Introductory note from zemeunvalsts.lv. A large delegation from the Latvian forest sector is currently visiting Gdańsk in Poland to learn about the latest developments in the Polish forest sector. Some of these developments are important for us to know about as well.
The audit of Poland's State Forests (Lasy Państwowe, hereafter also referred to as the company or the State Forests), which is examining legal and financial matters, will run until the end of 2024. The Polish State Forests have announced changes, but the company is still being criticised over nature conservation issues.
The audit began in January this year, when the company's management changed and Witold Koss took up the post of director general. According to him, the audit is a response to public criticism of the State Forests' activities to date; in addition to the directorate general, the regional directorates, forest districts and State Forests enterprises will also be audited. Preliminary audit results were announced on 4 April this year.
What the audit has established so far about spending in the State Forests in recent years points to large-scale squandering of public money, said Deputy Minister of Climate and Environment Mikołaj Dorożała when presenting the conclusions, pointing to a series of irregularities that occurred under the company's previous management and the previous Polish government. The information made public contains accusations that State Forests resources were used for political purposes linked to the interests of Sovereign Poland, the party that controlled the company. "Between 2021 and 2023 there was extensive, unprecedented misappropriation of State Forests funds," the statement says.
The auditors examined, for example, paid publications in the media financed by the State Forests; these were chosen in a way that was neither objective nor economically sound. The advertising content was produced by State Forests employees rather than by contractors, and the majority of the publications promoted politicians from a single party, write the authors of the preliminary findings after the first quarter of the audit, putting the cost of this activity at 8-10 million zloty over the period from 2020 to 2023. The irregularities also involve the allocation of 65 million zloty for the production of 2,000 advertising boards promoting forest management and nature conservation, and local events organised by the State Forests information centre, such as picnics or a ball.
The "estimated value of the losses" in this case is around 20 million zloty. The auditors also mention funding allocated for repairs to municipal roads that was intended to be used for political advertising, and the financing of the former director general's election campaign. The auditors' clients claim the losses run into millions of zloty, taking into account similar advertising expenditure on other candidates connected with forestry. The harsh conclusions also concern the State Forests' employment policy, which is accused of nepotism and party favouritism, the economically unjustified purchase of a palace and park for 12 million zloty, and an attempt to sell a property in Gdynia at a discount. The minor irregularities mentioned in the initial findings include unclear records of business trips and of the former press officer's working hours, and the introduction of new uniforms without prior consultation.
More than 700 million zloty in profit in 2021
The State Forests' financial policy during the period covered by the audit was also examined in the report Lasy na sprzedaż, published in March 2023 by the organisation Pracownia na rzecz Wszystkich Istot. According to the data cited in the report, the Polish State Forests manage more than 75% of Poland's forest area and obtain around 95% of its timber. Recent years, the report notes, have been a period of material prosperity for the company: in 2021 it recorded a net profit of more than 700 million zloty, more than three times higher than in 2008. Around 90% of the State Forests' revenue was expected to come from timber sales. In 2021 this revenue reached PLN 8.9 billion. The report's authors criticised the State Forests for imprecise and arbitrary criteria for disbursing Forest Fund resources, for marginalising nature conservation expenditure (which in 2021 was supposed to make up 0.5% of revenue), for excessive internal bureaucracy and for a lack of transparency in how the profits earned were redistributed. In the case of the State Forests, the total of direct taxes, levies and dividend-like payments per cubic metre of timber is more than twice as low as the average for other large self-financing state forest enterprises in the EU, the report's conclusions state.
Breaking the moratorium
On the day the audit results were announced, 4 April this year, Pracownia na rzecz Wszystkich Istot published a statement saying that the State Forests had breached the logging moratorium. As a reminder: on 8 January this year the Ministry of Climate and Environment (MKiŚ) announced, as a temporary precautionary measure while sustainable solutions are developed, the suspension or reduction of forest management in 10 locations in Poland. One of them was the spa forests near Iwonicz Zdrój in the Krosno district, where logging (thinning) was carried out despite the ban; this was discovered at the end of March this year by residents belonging to the local organisation Wspólny Las. The authors of the statement point out that the ministry's order was breached. It is not only the law that has been broken, but also the social contract. For forest lovers, the exclusion of the 10 areas from logging was a historic moment; breaking the moratorium shows that the State Forests are disregarding Polish society, continuing to act from a position of strength and have made no real changes. "We contacted residents of the Iwonicz-Zdrój municipality, who are unhappy because they have been trying for a long time to get the spa forests in their region better protected," comments Sylwia Szczutkowska (Sylwia Szczutkowska, a biologist and activist with the organisation Pracownia na rzecz Wszystkich Istot). She adds that, following the announcement of the moratorium, the State Forests directorate general instructed the regional directorates of the State Forests not to take any steps aimed at granting further reductions in logging volumes. That instruction froze the discussions that had been taking place at local level. "As a result, at operational level we face a ban on carrying out work to reduce logging, while at the level of communication the State Forests declare openness and a readiness for dialogue. There is an obvious contradiction between these decisions," says S. Szczutkowska.
"Closer-to-nature forestry"
The "Pracownia" representative also points out that nature conservation standards in forests must be higher not only in the 20% most valuable forests, which are ultimately to be permanently excluded from logging – as declared in the coalition agreement that laid the foundations for today's government – but also in "ordinary" commercial forests.
What is meant here is "closer-to-nature forestry", which involves abandoning clear-cuts, which have a negative impact on biodiversity and are widely used by the State Forests. Statistics show that 90 hectares of forest are lost this way every day. In addition, preference should be given to natural regeneration rather than to ploughing, fencing and afforestation by planting single tree species. Closer-to-nature forestry also means abandoning the use of chemicals that have a negative impact on birds and bats. "These are only the most important directions; the point of this set of practices is to reduce the negative impact of forest management on nature (in the forest)," explains Sylwia Szczutkowska.
The importance of legislation
Promoting the principles of sustainable forest management is among the objectives of the international certification organisation Forest Stewardship Council (FSC). As part of its "new policy", the Polish State Forests announced a willingness to enter into dialogue with the FSC in order to restore certification across all the forests they manage. On 26 March this year a statement was published about a "clear opportunity" to return to the FSC system in the Białystok Regional Directorate of the State Forests, intended to meet the demands of the timber industry. Asked to assess the importance of certification, Sylwia Szczutkowska explains that mandatory legal solutions are more effective for nature conservation. "We do not have time to wait for someone's goodwill. Certain standards must become mandatory by becoming part of the general rules. We want the State Forests to change the way they manage forests and to submit to public scrutiny as well. We will go into the consultations with such a programme," S. Szczutkowska said. The meeting announced by Poland's Ministry of the Environment for 22-23 April this year is intended to launch consultations with all interested parties – foresters, representatives of the timber industry, local authorities and the public – in order to develop sustainable changes to Poland's forest management system that better protect nature.
Are the recommendations still relevant?
In an interview with the newspaper Teraz Środowisko, Sylwia Szczutkowska argues that the results of the audit of the Polish state forests confirm what the organisation she leads had said previously – namely, that funds obtained by the Polish State Forests were also spent on supporting particular Sovereign Poland members of parliament, as well as on other superfluous (unnecessary) expenditure that had no economic justification and was unrelated to forest management and nature conservation. The scale of these events (unjustified spending of money) shows how urgent and necessary a serious reform of state forest management in Poland is. At the same time, S. Szczutkowska has objections to the current management of the State Forests, which in her view has not made real changes to the company's internal organisation or to the forest management process. "Of course, the style of communication has changed, and today the State Forests express openness to change. Unfortunately, however, apart from positive rhetoric, no other changes are yet visible," claims S. Szczutkowska, adding that the recommendations for specific reforms contained in last year's report still stand.
What are they? Representatives of Pracownia na rzecz Wszystkich Istot recommended increasing the funding of nature conservation from the money earned by the state forests (for example, by obliging the state forests to channel 5% of their revenue to national parks), increasing financial oversight of the institution and preventing funds from being used for purposes unrelated to forests, rationalising employment within the company, introducing ministerial oversight, and raising the rates paid to subcontractors for providing forestry services. Sylwia Szczutkowska also speaks of the need to amend the Forest Act currently in force. Amendments to the act should not concern only the financial management of the state forests. Measures related to nature conservation are also needed, such as the introduction of a strict system of species protection for animals, plants and fungi during forestry operations. "The new act must also take into account the EU Court of Justice ruling that nature conservation organisations are permitted to challenge forest management plans in court," she adds.



