thinking about 2040 and 2050, a whole range of sufficiently active people are on the one hand ready to demand money from every ministry, because "that's how it is in Finland", "in every democratic country...", "to safeguard independence" and so on, while at the same time doing quite enough to ensure that there is less money in the state purse. In effect, with the active support of the mass media, a mythical image of the forest sector entrepreneur is being created in society — someone who is bound to want to disturb, halt, destroy or spoil something. Moreover, activists often stir themselves only once one of the entrepreneurs has come forward with a logical proposal that the state (and therefore all of us) needs. Until then the activists are silent, but the moment a proposal is voiced, retired doctors and publishers, professional theatre directors, people who pride themselves on their doctorates and so on set to work. Part of society has already been deliberately taught that "activism is a good thing", which one could hardly object to, except... If we do not develop manufacturing, do not become energy-independent, do not build housing, restrict grain farming and so on — what exactly are you offering instead? How shall we earn a living? How shall we strengthen security? To this question there is usually one answer: "Our task is to object, yours is to think up other options. If we do not like option 2, 3 or 4, we shall continue the fight." Arguably, the constant restructuring of Latvia's education system and an acute shortage of professional teaching staff have left a lasting mark on the judgement of at least part of society, and that judgement is becoming an ever more fleeting phenomenon in a situation where problems must be solved today, not left to the next Saeima or to unknown "others".

Add a comment